There are two things I don't understand here.
Firstly, GUSD is created when someone deposits fiat on the Gemini exchange, so every GUSD in existence is backed up 1:1 with a dollar deposited. So what's the issue with cashing out? Have they spent all those dollars and now they can't redeem them, or are they literally just refusing so they can manipulate their numbers? Even if they had spent all those dollars, the Winklevoss twins are rich enough to cover it easily.
Secondly, why do people even trust stablecoins? You move to crypto to get away from centralized fiat issued by a government and held in a bank, and then you buy a centralized stablecoin issued by an exchange which you can't even cash out? I just don't see the point.
Their reasoning -
"a U.S.-based OTC desk told CoinDesk its Gemini account was promptly shut after redeeming several million GUSD. He now believes this was part of Gemini’s strategy to “maximize their status on CoinMarketCap.”
Paxos have done the same for the same reason.
They were issued to certain entities at a 1% discount on the agreement they wouldn't cash out, presumably there are time or proportion limits that are lifted. Still a ridiculous idea and I've no idea why anyone went for it.
It's centralisation on top of centralisation. And all the issuers are so terrified of compliance I expect many people will give up on them. Tether don't really give much of a fuck, or have ever offered much in the way of cashing out, which is why they'll stay relevant.