Author

Topic: Another lesson for those that are using custodial exchanges and wallets (Read 376 times)

hero member
Activity: 2282
Merit: 589
I haven't even heard about the exchange before, this is my first time to hear about the exchange, but why are they holding 10% of customers funds?
Some suspect because of indications of bankruptcy so they limit withdrawals to 90% for certain purposes, I don't know the bad situation of centralized exchanges like that case, maybe they are greedy to take investors funds in subtle ways without explaining the details of using 10%. However, I just read an update to this thread from @rikaflip that the 10% withdrawal has been granted access for full withdrawals without any restrictions, so apply for a withdrawal now.
hero member
Activity: 1484
Merit: 928
I haven't even heard about the exchange before, this is my first time to hear about the exchange, but why are they holding 10% of customers funds? That's really bad, I think we all are seeing reasons why we shouldn't leave our coin on exchange. Even if you are trying to buy your coin, always make sure you use a reputable exchange to avoid being scammed, and immediately you purchase coin from reputable exchange, make sure you withdraw it to your non custodial wallet address, even on reputation exchange, don't leave your coin their.
legendary
Activity: 1708
Merit: 1280
Top Crypto Casino
Still, some of the people in the cryptocurrency space have the time and money for the investment but don't have time the securing their funds, even though its a hassle  to make a transaction with a tons of verification security at the end of the day you have the fully automation potential with your assets and not just getting ruled with the exchange or other platform you are using just to store your funds. Thats why we support the not your keys not your coins.
hero member
Activity: 2520
Merit: 783
I do not know if Wyre is a custodial wallet or an exchange. I decided to post this on beginners and help for the beginners to learn another lesson which is not new again. But moderator can decide to move it to the appropriate board.

This is not about hack but it is about not you key not your coin. On noncustodial wallet, you are the owner of your coin, unlike on custodial wallets and exchanges that you are not the owner because the keys are not yours.

See the interesting news:
https://cointelegraph.com/news/wyre-imposes-up-to-a-90-withdrawal-limit-for-all-users

Wyre users are able to withdraw, but they can only withdraw 90% of their money. Assuming you have $1000 on the exchange, you can not be able to withdraw $100 and Wyre users will be panicking about their money by now. Can you see that the more money they have on Wyre, the more money they can not be able to withdraw. On noncustodial wallet, you can send all your coins on the wallet at anytime.

To bad for people that it will cost a lot of money for other people to learn from their mistakes hopefully incident like this if not happen will minimize in future since its really bad to see so many people got scam or always think about making an exchange as their personal wallet. Traders and investors should be wise on the decision they made to avoid such unfortunate incident that might happen to them.
hero member
Activity: 3178
Merit: 661
Live with peace and enjoy life!
So they're only stealing 10% of your money. They should call it a bail-in, that's what banks would do.
Yeah, basically holding you ransom to continue to use their platform, simply because they keep ten percent of your money. It's basically a built in fee for leaving them, and means that you'll never truly own all your money. It's a weird take on things, and I'm not sure how they've built up a client base with that sort of rule put in place. At least with centralised exchanges/wallets they don't actively advertise they'll steal your money.

Really odd decision, and they almost pass it off as a positive feature Tongue.
Yeah, this one is really odd. I don’t think if all their clients will agree to their own policy in the long run as they will eventually realized that this a clear stealing of their own hard-earned money. Although this could be a reason too not to leave the platform because of 10% remaining deposit, but if clients have known this before or they are already aware, surely this platform will never get one. And might as well some clients will sue them in the long run once they constantly deducting 10% from the whole deposit every time they do withrawal.
sr. member
Activity: 832
Merit: 286
DGbet.fun - Crypto Sportsbook
Good news for all those having money on Wyre, as they announced via Twitter they secured investment that enables them to lift the 90% withdrawal cap restriction so if there's anyone still having money there, get it out while you can.
Great news for anyone with 10% remaining funds in their wallet, anyone with funds in their wyre wallet should know this important information, they should immediately withdraw it to a non-custodial wallet as soon as possible because rules can change that easily, even though the withdrawal process is normal without restrictions but anyone would have any doubts about keeping assets in a Wyre wallet for the reason that locking up 10% funds is ridiculous and highly suspicious.
legendary
Activity: 1722
Merit: 5937
Good news for all those having money on Wyre, as they announced via Twitter they secured investment that enables them to lift the 90% withdrawal cap restriction so if there's anyone still having money there, get it out while you can.

Wyre secured a new source of funding, allowing it to drop its recently introduced 90% customer withdrawal cap, the company said on Twitter today.

“We’re excited to share that today we received financing from a strategic partner that allows us to continue our normal course of operations,” Wyre tweeted, adding that it would “resume accepting deposits and lift the 90% withdrawal limit effective immediately.”
staff
Activity: 3304
Merit: 4115
So they're only stealing 10% of your money. They should call it a bail-in, that's what banks would do.
Yeah, basically holding you ransom to continue to use their platform, simply because they keep ten percent of your money. It's basically a built in fee for leaving them, and means that you'll never truly own all your money. It's a weird take on things, and I'm not sure how they've built up a client base with that sort of rule put in place. At least with centralised exchanges/wallets they don't actively advertise they'll steal your money.

Really odd decision, and they almost pass it off as a positive feature Tongue.
hero member
Activity: 2716
Merit: 904
So they're only stealing 10% of your money. They should call it a bail-in, that's what banks would do.
I understand that it could be their own way of having a bail-in, but if we keep on depositing our funds there and everytime we withdraw they would also keep holding the 10% of our funds, then eventually they are like  gaining huge profits from our own deposits. That is way too unfair for our part. That is why we should never trust exchanges like this as they can get richer in time while leaving us poorer in the end. Its better to have our own non-custodial wallet wherein we could have the full control of our own hard-earned money.
hero member
Activity: 2940
Merit: 613
Winding down.
"We are modifying our withdrawal policy. While customers will continue to be able to withdraw their funds, at this time, we are limiting withdrawals to no more than 90% of the funds currently in each customer account, subject to current daily limits."

Man, I don't want to make quick conclusions, but this really smells like insolvency. You can slightly justify having a set amount of daily withdrawal limits due to regulatory reasons, but having a set percentage? That's just too fishy imo.
There is really something wrong with how this exchange set its own rule on withrawal. Then what about the remaining 10% of the users funds, surely they will automatically become the exchange’s possession. I don’t know if no one plans to sue this exchange but I think if the withrawal rate will not change, Wyre users will end up suing them as its obviously stealing their own funds.
legendary
Activity: 1288
Merit: 1081
Goodnight, o_e_l_e_o 🌹




All these are not big problems only if you understand what you are doing and also understand what an exchange is;

An exchange is not a charity organisation ;
An exchange is not your private wallet;
An exchange as the name implies is used to exchange your coin and move it back to where it is supposed to be;
An exchange is a business of someone who is strategizing to own your coins forever.

Use the exchange according to what they are. Do not trust them more than they deserve and  do not blame them when they do what they like with your coins.
hero member
Activity: 2856
Merit: 674
Wyre users are able to withdraw, but they can only withdraw 90% of their money. Assuming you have $1000 on the exchange, you can not be able to withdraw $100 and Wyre users will be panicking about their money by now. Can you see that the more money they have on Wyre, the more money they can not be able to withdraw. On noncustodial wallet, you can send all your coins on the wallet at anytime.
Holding 10% of seized funds doesn't look like much but imagine if you deposited larger amount of money.
I never used Wyre but I see they are being used as fiat-to-crypto gateway, and they had connection with Metamask shitcoin wallet.
For what I see Wyre is registered in United States so I wouldn't be surprised if we see people starting to sue them soon.
Just imagine how much Wyre can earn from these seized funds from all of its users, so this should be alarming for all Wyre users as they are slowly stealing our funds, and this 10% will eventually grow more in the months to come. Although 10% is not that big if we only put minimal amount, but it would be a very huge amount of loss already if you are a huge amount depositor. So stay away from it if you have plans putting your funds into Wyre.
sr. member
Activity: 952
Merit: 275
Crypto wallets like Wyre are custodial, I doubt they give users access to their private keys or recovery seed, on such wallet you will only need your Gmail and a password to log into the wallet, KYC information is also required as per my research lol, this is a big red flag, I hope people learn and understand the importance of non custodial wallet.
hero member
Activity: 2268
Merit: 669
Bitcoin Casino Est. 2013
I do not know if Wyre is a custodial wallet or an exchange.

It is both and what they do is to trick users that they aren't centralized and this has happened to many people in such manners having same experience from the exchange they uses, but i thought peop would have learnt their lessons by avoiding them to remain secured with a decentralized one tht can present them their keys in a non custodial pattern perfectly, there's no lie or manipulations about it if it's not decentralized then it's fully centralized, i only pity the newbies that have not key to learning about knowing the differences.

 
I cam say the same that it is both since people can buy, sell and exchange as what they have claimed but I don't trust them if I were to use an exchange or a wallet. If I am one of the people who use it then I would be worried about the platform when they announced that they are modifying the withdrawal policy which in my opinion is kind of a negative review for me. 10% is indeed quite a lot if someone deposit huge amount and they can keep 10% and add all the 10% money from every customer they have then that would be a lot.
hero member
Activity: 952
Merit: 555
I do not know if Wyre is a custodial wallet or an exchange.

It is both and what they do is to trick users that they aren't centralized and this has happened to many people in such manners having same experience from the exchange they uses, but i thought peop would have learnt their lessons by avoiding them to remain secured with a decentralized one tht can present them their keys in a non custodial pattern perfectly, there's no lie or manipulations about it if it's not decentralized then it's fully centralized, i only pity the newbies that have not key to learning about knowing the differences.

 
hero member
Activity: 2128
Merit: 532
FREE passive income eBook @ tinyurl.com/PIA10
For what I see Wyre is registered in United States so I wouldn't be surprised if we see people starting to sue them soon.

There were non-US exchanges that got sued, Bitgrail (Italy) being one of them.

Not gonna be easy for those scumbags to walk off scot-free
legendary
Activity: 2212
Merit: 7064
Wyre users are able to withdraw, but they can only withdraw 90% of their money. Assuming you have $1000 on the exchange, you can not be able to withdraw $100 and Wyre users will be panicking about their money by now. Can you see that the more money they have on Wyre, the more money they can not be able to withdraw. On noncustodial wallet, you can send all your coins on the wallet at anytime.
Holding 10% of seized funds doesn't look like much but imagine if you deposited larger amount of money.
I never used Wyre but I see they are being used as fiat-to-crypto gateway, and they had connection with Metamask shitcoin wallet.
For what I see Wyre is registered in United States so I wouldn't be surprised if we see people starting to sue them soon.
hero member
Activity: 826
Merit: 641
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
It's so bad to hold one's crypto in any decentralized wallet, this is part of the repercussion.
You have a very good post but you make a mistake, I guess you are talking about custodial wallet and centralized exchanges, that we should not save crypto on them, instead we should use noncustodial wallet which is what we are talking about. On decentralized exchanges, you can send coin from your noncustodial wallet and receive the coin you exchange for on noncustodial wallet, they are not the same as centralized exchanges. What we against is that people should not save their coins are centralized exchanges and custodial wallets because you do not have the keys. We can not say a wallet is decentralized, if we have to say that, it means we should refer to those wallets that you run your node like bitcoin core.
Thanks for pointing out these mistakes. However, I know all of what you have explained, it was a mere typo error on my part yesterday which was corrected immediately after I detected it. You should have known through the meaning of the post itself, and you might want to check it again now.
legendary
Activity: 2184
Merit: 1302
I do not know if Wyre is a custodial wallet or an exchange.
It is a cryptocurrency payment company
Many centralized exchanges including Binance halted withdrawal of particular coin for a while and they mention it as maintenance or something temporary suspension so every exchange face this and probably actual maintenance is going or they are facing some regulatory actions so they put limitations but whenever you're deposited the funds into a centralized exchange or even bank the money is not in your control anymore.
I don't think they are undergoing maintenance, from all the news i have read about this issue, it is somewhat certain that the collapse didn't just happen, it has been coming, some of their workers had already disclosed that they were preinformed that the company was going to be shut down, and that the CEO had already emailed the workers to inform them about this:
Quote
Two unnamed employees told Axios that Wyre is shutting down, with one adding that CEO Ioannis Giannaros emailed part of the staff during the holidays about plans to liquidate the company and terminate services by the end of the month.
Quite a lot of people believe their collapse has something to do with what happened to FTX some couple of months ago, though there is another side to the story that it was as a result of their fall out in partnership with metamask:
Quote
Reports suggesting a collapse of Wyre resulted in its breakup of partnership with crypto wallet MetaMask.


One thing is certain, and that's that they can only go on with this withdrawals for as long as they can handle it, very soon withdrawals would stop completely, and by then not too many people would have managed to take their money out.
sr. member
Activity: 2520
Merit: 280
Hire Bitcointalk Camp. Manager @ r7promotions.com
I do not know if Wyre is a custodial wallet or an exchange. I decided to post this on beginners and help for the beginners to learn another lesson which is not new again. But moderator can decide to move it to the appropriate board.

This is not about hack but it is about not you key not your coin. On noncustodial wallet, you are the owner of your coin, unlike on custodial wallets and exchanges that you are not the owner because the keys are not yours.

See the interesting news:
https://cointelegraph.com/news/wyre-imposes-up-to-a-90-withdrawal-limit-for-all-users

Wyre users are able to withdraw, but they can only withdraw 90% of their money. Assuming you have $1000 on the exchange, you can not be able to withdraw $100 and Wyre users will be panicking about their money by now. Can you see that the more money they have on Wyre, the more money they can not be able to withdraw. On noncustodial wallet, you can send all your coins on the wallet at anytime.

Many centralized exchanges including Binance halted withdrawal of particular coin for a while and they mention it as maintenance or something temporary suspension so every exchange face this and probably actual maintenance is going or they are facing some regulatory actions so they put limitations but whenever you're deposited the funds into a centralized exchange or even bank the money is not in your control anymore.
legendary
Activity: 1778
Merit: 1474
🔃EN>>AR Translator🔃
So they're only stealing 10% of your money. They should call it a bail-in, that's what banks would do.

This is a really strange decision, especially since the platform will officially stop working after offering to buy it from the Bolt platform, as most reports indicate. On the other hand, the decision seems somewhat absurd because the procedure applies to the rate of daily withdrawals, meaning that the user can withdraw 90 percent of his savings, then within the next 24 hours withdraw another 90 percent of the remaining amount, and so on until there is nothing left. But the situation will be more complicated if the daily withdrawal rate does not exceed a certain limit, meaning if you have 5 bitcoins and the daily withdrawal limit is 1 bitcoin, you will be able to withdraw the full amount within about a week. This is very suspicious.
hero member
Activity: 1659
Merit: 687
LoyceV on the road. Or couch.
So they're only stealing 10% of your money. They should call it a bail-in, that's what banks would do.
sr. member
Activity: 378
Merit: 258
Lohamor Family
I will advice customers to withdraw the 90% funds left in the payment platform, in other for them not to come up with another scam or hack stories,because it is like they are about to crash due to insufficient funds on the platform. Everyday we keep on seeing platforms crashing due to mismanagement and customers using these exchanges or platforms lost at the long run,this is enough lesson for crypto users to know that a noncustodial wallet is your own personal bank and only you can keep your coins safe. Trust no centralized system no matter their level of operation and for how long they have gained customers trust.
sr. member
Activity: 1554
Merit: 413
....Man, I don't want to make quick conclusions, but this really smells like insolvency.
Well.... https://www.axios.com/2023/01/03/wyre-shutdown-crypto-winter

Scaling back operations certainly means they are being hit by heavy losses and likely running out of cash. Also reported in that article is the failed deal to purchase the said payment platform for $1.5 Billion last April 2022. Anyone following the news should have expected this move by Wyre to avoid a complete shutdown.
mk4
legendary
Activity: 2870
Merit: 3873
Paldo.io 🤖
"We are modifying our withdrawal policy. While customers will continue to be able to withdraw their funds, at this time, we are limiting withdrawals to no more than 90% of the funds currently in each customer account, subject to current daily limits."

Man, I don't want to make quick conclusions, but this really smells like insolvency. You can slightly justify having a set amount of daily withdrawal limits due to regulatory reasons, but having a set percentage? That's just too fishy imo.
hero member
Activity: 1498
Merit: 785
Wyre users are able to withdraw, but they can only withdraw 90% of their money. Assuming you have $1000 on the exchange, you can not be able to withdraw $100 and Wyre users will be panicking about their money by now. Can you see that the more money they have on Wyre, the more money they can not be able to withdraw. On noncustodial wallet, you can send all your coins on the wallet at anytime.

Previously it was also the same as Juno urging its users to withdraw due to uncertainty whereas they involved Wyre as a partner who could control this.
Source: https://cointelegraph.com/news/crypto-firm-juno-urges-users-to-withdraw-after-uncertainty-with-custody-partner

As for this news and it's true that Wyre is having a problem so users who want to withdraw at 90% limit this will be their panic but I don't know what the problem is but what is clear from the tweet is making an important change in management.

It is clear from the previous case that exchanges are vulnerable to our assets, so don't ever trust them, even though they have been operating for a long time, if our assets on the exchange are not ours.

But still there are always people who believe in the exchange. huh
legendary
Activity: 1064
Merit: 1298
Lightning network is good with small amount of BTC
It's so bad to hold one's crypto in any decentralized wallet, this is part of the repercussion.
You have a very good post but you make a mistake, I guess you are talking about custodial wallet and centralized exchanges, that we should not save crypto on them, instead we should use noncustodial wallet which is what we are talking about. On decentralized exchanges, you can send coin from your noncustodial wallet and receive the coin you exchange for on noncustodial wallet, they are not the same as centralized exchanges. What we against is that people should not save their coins are centralized exchanges and custodial wallets because you do not have the keys. We can not say a wallet is decentralized, if we have to say that, it means we should refer to those wallets that you run your node like bitcoin core.
hero member
Activity: 826
Merit: 641
Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform
Another big lesson indeed! Well, thank goodness that I already know BTT, I would have been a victim of such as close as early last year. It's so bad to hold one's crypto in any centralized/custodial exchange/wallet, this is part of the repercussions. For those looking for trusted wallets, @theymos advice here will do a lot of good: https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/m.61293646

And for clarity, this (Wyre) is not an exchange but a payment platform, it's clearly stated in the article. Can you imagine having $20,000 in such a payment platform and waking up to the news as shown in the image below:



It's just yesterday's event, so new. This is a company that was founded in 2013 and has built the trust of many, only to swindle them with their money when perhaps the amount to gain through it is now much. This is preposterous, unfortunately, such would continue to happen unabated. And see what I found on Google while inquiring about the Wyre company with some search words.



The company has processed over $1 billion as of October 2020, how much more thereafter?

This is why I like to advocate for more regulation of cryptocurrency, particularly the centralised ones so that anyone would not just cheat people under any guise and go away with it.

legendary
Activity: 1064
Merit: 1298
Lightning network is good with small amount of BTC
I do not know if Wyre is a custodial wallet or an exchange. I decided to post this on beginners and help for the beginners to learn another lesson which is not new again. But moderator can decide to move it to the appropriate board.

This is not about hack but it is about not you key not your coin. On noncustodial wallet, you are the owner of your coin, unlike on custodial wallets and exchanges that you are not the owner because the keys are not yours.

See the interesting news:
https://cointelegraph.com/news/wyre-imposes-up-to-a-90-withdrawal-limit-for-all-users

Wyre users are able to withdraw, but they can only withdraw 90% of their money. Assuming you have $1000 on the exchange, you can not be able to withdraw $100 and Wyre users will be panicking about their money by now. Can you see that the more money they have on Wyre, the more money they can not be able to withdraw. On noncustodial wallet, you can send all your coins on the wallet at anytime.
Jump to: