Topic: 100BTC bet on pirate default against RoloTonyBrownTown (Read 4931 times)

Matthew = dust and this whole thing was a ploy to get 100 btc. 

To be honest I think Matthew has truly taken you for a ride, but good on you for staying honest.

I should come out just about even after it all.   In hindsight, the Dust bet was a daft one, but I got caught up in the excitement,  and figured Matthew must be pretty damn confident to put all that money on the line.   I didn't really consider that he'd use some (tenuous) loophole to get out of it.    I clearly have too much faith in people as a whole.

Still,  I still think his initial reasoning for the bet was a good one.   I stand by that.

Serious question:
Given that you were heavily invested in pirate, bought up bitcoinmax accounts and had this bet, how much have you lost in this whole thing?
I hate to see people losing significant cash...

As I said, I'm not holding you to the bet. Honestly I just wanted you do stop shilling for someone who STILL has yet to pay anyone back. If you decide to donate, great. If you don't, I won't even mention it.

Hah,  yes fair enough    Still,  doesn't stop some trying to use vagueness to get out of these things.

But yeah,  Escrow should be mandatory for these things regardless.

I'll shoot the 5BTC to that address shortly,  I'm at work and need to remote into my bitcoin machine.   Don't panic if it's not there in the next few hours

That's pretty man of you...considering you had no choice...

Thanks Dust, RoloTonyBrownTown, and Themos, for demonstrating how to do bets in Bitcoin-land if betting on this and that is your thing.

Huh, that could work. If you wish, send funds to 1BTC1oo1J3MEt5SFj74ZBcF2Mk97Aah4ac, along with a transaction #, and we'll add you to the list of donors 

Ooh, send it to the Bitcoin 100!

Ah Rassah,  I totally forgot about that.   I agreed to pay up if I lost,  so I still will if you want to post an address.

Even though I've won my 5BTC bet due to Pirate/Matthew's default, I'm withdrawing my bet anyway. Rolo got screwed well enough as it is.

Agreed.    Matthew may have weasled out of his bet,  but I'll be sticking to mine.

Buy something nice with it Dust

This was cool.. GooD job guys

Escrow!

Good to see someone honour their agreement.

That was quite the pun

I guess you are pretty short on BTC now

Congrats to dust!

Funds received.

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

Sent. Congrats!
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iF4EAREIAAYFAlBM5RcACgkQxlVWk9q1kecvWAD/UWYclsP3mS6JKrOxPbg7RPLH
bYhqA9zj89HrG4u0KUYA/1K13ZMjgXRZB1wr4Wl5C2mUTeqiQtkPVOp49oPTIAnP
=23t6
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Sweet.

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA512

Theymos, please send the coins to 1QHLpbjkC5Nz5jNFG15eEWK5MVwDGjhjig
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
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=FL5U
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Congratulations to dust, and thank you for putting your money where your mouth was.

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

Dust wins. Both Matthew and pirateat40 conceded defeat in their respective bets. Where shall I send the 200 BTC, dust?
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iF4EAREIAAYFAlBMysUACgkQxlVWk9q1keeuygEAxO91bXn2o8H3JrNV36sEQ0yA
HEjUGe3GDkoaMY/Ii10BALSseTL/FA/ZGKIrPVXXkYZdqML+7/GJmxBDjS9r4oH1
=8s0i
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

True, that would be the situation if he actually planned not to pay back since the beginning, rather than just being unable to keep up.

In any case what looks most possible is that these 500K don't exist, and it's a much lower number, around 100K. That amount is not enough to tank the market even if dumped at once.

I'm thinking some people only bought bitcoins to invest with Pirate.  So if they get their coins back they'll likely want their "real money" (as they see it) back.

Indeed.  Everyone seems to think that as soon as people get their Pirate money back (assuming they do), they'll immediately sell.   Well, why?    The only reason I see for doing that is because you think everyone else is going to sell, which is obviously daft

Anyway, I won't be selling mine if they're returned.  I'm long BTC.

I don't.  I think that if it's a scam then pirate will have been selling excess bitcoins all along rather than dumping them all at the end.  His lenders didn't have that option.

Lol...
Really at this point even theymos being the administrator doesn't mean he can re-write history. That's one of the main functions of PGP signatures -- anyone can dig this message up and prove theymos wrote it.

for the record. 

Why do you think Pirate would keep BTCs for longer than his creditors? If he's on the run he will need fiat. Anything else other than the previous lock will push prices down, but difficulty is way up and block reward halving is closer.

I'm buying with every significant drop.

No one long on BTC thinks that way.

Seems to me this isn't really even money (in dollars), in that if Pirate pays out, there will be a flood of people selling their proceeds, pushing the price of BTC down.  So dust either wins a lot or loses a little?

For the suspicious, theymos' signature checks out.
Also, I love the comment about bitlane.

This is the way it should be done.

Hopefully not Zip.A. (Too soon?)

We've both bet 100.  2BTC is Theymos' fee.  The winner gets 200BTC.  The loser gets zip.

so your actually betting 101 btc (escrow fee included) to win 100 plus 99 btc back?

Do that here:  https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=101751.500

I'm maxed out  

well, that explains it then. All those spare brain cells are driving you mad. I have the same affliction. I always tell my m8's I'm 'high on life' ;p They think I'm a nutter....

Nah, I don't drink. Ironically, the reason is because I like to keep a clear head all the time and as in touch with reality is possible. (Did I make you laugh?  )

Damn, I'm really tempted to throw a couple hundred btc at this...

I finalized the OP and clearsigned it.

haha, if you don't win, you're gonna be asking Vlad to buy your beers for the next decade. ;p

oh, and @thread Test Your Might

If I win, I'll buy everyone popcorn. If not, can I have some popcorn guys?

Rolo vs dust, round 1 / 12 begin !

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

04113fc2af8442cba99c3771f36b2bdb25ed784fcf6b95ac3ee73574356744c8
170d75335d2bb47fa1e5bcb8f9a3040aca993bbeae9711471e3d8446ba30b66f

Received. Good luck!
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iF4EAREIAAYFAlA0b1oACgkQxlVWk9q1kefVPAD/d0U4F2SGK62WnV/r9Oc9vBrM
PAA0OI92sEsZ+O4hXqYBAJ3oj9mOmxpfORwlSHL/YZ+fiNVaNAAIsx8XIPWVDlZn
=09NW
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Well, that depends on how much they're worth when all this is over   That could be $100 or $1500 I guess

On its way gents:

txid:  170d75335d2bb47fa1e5bcb8f9a3040aca993bbeae9711471e3d8446ba30b66f

101BTC sent, txid: 04113fc2af8442cba99c3771f36b2bdb25ed784fcf6b95ac3ee73574356744c8

100 Bitcoin!?

This is insane. :p.

haha, normally I don't thread camp. =) This one just happened to be on top the last few times I hit show unread posts. ;p

Thanks Theymos (and Panda again ).  I'll send that through shortly.

quoted for record

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA256

I'll escrow for 1 BTC from each of you. Each of you should send 101 BTC to the appropriate address:

RoloTonyBrownTown: 14mDQDopvsBCqvYFPqDFmE9MuHbBsXt1t9
dust: 1Pomp8HMtZrEVYKjHr7wkAEgxTzLdoze1u

Rules:
"The outcome of Matthew N. Wright's bet thread, https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/im-giving-100-roi-away-to-anyone-who-thinks-pirate-is-a-fraud-101751, will decide the winner. In the event that Matthew N. Wright fails to conclusively decide a winner, nanotube's ruling on Vandroiy's bet against Pirateat40 will decide the winner. In the case that nanotube's ruling is used, a failure to pay bitlane will not be considered a default."
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iF4EAREIAAYFAlA0a40ACgkQxlVWk9q1keeeVwEAlwvNObWQyjh8xfvysdM0gMZs
qFwRT+4Bfb5XtgUTqroA/jgHmOk8WTZWhXfxQAUXpj9d8AaUDN0uKM1F7KeI8uqx
=mCOQ
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Coolz.

(thanks Panda)

quoted for record.

good luck u 2.

Theymos has agreed to act as escrow for this bet for a fee of 2BTC.  RolyTonyBrownTown and I will each send 101BTC to an address provided by theymos.

Hi

Confirmed.  Just to clarify, we're keeping this simple, so if it's decided that Matt has won his bet, then I win this one.  If it's decided that Matt loses his bet, I lose this one.

Dust, with regards to Escrow, can I recommend Graet?   He's a well established member of the community, has plenty to lose (pools etc), and he previously provided Escrow for when I was selling some BFL singles a month or two back.  He was very professional, and he's a nice dude.    Shoot him a PM if you like and have a chat, see what you think.   

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

I, forum member dust, am betting 100BTC at even odds against forum member RoloTonyBrownTown that pirate will fail to pay back his lenders in full.

The outcome of Matthew N. Wright's bet thread, https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/im-giving-100-roi-away-to-anyone-who-thinks-pirate-is-a-fraud-101751, will decide the winner.
In the event that Matthew N. Wright fails to conclusively decide a winner, nanotube's ruling on Vandroiy's bet against Pirateat40 will decide the winner.
In the case that nanotube's ruling is used, a failure to pay bitlane will not be considered a default.

Theymos will hold both bettors coins until the outcome is decided.
Each bettor has paid theymos a 1 BTC fee for acting as escrow.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
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=88YO
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Aug. 27 2012 edit: Matthew's precise date and terms for his bet