Author

Topic: [2014-12-26] Reuters: Bitcoin’s defects will hasten its demise in 2015 (Read 784 times)

legendary
Activity: 1582
Merit: 1064
In case you don't know what seignorage is (like I didn't), I Googled it and it appears to be the "cost of making money" something like that.

Seignorage is the value of money created minus cost of creating money.

In the case of fiat, say the government prints USD 1 million. The cost of printing bills might only be USD 10K. The remaining would be called seignorage.

In the case of Bitcoin, seignorage would be the block reward minus costs incurred by a miner (electricity, hardware costs). I think the article is talking about the block reward halving.
legendary
Activity: 2086
Merit: 1031
sound like the topic of the threat of  51% attack! It is resolved by the big miners's self adjust. when their hash power exceeds a certain level, they will voluntarily shift some hash power to other small pool!
Quote
As seignorage declines it will become cost-uncompetitive for transactions.
I don't think the transaction fee will be increased to become cost-uncompetitive when seignorage declines!

In case you don't know what seignorage is (like I didn't), I Googled it and it appears to be the "cost of making money" something like that.

I don't think it's fair to assume that the transaction fees won't be increased.  I assume the bitcoin community will always do what is good for bitcoin.

If that includes fee increases or decreases, we'll see, but I do agree that the fees would only increase if that was a good thing for the miners.  So if they were to do anything to harm the community (and thus price), it would ultimately hurt the miners.  So we'll see how much blood is squeezed from the onion.

For now, the fees remain a very small fraction of the mining revenues, so I suspect we're debating about 10-20 years from now at least... what a problem to have if we make it that far!
hero member
Activity: 574
Merit: 500
sound like the topic of the threat of  51% attack! It is resolved by the big miners's self adjust. when their hash power exceeds a certain level, they will voluntarily shift some hash power to other small pool!
Quote
As seignorage declines it will become cost-uncompetitive for transactions.
I don't think the transaction fee will be increased to become cost-uncompetitive when seignorage declines!
legendary
Activity: 2086
Merit: 1031
Heard this before... will hear it again... it won't come true again... moving on...
donator
Activity: 1736
Merit: 1006
Let's talk governance, lipstick, and pigs.
2011 called. They want their headline back.
legendary
Activity: 1246
Merit: 1000
Bitcoin’s defects will hasten its demise in 2015

http://blogs.reuters.com/breakingviews/2014/12/26/bitcoins-defects-will-hasten-its-demise-in-2015/

Bitcoin’s defects will hasten its demise in 2015. The leading crypto-currency’s economies of scale in mining and its transaction system’s vulnerability to subversion by a dominant miner make it unsound. As seignorage declines it will become cost-uncompetitive for transactions. These flaws will cause its price to lose further altitude.
Jump to: