Author

Topic: A completely abuse of merits, Legendary member ( Waiting For DT) (Read 490 times)

sr. member
Activity: 308
Merit: 280
Cheesy Cheesy Cheesy very interesting  merit abuse report. lyka sell 200 merit only 22$.  Cheesy very lol. DT rank member bann him firstly.   
Where have you got the info? If it's sale, this guy deserves a ban, of course.
For your info, DT can't ban members here. Moderator and admin can do it. If you don't understand what DT is, it's worthy to have a look here- https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.48081277
jr. member
Activity: 181
Merit: 5
A Blockchain Mobile Operator With Token Rewards
I found a merit abuse which is quietly LOL! Cheesy shamimal93 sent a merit to Tamim121 on a bounty report which is really insane. Did they shared there merit on a bounty report to hide from the Eye of DT members?  Grin

Merit receiver: Tamim121 - https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/tamim121-1217533
Merit sender: shamimal93 - https://bitcointalksearch.org/user/shamimal93-1337483

I have also found connection of them -

Etherscan address : https://etherscan.io/tokentxns?a=0x07166f30f57fdde2b31ff233e73f00c3a89dae61
Ether address of shamimal93 : 0x07166f30f57fDDe2b31fF233E73F00c3A89DAe61
Ether address of Tamim121 : 0xD08440AeE82f456A515538A5967F09cdBF1a5CA6




merit receiving thread : https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.27759563
member
Activity: 532
Merit: 15
Trader
lyka  again give 50 merit yesterday to lybship53
He/She Has given 200 merit 6 times, to 2 profiles
He/She Send 150 merit 5 time to lybship53
And Send 50 merit 1 time to temcolabs
I think they ar Same person. or, Lyka Merit is selling.





Merited Post: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.48024508

Merited Profile: lybship53

Waiting For DT
legendary
Activity: 1484
Merit: 1655
Rêlêå§ê ¥ðµr MïñÐ
Merit Sender: lyka
Merit Receiver 1: [ DO NOT POST SESC LINKS ] temcolabs[/url]
Merit Receiver 2: lybship53

Proof of connection

lyka and lybship53 have sent tokens to the same ETH wallet


https://etherscan.io/address/0x856f3284e5fd0e3ee7cca07916d23a4fbbe5ed79#tokentxns

0x56A37A1366B03fD0D4d879212F70Af0aA4466272 belongs to lybship53
0xf3f0505e7B8F2986e0A9368774Bd7402685AD580 belongs to lyka

Facebook
WEEK:2 (02/01 - 09/01)
Your number on the spreadsheet: 143
Facebook Link: https://www.facebook.com/lybship
ETH Address: 0x56A37A1366B03fD0D4d879212F70Af0aA4466272
Facebook
WEEK: 2 (3.01 – 9.01)
Your number on the spreadsheet: 137
Facebook Link: https://www.facebook.com/lukashenkovictor
ETH Address: 0xf3f0505e7B8F2986e0A9368774Bd7402685AD580
(Archive)
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 2061
Join the world-leading crypto sportsbook NOW!
lybship53 account was just banned for plagiarism. A grand total of 150 merits down the drain.  Grin

There was an additional 50 merit transaction between lyka and lybship53 an hour ago; https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.48024508



Edit: @Veleor nice findings. Since both accounts belong to the same guy, it might be worth checking lyka for plagiarism too. See if can get 2/2 lol
legendary
Activity: 2100
Merit: 1167
MY RED TRUST LEFT BY SCUMBAGS - READ MY SIG
Earlier the post was in reputation, now you have moved it to meta? Wasn't reputation the correct board? Why have you moved it here, btw? I don't see any reason to move it.
I did not get any reply on this post. So, to show the members of the DT power, I move my post to meta thread.

How come removed it back to this section again?
member
Activity: 72
Merit: 12
It looks like a case of merits being awarded excessively to a post that doesn't deserve that much.
I would not call it an without concrete evidence that it's an alt or the merits were bought.

There are many cases of merits being awarded to maybe underserving posts and replies but it's an unregulated system and smerit holders can do as they please with it.
I came across a post where a merit source (was a source at the time, not sure about now) gave 30 merits to those who commented under his/her post, as a sort of giveaway.
legendary
Activity: 2100
Merit: 1167
MY RED TRUST LEFT BY SCUMBAGS - READ MY SIG
I don't really think that the merited posts merite 50 points, this is a clear abuse.

Some thoughts:
Even confirming that the sender is an abuser, it will require more proofs to confirm the connection between the accounts; means no determined proofs of clear abuse against receivers (at most cases, posts can be reported if meaningless or shitposts).
The problems of merit system abuse can be reduced by adding a demerit option (already suggested by DT members) available for mods and DT members in abuse cases.


The topic has no Meta content, it's a matter of profile's reputation.. i think this is the appropriate board.

LOL how recognised are you at bitcointalk is that not a profiles reputation? get that one moved first then.

This is the merit board. Get with the program.

LOL no thanks DT members should not have this power. Mods only. You can't really ruin a board with  2 or 3 being accountable  because they can not gain enough momentum it easily becomes observable as a dictatorship and since the only real fear is a ban people will just leave. However start opening it up to a clique of 40+ and there associated  pets and you will make things far more risky and dark here.

Demerit for mods only with clear criteria.

This guy deserves some merit for spotting abuse.


member
Activity: 265
Merit: 14
Nina
I don't really think that the merited posts merite 50 points, this is a clear abuse.

Some thoughts:
Even confirming that the sender is an abuser, it will require more proofs to confirm the connection between the accounts; means no determined proofs of clear abuse against receivers (at most cases, posts can be reported if meaningless or shitposts).
The problems of merit system abuse can be reduced by adding a demerit option (already suggested by DT members) available for mods and DT members in abuse cases.


The topic has no Meta content, it's a matter of profile's reputation.. i think this is the appropriate board.
legendary
Activity: 2100
Merit: 1167
MY RED TRUST LEFT BY SCUMBAGS - READ MY SIG
Earlier the post was in reputation, now you have moved it to meta? Wasn't reputation the correct board? Why have you moved it here, btw? I don't see any reason to move it.
I did not get any reply on this post. So, to show the members of the DT power, I move my post to meta thread.

Very interesting report. I await to see what happens about it all.

50 merits for one post is quite insane ... even a great poster on the alt discussion will never likely attain such merit in years.

Demonstrating merit is gamed hard here very valuable.



member
Activity: 532
Merit: 15
Trader
Earlier the post was in reputation, now you have moved it to meta? Wasn't reputation the correct board? Why have you moved it here, btw? I don't see any reason to move it.
I did not get any reply on this post. So, to show the members of the DT power, I move my post to meta thread.
legendary
Activity: 2100
Merit: 1167
MY RED TRUST LEFT BY SCUMBAGS - READ MY SIG
Well this is the merit board so of course it can be discussed here. I see 50% of threads here are about merit or greater. So one more is of course welcomed and fully at home.

The entire merit system is a circle jerking backslapping club in meta so don't worry too much about it. Just enjoy posting here and make posts that you know are good and make a difference.

The entire system is abused if you consider a small actually tiny tiny tiny majority of posters circling it around to each other for simply aligning with their ideology of how the board should be. 

A lot of the top merit holders here pass merit amongst themselves on a small sub board for discussing how much merit they have.

So long as merit is holding off new bot and scammers from the alt discussion board it's doing it's job and that is all you can say about it.

Good for highlighting it though.

Merit is to stop spammers, account farmers, ico pumpers - it has no other real value than that.  I

Having said that legends passing it all around to other legends is not so bad as legends obviously powering up puppet accounts or merit buyers. We don't want that.

Get that legend reduced back to senior at max take all his merit away.





jr. member
Activity: 30
Merit: 12

Probably OP didn't get any replies over there,qnd thought,hey "it'll definitely get attention over here"
Now sadly I really think he has to move it back..

The report looks like a blatant merit abuse to me though
sr. member
Activity: 308
Merit: 280
Earlier the post was in reputation, now you have moved it to meta? Wasn't reputation the correct board? Why have you moved it here, btw? I don't see any reason to move it.
member
Activity: 532
Merit: 15
Trader
With my Eyes I'm thinking it's a complete abuse of merits.

He/She gave 50+50= 100 merit out of the small two posts. The post two had the same context.
He/she Has given 150 merit 5 times, to 2 profiles.
see a proof a picture attractive value.






Merited post 1 : https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.47057487
Merited post 2 : https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.45814295

Merit Sender: lyka
Merit Receiver 1: [ DO NOT POST SESC LINKS ] temcolabs[/url]
Merit Receiver 2: lybship53

Please forgive, if I Worng.
Jump to: