2013-02-24 Daily Bell: Robert Wenzel Interview

cypherdoc

legendary

Activity: 1764

Merit: 1002

Quote from: imanikin on February 25, 2013, 06:55:37 PM

I wonder whether this Wenzel would or has said that gold is not money now because people value it in their heads in terms of fiat quantities? Huh

If he hasn't, i dare him to say that during one of his GoldMoney interviews, or to Ron Paul supporters! Cheesy

+1

sunnankar

legendary

Activity: 1031

Merit: 1000

Quote from: meowmeowbrowncow on February 25, 2013, 06:16:42 PM

He uses the example of AMEX traveler's cheques. These cheques are pegged at their denomination in currency.

Yes, it shows he does not fully understand the Bitcoin concept. By analogy, Bitcoin is both the blood (value store) and the veins (value transfer).

In his example with AMEX traveler's cheques, the USD is the blood and the traveler's cheque is the veins.

Gabi

legendary

Activity: 1148

Merit: 1008

If you want to walk on water, get out of the boat

Quote from: lassdas on February 25, 2013, 05:03:47 PM

Quote

Robert Wenzel:
..
Anyone using bitcoins in a transaction is converting bitcoin values in their head to dollars.
..
If people ever stop the calculation from bitcoins into dollars and just start thinking in terms of bitcoin buying power, then it would become money.
..

Everytime I use dollars in a transaction I'm converting dollar values in my head to euros.
Do I need to stop calculating and just start thinking in terms of dollar buying power for the dollar to become money?

This

I was going to say exactly the same thing.

FreeMoney

legendary

Activity: 1246

Merit: 1014

Strength in numbers

I swear one time I won some dollars and my thought was "Yes, that's over 500 bitcoins".

But we already knew the dollar isn't "real money"(tm)

imanikin

hero member

Activity: 702

Merit: 503

I wonder whether this Wenzel would or has said that gold is not money now because people value it in their heads in terms of fiat quantities? Huh

If he hasn't, i dare him to say that during one of his GoldMoney interviews, or to Ron Paul supporters! Cheesy

meowmeowbrowncow

sr. member

Activity: 322

Merit: 250

There are contradictions in his statement about 'buying power.'

He uses the example of AMEX traveler's cheques. These cheques are pegged at their denomination in currency.

Bitcoin isn't pegged. Functionally, it's a secondary, intermediate currency with it's own buying power. Greater than a commodity - since one rarely pays for a steak dinner with (n) amount of pork bellies.

odolvlobo

legendary

Activity: 4298

Merit: 3209

Quote from: n8rwJeTt8TrrLKPa55eU on February 24, 2013, 11:57:40 PM

Robert Wenzel on His Economic Policy Journal, Elite Memes and the Expanding American Empire

Quote

If people ever stop the calculation from bitcoins into dollars and just start thinking in terms of bitcoin buying power, then it would become money.

This is his personal criteria. It does not exist in any definition or classification of money anywhere that I know of. In other words, he just made it up.

lassdas

legendary

Activity: 3649

Merit: 1412

Quote

Robert Wenzel:
..
Anyone using bitcoins in a transaction is converting bitcoin values in their head to dollars.
..
If people ever stop the calculation from bitcoins into dollars and just start thinking in terms of bitcoin buying power, then it would become money.
..

Everytime I use dollars in a transaction I'm converting dollar values in my head to euros.
Do I need to stop calculating and just start thinking in terms of dollar buying power for the dollar to become money?

FreeMoney

legendary

Activity: 1246

Merit: 1014

Strength in numbers

Quote from: n8rwJeTt8TrrLKPa55eU on February 24, 2013, 11:57:40 PM

Robert Wenzel on His Economic Policy Journal, Elite Memes and the Expanding American Empire

Quote

Daily Bell: What do you think of bitcoin?

Robert Wenzel: Bitcoins have some use value for anonymous transactions and also as a method for quick, safe transactions. But it is not money at this time. Anyone using bitcoins in a transaction is converting bitcoin values in their head to dollars. Thus, a bitcoin is closer to a digital American Express travelers check (with a fluctuating value), then a stand-alone currency.

If people ever stop the calculation from bitcoins into dollars and just start thinking in terms of bitcoin buying power, then it would become money.

This is not impossible. If there is ever a major crackdown on the economy and, say, price controls and major black market activity develops, bitcoins could become an alternative currency.

Thus, I am not saying bitcoins won't become money, but they are not now. And I don't see it occurring in the short term at all. In the long term, there is a slim chance. More likely, bitcoin could become a popular method to facilitate safe, secure transactions, rather than become a money.

Full Interview:
http://dailybell.com/28719/Anthony-Wile-Robert-Wenzel-on-His-Economic-Policy-Journal-Elite-Memes-and-the-Expanding-American-Empire

I wonder in his actual opinion if we have to stop it 'ever' or 'forever' because some people have sometimes done that.

I think it's kind of a silly idea though. If I ever find myself in a land that uses Euros I'll be converting it in my head to dollars not because Euros aren't money but because I spend most of my time in a place that uses dollars. The existence of some people who don't do that doesn't seem very important. Suppose there was a place where no one lived but only vacationed (humor me, even the workers only stay for one month shifts) everyone would always be thinking of the currency there as foreign and doing conversions but that money would still be a money.

n8rwJeTt8TrrLKPa55eU

hero member

Activity: 588

Merit: 500

Robert Wenzel on His Economic Policy Journal, Elite Memes and the Expanding American Empire

Quote

Daily Bell: What do you think of bitcoin?

Robert Wenzel: Bitcoins have some use value for anonymous transactions and also as a method for quick, safe transactions. But it is not money at this time. Anyone using bitcoins in a transaction is converting bitcoin values in their head to dollars. Thus, a bitcoin is closer to a digital American Express travelers check (with a fluctuating value), then a stand-alone currency.

If people ever stop the calculation from bitcoins into dollars and just start thinking in terms of bitcoin buying power, then it would become money.

This is not impossible. If there is ever a major crackdown on the economy and, say, price controls and major black market activity develops, bitcoins could become an alternative currency.

Thus, I am not saying bitcoins won't become money, but they are not now. And I don't see it occurring in the short term at all. In the long term, there is a slim chance. More likely, bitcoin could become a popular method to facilitate safe, secure transactions, rather than become a money.

Full Interview:
http://dailybell.com/28719/Anthony-Wile-Robert-Wenzel-on-His-Economic-Policy-Journal-Elite-Memes-and-the-Expanding-American-Empire

Topic: 2013-02-24 Daily Bell: Robert Wenzel Interview (Read 1389 times)