Take the new one you got back and invest in a gold coirsar or seasonic unless you want your very expensive video cards to die
I would question your credibility in the area of PSU standards if you think Bronze certified PSU's do not provide the Watts they advertise. Not to sound harsh, it's just that standards such as the 80+ bronze/silver/gold/platinum exist for a reason.
I believe whether a PSU is gold or bronze has absolutely no bearing on the advertised Wattage that the PSU can dish out. If you check out the spec differences between a bronze and gold PSU for example, you'll notice the difference is in fail-overs and safe-guards mainly as well as efficiency levels. Total Watts supplied has absolutely nothing to do with a PSU's level of 80+ certification. A PSU will dish out whatever amount of Wattage it advertises, efficiency in supplying that power is a different story (this is where 80+ comes in).
I highly recommend reading this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/80_Plus
Again, sorry to sound like an ass if i did, i just dislike it when inaccurate information is provided.