This has been in a roller coaster ride because of its poor management by IRFAN. I would like to point out one by one on his lapses:
1. On June 30 there were some few of participants who joined in the Adex Bounty Campaign (
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/--1980387) and as they joined the campaign, noticed that on the Spreadsheet the last few participants who joined were deleted because
the Campaign Manager did not lock the Spreadsheet thus it allowed people to delete freely what was written or posted on the sheet. I don't want to pinpoint who did that because obviously I don't think Irfan found out who the culprit was. Mind you, a lot joined "last minute" obviously it was because they saw that the ICO was about to sold out.The application also was not closed so that means it was still open for new participants.
2. Now when he found out on that same day what happened on the Spreadsheet, Irfan then CLOSED the application for participants and changed the deadline on the Spreadsheet to 06.29 Thursday but on the first page he posted there that the deadline was a Friday June 30 at 23:59pm (Rule 7) which then Irfan acclaimed he was "TYPO". I think I remember the same incident that happened on the iDice Campaign too that the same Campaign Manager said he got "TYPO" too. (If this has been happening not just once, don't you think you need to be more accurate the next time you are handling a campaign, because it would be a redundant reason to get the same error over and over again.)
3. So when Irfan changed his rules, a lot obviously complained in the bounty thread and even replied to some post and stated he will fix it. And even corrected the mistake and said
We are going to count 30th June in the previous week. Those who joined the campaign on this date will get stakes in the first week. So again changed the rules back again to the original Rule #7.
4. And lastly regarding the stakes on the Spreadsheet, Irfan gave chance to some participants and gave stakes to those who completed the 10 posts on June 30 and then just today, he made a change again and decided without any further explanation of some sort that the stakes was again changed to only half the amount instead of the full amount of stakes before the distribution.
If I were to rate 1 as the highest and 10 as the lowest you could possibly rate a campaign manager, I would rate IRFAN 8.5 out of 10 for him handling this campaign, maybe because you handled a lot of campaign already and you are not able to manage well this campaign or you were out of focus because of the many campaigns you are handling but so far out of all the managers you are one of the worst because of how poorly you manage this campaign and the many issues that were thrown at you.
