Author

Topic: About "investing in bitcoin does not create value" (Read 924 times)

legendary
Activity: 1988
Merit: 1012
Beyond Imagination

Saving/hoarding/speculating in bitcoin raises the value of the bitcoin unit to a level higher than the current value would be, if only the current usage was taken into account. Without speculation, the current value could be less than a dollar.

Stated otherwise: If the coin was constructed such that the volume of coins increased with usage, speculation would be futile and the value based on use in indirect exchange could be less than a dollar per coin.


Suppose that bitcoin were used for some people's private retirement saving, and each person put 10K dollar into bitcoin as a small part of his investment portfolio. 10K such person will push the bitcoin price to $9

And that is under an assumption that all the coins are out for sell, in reality maybe only 10% of coins are out for sell, so the price will possibly reach $90 easily

In fact it takes much less money to push up the exchange rate, due to extremely low supply of coins on the market
sr. member
Activity: 280
Merit: 250
Some people say that investing in bitcoin is not really an investment, since it does not create any value

Correct. Money has no direct use value. Having more or less makes no difference. Saving money is just saving. Investment is when the saver buys capital goods with the intention to produce something.

But note: Somebody must save before investing is possible. Saving has to come first.

And: On the individual level there is no difference, because it is easy to transform money to capital and back.

Quote
In modern economics theory, value is only decided by supply and demand. If investing in bitcoin can satisfy people's certain kind of demand, then it creates value

Investing in bitcoin, is to inject capital into the bitcoin currency system. It will support and raise the bitcoin exchange rates. While the exchange rate continuously improve, it will gain popularity and credibility, thus satisfy the demand of an anti-inflation medium of saving

Saving/hoarding/speculating in bitcoin raises the value of the bitcoin unit to a level higher than the current value would be, if only the current usage was taken into account. Without speculation, the current value could be less than a dollar.

Stated otherwise: If the coin was constructed such that the volume of coins increased with usage, speculation would be futile and the value based on use in indirect exchange could be less than a dollar per coin.

Quote
This demand can not be satisfied by ever-inflating fiat money, people can only put their excessive funds into stock/ real estate / gold, but these assets are risky and difficult to transfer

And satisfying this demand will enhance the economy activity of the whole society, after people had some savings that do not lose its value over time, they will have the confidence to spend

Correct. Sound money makes saving in money possible, possibly reducing production of things that people don't really want, but have to buy because of inflation.

Quote

Like any other investment, the investment in bitcoin also has risk. But due to limited supply of coins, that risk is much lower than any other investment vehicles, it has a reward/risk ratio of over 30:1  Cheesy

Absolutely correct. Just get in if you are not in already.
hero member
Activity: 642
Merit: 500
Evolution is the only way to survive
fiat currency 's inflation destroy value  , which's better?
newbie
Activity: 27
Merit: 0
Today I bought $4500 worth of gold and silver using Bitcoins.  (Admittedly, I sold those, and used the cash to buy the metals.)  Needless to say, investing in Bitcoin can create value - it just depends on how you think about it.

(For the record, I think it its own value.  That it can create other value is well is a nice bonus.)   Grin
legendary
Activity: 1988
Merit: 1012
Beyond Imagination
Some people say that investing in bitcoin is not really an investment, since it does not create any value

In modern economics theory, value is only decided by supply and demand. If investing in bitcoin can satisfy people's certain kind of demand, then it creates value

Investing in bitcoin, is to inject capital into the bitcoin currency system. It will support and raise the bitcoin exchange rates. While the exchange rate continuously improve, it will gain popularity and credibility, thus satisfy the demand of an anti-inflation medium of saving

This demand can not be satisfied by ever-inflating fiat money, people can only put their excessive funds into stock/ real estate / gold, but these assets are risky and difficult to transfer

And satisfying this demand will enhance the economy activity of the whole society, after people had some savings that do not lose its value over time, they will have the confidence to spend

Like any other investment, the investment in bitcoin also has risk. But due to limited supply of coins, that risk is much lower than any other investment vehicles, it has a reward/risk ratio of over 30:1  Cheesy
Jump to: