I'm going to go out on a limb here and say it was done for the good of the forum. Let's say you did it once, then it sort of sets the precedence for someone else to do it over and over again.
So my removing your posts and other like it it sends a message that 3 letter posts will not be tolerated. I wouldn't think of it as an attack on you but spamming posters in general who try and game the system in order to build rep or what have you.
Topic: A Mod was bored i guess. (Read 1488 times)
One word posts are sometimes fine. It really has to do with context, as to whether it is a complete answer/thought in reply. For example
OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
[...]
I would like to disagree. If you're rejecting an offer, you don't need to reply because the lack of a reply constitutes a rejection of the offer.OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
[...]
Some times OP wants some one to reply his thread. Only by that way, they can know whether some like the offer or not.
If no one replies, then OP may think no one read the thread at all, even though thread view shows some number.
One word posts are sometimes fine. It really has to do with context, as to whether it is a complete answer/thought in reply. For example
OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
[...]
I would like to disagree. If you're rejecting an offer, you don't need to reply because the lack of a reply constitutes a rejection of the offer.OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
[...]
Some times OP wants some one to reply his thread. Only by that way, they can know whether some like the offer or not.
If no one replies, then OP may think no one read the thread at all, even though thread view shows some number.
I think the biggest problem is when people are posting one or two word replies to increase their post count or activity.
One word posts are sometimes fine. It really has to do with context, as to whether it is a complete answer/thought in reply. For example
OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
[...]
I would like to disagree. If you're rejecting an offer, you don't need to reply because the lack of a reply constitutes a rejection of the offer. OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
[...]
Insubstantial posts like your "lol" add zero value to the discussion, and are frequently deleted.
Ok fair enough. I'll make sure my posts contain more than a 1 word reply.Thanks for the response.
lol. funny!
I posted that expecting it to be deleted. This just shows mods are not robots - they each have their own views on what is and isn't acceptable.
Insubstantial posts like your "lol" add zero value to the discussion, and are frequently deleted.
Ok fair enough. I'll make sure my posts contain more than a 1 word reply.Thanks for the response.
lol. funny!
I posted that expecting it to be deleted. This just shows mods are not robots - they each have their own views on what is and isn't acceptable.
I think bearing in mind how busy a thread is as well. Some of those mining hardware threads can have a hundred posts in a day and they're impossible to navigate if they're also interspersed with extra posts of just LOL, +1, -1, awesome, etc...
One word posts are sometimes fine. It really has to do with context, as to whether it is a complete answer/thought in reply. For example
OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
Vs.
OP: Hey guys! I'm here announcing my new service, I take your Bitcoins, invest them in my own secret ways, and then return the money 100% Guarenteed. If you aren't satisfied, get 100% of your money back!!! Fully insured deposits, you cant lose!
You: No
While it is somewhat on topic, and we could infer that you were saying "No..." with implied extra meaning, that is an example of a post that may or may not be deleted. If the thread is 50 pages long and people have already explained that the OP in this situation is a moron, your "No" reply probably isn't needed. Plus added other situational things, and depending on who is reading it, etc etc.
I suppose my point is, post one word replies if you wish, just try and make sure that your one word reply is completing an idea or thought. It is however more easy to do with multiple words.
OP: Hey guys! I'm here looking for a 10 BTC loan, I have no credentials, no reason to pay you back, and no trust, anyone want to give me a loan?
You: No
In this situation, you are directly responding and giving a straightforward on topic answer in one word.
Vs.
OP: Hey guys! I'm here announcing my new service, I take your Bitcoins, invest them in my own secret ways, and then return the money 100% Guarenteed. If you aren't satisfied, get 100% of your money back!!! Fully insured deposits, you cant lose!
You: No
While it is somewhat on topic, and we could infer that you were saying "No..." with implied extra meaning, that is an example of a post that may or may not be deleted. If the thread is 50 pages long and people have already explained that the OP in this situation is a moron, your "No" reply probably isn't needed. Plus added other situational things, and depending on who is reading it, etc etc.
I suppose my point is, post one word replies if you wish, just try and make sure that your one word reply is completing an idea or thought. It is however more easy to do with multiple words.
lol. funny!
Great post! I just sent you a tip for it, I value your post at 0.0016 BTC
Thank you muchly; I agree with your assessment.
lol. funny!
Great post! I just sent you a tip for it, I value your post at 0.0016 BTC
Insubstantial posts like your "lol" add zero value to the discussion, and are frequently deleted.
Ok fair enough. I'll make sure my posts contain more than a 1 word reply.Thanks for the response.
lol. funny!
+1. Such Wow!
(^_^ Was tempted to just make the above the reply)
Ok fair enough. I'll make sure my posts contain more than a 1 word reply.
That wouldn't necessarily be enough. I just deleted a couple of one-liners that didn't add anything to the discussion, e.g. "yes we all should change our passwords" re: heartbleed.
Insubstantial posts like your "lol" add zero value to the discussion, and are frequently deleted.
Ok fair enough. I'll make sure my posts contain more than a 1 word reply.Thanks for the response.
lol. funny!
I think 'added value' is the key here. So 'yes' or 'no' are 1 word replies that *may* add value, or not, for instance.
Insubstantial posts like your "lol" add zero value to the discussion, and are frequently deleted.
I also had a deleted post in the KnC miner tread that was fairly harmless (informative though off-topic)
I thought: don't take it personally... just move along
I thought: don't take it personally... just move along
Quote from: Bitcoin Forum
A reply of yours, quoted below, was deleted by a Bitcoin Forum moderator. Posts are most frequently deleted because they are off-topic, though they can also be deleted for other reasons. In the future, please avoid posting things that need to be deleted.
Really? Did my lol break a rule? I really have no idea why it was deleted. the lol was a comment i left after someone posted something funny.Quote
lol
What about these posts which consist of nothing but "+1", or "-1"?
I consider these posts to be off-topic because they have no point, but they don't cause much damage, so I usually don't delete them unless the poster posts useless replies a lot or the useless replies are reported.Other moderators might be more or less strict about this.
Got this msg in my inbox
Quote from: Bitcoin Forum
A reply of yours, quoted below, was deleted by a Bitcoin Forum moderator. Posts are most frequently deleted because they are off-topic, though they can also be deleted for other reasons. In the future, please avoid posting things that need to be deleted.
Really? Did my lol break a rule? I really have no idea why it was deleted. the lol was a comment i left after someone posted something funny.Quote
lol
Jump to: