Topic: Another signature campaign with plagiarism (Read 330 times)
It's one thing that yahoo is ok about the plagiarism of the same rules for the campaign but it is another when we are talking about the rules here in the forum. Since they have copied a post even if it is partially I think it would still qualify as plagiarism here in the forum and the campaign manager should be banned. Only problem if this happens really is the sig campaign for this project won't continue anymore since if they create a new account it would count towards ban evasion. It's the first time I am seeing this kind of case so I don't know how the mods will handle this since it's only rules we are talking about and literally anyone can have the same rules for their campaign.
Also i would like to add that if he has copy pasted the rules, he should implement them just as Yahoo do and select only the quality participants and also check the post quality.
I,m not judging SBOSS here or anything but do you really think that someone who was too lazy to set and write his own campaign rules and copy-pasted someone else's work can manage a sig campaign ptoperly and apply high standards!Check all the campaign managers rules, they all are almost same.
yes, all campaigns have almost the same rules but here the rules were copied word for word. However, I don't think it's a ban-worthy offence.
Although this should never be done, no one should copy ans paste the campaign rules as other, it is more or less are same for almost all the campaigns. So, calling it as a plagiarism wouldn't be a good idea I think. Check all the campaign managers rules, they all are almost same.
Since yahoo62278 have no problem so there is no problem IMO, but this isn't appreciated. Copy paste word to word wouldn't be a wise decision, for this job a manager should ask original owner. I have remembered one of my client has created a signature which was similar of yahoo62278's campaign. So I had asked yahoo62278 and he had referred to signature designer. Eventually I was disagree to use that signature and team has created another new code. That's how should handle such as copy paste.
Also i would like to add that if he has copy pasted the rules, he should implement them just as Yahoo do and select only the quality participants and also check the post quality. If he is managed to do all this and come up with the same standards as of Manager Yahoo, then it will be appreciated by all of us.
Technically, the user should be banned for plagiarizing content, but usually those who get banned for plagiarism are the ones who try to earn from signature campaigns. This is to start a campaign in itself. Also, this has happened before and I don't know if anyone has gotten banned for plagiarizing the rules. Report the post and see what happens.
And yahoo has no say over the permaban itself, but it would have been sensible if they asked for Yahoo's permission and put a note saying so.
I think context has to be taken in these instances because the member is not trying to steal content and pass it off as their own which is what plagiarism is and that is what the plagiarism rule is there for to prevent people stealing other peoples work. Copying terms and conditions or using terms of services of other companies as a template is common and most companies use a template for this. I don't think the member should be banned and I don't think its too big of a deal for copying the rules. And yahoo has no say over the permaban itself, but it would have been sensible if they asked for Yahoo's permission and put a note saying so.
For me, the only copied thing is the layout and how it was posted. That's the wrong part.
But for the rules, somehow it was in general even we say they used the same word.
Good thing, they are running a legit campaign, and payments were escrowed. Maybe just PM the manager there to make changes in their formatting.
For me, the only copied thing is the layout and how it was posted. That's the wrong part.
But for the rules, somehow it was in general even we say they used the same word.
Good thing, they are running a legit campaign, and payments were escrowed. Maybe just PM the manager there to make changes in their formatting.
Technically, the user should be banned for plagiarizing content, but usually those who get banned for plagiarism are the ones who try to earn from signature campaigns. This is to start a campaign in itself. Also, this has happened before and I don't know if anyone has gotten banned for plagiarizing the rules. Report the post and see what happens.
And yahoo has no say over the permaban itself, but it would have been sensible if they asked for Yahoo's permission and put a note saying so.
And yahoo has no say over the permaban itself, but it would have been sensible if they asked for Yahoo's permission and put a note saying so.
Hmm, Yes Yahoo doesn't mind using its rules.
In fact, I don't see anything criminal here, which is just as well.
A person may not quite know the rules of this forum and how to properly handle them, so I borrowed the rules from yahoo.
But he is wrong in one case, he did not ask yahoo about it as the Coolcryptovator said. And it was rude of him.
Plagiarism is when you steal content, but not in this case. I think it's better to close the topic and forget it.
In fact, I don't see anything criminal here, which is just as well.
A person may not quite know the rules of this forum and how to properly handle them, so I borrowed the rules from yahoo.
But he is wrong in one case, he did not ask yahoo about it as the Coolcryptovator said. And it was rude of him.
Plagiarism is when you steal content, but not in this case. I think it's better to close the topic and forget it.
Since yahoo62278 have no problem so there is no problem IMO, but this isn't appreciated. Copy paste word to word wouldn't be a wise decision, for this job a manager should ask original owner. I have remembered one of my client has created a signature which was similar of yahoo62278's campaign. So I had asked yahoo62278 and he had referred to signature designer. Eventually I was disagree to use that signature and team has created another new code. That's how should handle such as copy paste.
Rules aren't really copyrighted or trademarked. Looks like either a newer manager or a company looking to run their own campaign and they used my rules as a guideline to go off of.
Most campaigns have quite a few of the same rules. I've used the same rules for the last 5 years pretty much, with a few tweaks here and there depending on the companies input. I'm not really upset if a company decides to copy my rules. I'd rather they pm me and ask if they're going to post word for word, but it's not required.
Other option is to just hire me and not worry about it
Most campaigns have quite a few of the same rules. I've used the same rules for the last 5 years pretty much, with a few tweaks here and there depending on the companies input. I'm not really upset if a company decides to copy my rules. I'd rather they pm me and ask if they're going to post word for word, but it's not required.
Other option is to just hire me and not worry about it
A new signature campaign is just launched by copying contents from Yahoo : ***Crypto Exchange Software – Signature Campaign***(Member-Legend Accepted)*Open
Archived.
Is there any chances for Yahoo to grand permission to copy their terms and conditions. Even if it is copied for business purposes, forum rules allow under plagiarism guidelines? AFAIK plagiarism will lead to perma ban.
* Posts must be constructive and on topic.
* 75 characters minimum.
*
*
* Users who are not posting enough to qualify for weekly pay can be removed with no warnings.
* 1 bitcoin talk account per person(If you are found to be enrolling alts you will be removed without pay)
* If you receive negative trust while enrolled, the issue will be looked at and could disqualify you from being paid.
* If you’re placed on SMAS blacklist during your time enrolled you will not be paid.
* You should not advertise any other sites in your signatures.
* Posts in any signature campaign or bounty threads will not count.
* Users should not change payment Addresses. You will use the same BTC Address the whole campaign.
* Posts in Games, Off-topic, Lending, Auctions, Politics, Beginners help and Archival will not count.
* 75 characters minimum.
*
*
* Users who are not posting enough to qualify for weekly pay can be removed with no warnings.
* 1 bitcoin talk account per person(If you are found to be enrolling alts you will be removed without pay)
* If you receive negative trust while enrolled, the issue will be looked at and could disqualify you from being paid.
* If you’re placed on SMAS blacklist during your time enrolled you will not be paid.
* You should not advertise any other sites in your signatures.
* Posts in any signature campaign or bounty threads will not count.
* Users should not change payment Addresses. You will use the same BTC Address the whole campaign.
* Posts in Games, Off-topic, Lending, Auctions, Politics, Beginners help and Archival will not count.
Archived.
Posts must be constructive and on topic
75 characters minimum
Users not posting enough to qualify for weekly pay can be removed with no warning
1 bitcointalk account per person(If you are found to be enrolling alts you and your alt are kicked out with no pay)
If you receive neg trust while enrolled, the offense will be looked at and could disqualify you from being paid.
If youre placed on SMAS blacklist during your time enrolled you will not be paid
You may not advertise any other sites in your signatures
Posts in any sig campaign or bounty threads will not count
Users will not rank up unless I announce there is an available opening
Users may not change payment Addresses. You will use the same Address the whole campaign
Posts in Games & Rounds, Off topic, Lending, Auctions, Politics & Society, Beginners and help,Tokens, or Archival will not count
75 characters minimum
Users not posting enough to qualify for weekly pay can be removed with no warning
1 bitcointalk account per person(If you are found to be enrolling alts you and your alt are kicked out with no pay)
If you receive neg trust while enrolled, the offense will be looked at and could disqualify you from being paid.
If youre placed on SMAS blacklist during your time enrolled you will not be paid
You may not advertise any other sites in your signatures
Posts in any sig campaign or bounty threads will not count
Users will not rank up unless I announce there is an available opening
Users may not change payment Addresses. You will use the same Address the whole campaign
Posts in Games & Rounds, Off topic, Lending, Auctions, Politics & Society, Beginners and help,Tokens, or Archival will not count
Is there any chances for Yahoo to grand permission to copy their terms and conditions. Even if it is copied for business purposes, forum rules allow under plagiarism guidelines? AFAIK plagiarism will lead to perma ban.
Jump to: