Author

Topic: [ANN] GLBSE hot wallet empty, withdrawals delayed (Read 2046 times)

hero member
Activity: 686
Merit: 500
Wat
I like the idea of people covering the hot wallet deposits for the fee.
sr. member
Activity: 389
Merit: 250
A secure longer term solution could be simply paying out only of cold storage a few times per day.
The insecure alternative would be only operating a hot wallet.

Is it really that necessary to have bitcoins confirmed in your wallet in ~1 hour? Within 24h would be fine for me as well, if it is more secure and it would still be faster than bank transfers.

Also P2SH might be interesting to evaluate, though I still haven't seen some real implementations of that... considering Gavin was acting as if it has to be done asap and better yesterday than today, it seems a little bit weird in hindsight.

Trying to run a pirate pass though when the delay is 24 hours is massive fail if we have to pay out 6.8%   
What about a small fee (0.05%?) For hot wallet transactions and free cold transactions within whatever timeframe Nefario wants to offer.

Any thoughts?
It wouldn't solve someone wanting a large amount of BTC immediately to put into something else if the hot wallet's refill amount is less than the amount being withdrawn -- it'll always still require Nef manually refill the hot wallet. I think that's what is causing problems -- someone like Goat wanting the huge investment money to deposit in Pirate - and it results in massive losses for him to wait for the BTC. It would be nice if how many coins remain in the hot wallet were displayed on GLBSE so we can better-plan our withdrawals.
The big result would be that people would be less inclined to use the hot wallet. It may be easier for Nefario to as a little extra to the wallet on Monday figuring this quick use is from that.

In the "just crazy enough to work" line of thought, if there was a hot wallet fee, why not alert and allow other people to add funds to the hot wallet to claim the fee for themselves. The setup and implementation would be a pain more than likely, but it might lower the time for the wallet to fill up again. (The fee should keep people from gaming the system).
hero member
Activity: 686
Merit: 500
Wat
A secure longer term solution could be simply paying out only of cold storage a few times per day.
The insecure alternative would be only operating a hot wallet.

Is it really that necessary to have bitcoins confirmed in your wallet in ~1 hour? Within 24h would be fine for me as well, if it is more secure and it would still be faster than bank transfers.

Also P2SH might be interesting to evaluate, though I still haven't seen some real implementations of that... considering Gavin was acting as if it has to be done asap and better yesterday than today, it seems a little bit weird in hindsight.

Trying to run a pirate pass though when the delay is 24 hours is massive fail if we have to pay out 6.8%   
What about a small fee (0.05%?) For hot wallet transactions and free cold transactions within whatever timeframe Nefario wants to offer.

Any thoughts?
It wouldn't solve someone wanting a large amount of BTC immediately to put into something else if the hot wallet's refill amount is less than the amount being withdrawn -- it'll always still require Nef manually refill the hot wallet. I think that's what is causing problems -- someone like Goat wanting the huge investment money to deposit in Pirate - and it results in massive losses for him to wait for the BTC. It would be nice if how many coins remain in the hot wallet were displayed on GLBSE so we can better-plan our withdrawals.

Do you think that would introduce a security risk ?
donator
Activity: 1218
Merit: 1015
A secure longer term solution could be simply paying out only of cold storage a few times per day.
The insecure alternative would be only operating a hot wallet.

Is it really that necessary to have bitcoins confirmed in your wallet in ~1 hour? Within 24h would be fine for me as well, if it is more secure and it would still be faster than bank transfers.

Also P2SH might be interesting to evaluate, though I still haven't seen some real implementations of that... considering Gavin was acting as if it has to be done asap and better yesterday than today, it seems a little bit weird in hindsight.

Trying to run a pirate pass though when the delay is 24 hours is massive fail if we have to pay out 6.8%   
What about a small fee (0.05%?) For hot wallet transactions and free cold transactions within whatever timeframe Nefario wants to offer.

Any thoughts?
It wouldn't solve someone wanting a large amount of BTC immediately to put into something else if the hot wallet's refill amount is less than the amount being withdrawn -- it'll always still require Nef manually refill the hot wallet. I think that's what is causing problems -- someone like Goat wanting the huge investment money to deposit in Pirate - and it results in massive losses for him to wait for the BTC. It would be nice if how many coins remain in the hot wallet were displayed on GLBSE so we can better-plan our withdrawals.
sr. member
Activity: 389
Merit: 250
A secure longer term solution could be simply paying out only of cold storage a few times per day.
The insecure alternative would be only operating a hot wallet.

Is it really that necessary to have bitcoins confirmed in your wallet in ~1 hour? Within 24h would be fine for me as well, if it is more secure and it would still be faster than bank transfers.

Also P2SH might be interesting to evaluate, though I still haven't seen some real implementations of that... considering Gavin was acting as if it has to be done asap and better yesterday than today, it seems a little bit weird in hindsight.

Trying to run a pirate pass though when the delay is 24 hours is massive fail if we have to pay out 6.8%   
What about a small fee (0.05%?) For hot wallet transactions and free cold transactions within whatever timeframe Nefario wants to offer.

Any thoughts?
legendary
Activity: 2618
Merit: 1007
A secure longer term solution could be simply paying out only of cold storage a few times per day.
The insecure alternative would be only operating a hot wallet.

Is it really that necessary to have bitcoins confirmed in your wallet in ~1 hour? Within 24h would be fine for me as well, if it is more secure and it would still be faster than bank transfers.

Also P2SH might be interesting to evaluate, though I still haven't seen some real implementations of that... considering Gavin was acting as if it has to be done asap and better yesterday than today, it seems a little bit weird in hindsight.
hero member
Activity: 602
Merit: 513
GLBSE Support [email protected]
Update, wallets empty again.
donator
Activity: 588
Merit: 500
I have opened a support ticket for 5 days with Nefario. Do anybody know what is happening?

He got back to me today.

Thank you Nefario.
hero member
Activity: 784
Merit: 1000
0xFB0D8D1534241423
I don't understand, why post this here? When you have issues like this you're supposed to keep them on the down low until enough people start complaining, and then blame them until you have time to resolve the situation. Geez, you brown nosers are going to give everyone else a bad name. Tongue

LOL sorry I found this funny Smiley.




Yes, +1  Thank you for being open and public about issues. That is very important to many of us.
This ++ Smiley
donator
Activity: 588
Merit: 500
I have opened a support ticket for 5 days with Nefario. Do anybody know what is happening?
hero member
Activity: 518
Merit: 500
I just had a withdrawal go through in reasonable time, so I assume these issues have now been dealt with. Can you provide an update, Nefario?
sr. member
Activity: 464
Merit: 250
I don't understand, why post this here? When you have issues like this you're supposed to keep them on the down low until enough people start complaining, and then blame them until you have time to resolve the situation. Geez, you brown nosers are going to give everyone else a bad name. Tongue

LOL sorry I found this funny Smiley.


hero member
Activity: 938
Merit: 1000
Yeah I'd already downloaded the blockchain from sourceforge but it only goes up to March.

While doing this I did look at electrum but just got errors when I tried to send any coins, so that was a no go.

Personally I think the electrum model is the best but the client is not really usable at the moment.

What kind of errors did you get?
legendary
Activity: 1274
Merit: 1004
I don't understand, why post this here? When you have issues like this you're supposed to keep them on the down low until enough people start complaining, and then blame them until you have time to resolve the situation. Geez, you brown nosers are going to give everyone else a bad name. Tongue
hero member
Activity: 602
Merit: 513
GLBSE Support [email protected]
Yeah I'd already downloaded the blockchain from sourceforge but it only goes up to March.

While doing this I did look at electrum but just got errors when I tried to send any coins, so that was a no go.

Personally I think the electrum model is the best but the client is not really usable at the moment.
rjk
sr. member
Activity: 448
Merit: 250
1ngldh
As a stop-gap until scalability issues are sorted, this link can be faster than a standard download: http://eu1.bitcoincharts.com/blockchain/
However, you must rescan all addresses after importing that.

Coming from Bitcoincharts, I would consider it trusted.
hero member
Activity: 868
Merit: 1000
Thanks for the update, that makes you a class act.

THis does point out a real problem though - I shouldn't have to download an entire 2.3 GB file to send a few coins when I have to reinstall a client. There should be trusted block chain that can be downloaded faster & validated, or the ability to validate needed chain pieces on a mirror.

There's an ongoing discussion about this problem, I think they can use a hand: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ultimate-blockchain-compression-w-trust-free-lite-nodes-88208 Smiley
member
Activity: 104
Merit: 10
Thanks for the update, that makes you a class act.

THis does point out a real problem though - I shouldn't have to download an entire 2.3 GB file to send a few coins when I have to reinstall a client. There should be trusted block chain that can be downloaded faster & validated, or the ability to validate needed chain pieces on a mirror.
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1227
Away on an extended break
Better then the risk of loss of coinage through a huge hot wallet though.  Grin
hero member
Activity: 602
Merit: 513
GLBSE Support [email protected]
Our hot wallet has run dry,

the timing of this has coincided with the messing up of the bitcoin client that normally handles our cold storage.

We have to wait for the blockchain to download before we're able to top up our hotwallet.

This means that all withdrawals are going to be delayed for 4 more hours at least (it's already been a little over 12 hours since this problem started).

All bitcoin that we've kept in coldstorage is perfectly safe, and this is nothing more than a delay.

Sorry for any trouble this may cause.

Nefario.

Jump to: