Asus DUAL-RX580-O8G VS MSI RX 580 GAMING X 8G?

lsszmeja

newbie

Activity: 13

Merit: 0

Quote from: BustyKuroNeko on June 08, 2017, 12:59:19 PM

Thank you and also great config running them at 30.5mhs with those fan speed. But I am curious about the temps you are getting off of them.

Open air gets to about 70C with fans at 50 to 60%
With a closed case the airflow works better n temps are about 40 to 50C Case fans do the work

Mattthev

sr. member

Activity: 966

Merit: 359

👉MINING-BIOS.eu💲⛏

Quote from: nixx on June 09, 2017, 09:20:45 AM

Which aspect did I push too much? I see many people running 2100+ memory clock and this card is 2000 out of the box.

I did not reinstall drivers. I will do that tonight when I get home if that's a missing step

Some people also have fallen from 10m and do not hurt yourself, but I think I still wont do that.

I had Asus Dual, it wasn't even able run stock clocks...

There is no reason clocking memory to speed of light... tighter timing makes biggest difference.

nixx

newbie

Activity: 16

Merit: 0

Quote from: Mattthev on June 09, 2017, 05:45:06 AM

Quote from: nixx on June 08, 2017, 07:01:56 PM

I just bought two of the MSI 580 Gaming X and one plus version.

On the non-plus - stock they ran about 22mhs. I modded and got 25mhs.

For some reason ANY modification to the memory clock COMPLETELY DESTROYS mhs. At 2000 I get 25 mhs, bump to 2050 and it falls to 18mhs. Slowly ramping up I might get up to 20 mhs until 2100+ will crash the card.

I have no idea wtf is wrong. I tried both MSI afterburner and wattman. I tried oc the memory with no other adjustments and as soon as I touch the memory clock, mhs falls like a rock. This happened with stock and modded bios.

If anyone has any ideas, please give me one. Oh - and I have hynix memory

I haven't tried modding the plus version yet. It runs 24.5mhs stock, but temps are insane. Like 85c already.

You pushed too much. Hynix can't handle this much overclock.
Also did you reinstall drivers after flash?

Which aspect did I push too much? I see many people running 2100+ memory clock and this card is 2000 out of the box.

I did not reinstall drivers. I will do that tonight when I get home if that's a missing step

spyshagg

full member

Activity: 176

Merit: 100

Quote from: BustyKuroNeko on June 09, 2017, 08:51:44 AM

Didn't think hynix vram was that bad...

Its not

Use these timings

777000000000000022339D00CE515A3D9055111230CB440900400600740114206A8900A00200312 0100F292F94273116

25.4 mh/s @ 1750mhz
28.7 mh/s @ 2000mhz

cheers

BustyKuroNeko

full member

Activity: 125

Merit: 100

Canadian Miner Passing Through~~

Didn't think hynix vram was that bad...

Mattthev

sr. member

Activity: 966

Merit: 359

👉MINING-BIOS.eu💲⛏

Quote from: nixx on June 08, 2017, 07:01:56 PM

I just bought two of the MSI 580 Gaming X and one plus version.

On the non-plus - stock they ran about 22mhs. I modded and got 25mhs.

For some reason ANY modification to the memory clock COMPLETELY DESTROYS mhs. At 2000 I get 25 mhs, bump to 2050 and it falls to 18mhs. Slowly ramping up I might get up to 20 mhs until 2100+ will crash the card.

I have no idea wtf is wrong. I tried both MSI afterburner and wattman. I tried oc the memory with no other adjustments and as soon as I touch the memory clock, mhs falls like a rock. This happened with stock and modded bios.

If anyone has any ideas, please give me one. Oh - and I have hynix memory

I haven't tried modding the plus version yet. It runs 24.5mhs stock, but temps are insane. Like 85c already.

You pushed too much. Hynix can't handle this much overclock.
Also did you reinstall drivers after flash?

nixx

newbie

Activity: 16

Merit: 0

I just bought two of the MSI 580 Gaming X and one plus version.

On the non-plus - stock they ran about 22mhs. I modded and got 25mhs.

For some reason ANY modification to the memory clock COMPLETELY DESTROYS mhs. At 2000 I get 25 mhs, bump to 2050 and it falls to 18mhs. Slowly ramping up I might get up to 20 mhs until 2100+ will crash the card.

I have no idea wtf is wrong. I tried both MSI afterburner and wattman. I tried oc the memory with no other adjustments and as soon as I touch the memory clock, mhs falls like a rock. This happened with stock and modded bios.

If anyone has any ideas, please give me one. Oh - and I have hynix memory

I haven't tried modding the plus version yet. It runs 24.5mhs stock, but temps are insane. Like 85c already.

BustyKuroNeko

full member

Activity: 125

Merit: 100

Canadian Miner Passing Through~~

Quote from: Mattthev on June 08, 2017, 02:20:14 PM

Quote from: BustyKuroNeko on June 08, 2017, 09:23:52 AM

Hi,
I am about to place an order for some GPU's but wanted to know which one of these is better?
Asus DUAL-RX580-O8G 244.62$ USD
MSI RX 580 GAMING X 8G 267.70$ USD

I read that the msi run cooler but i never had a msi so i cant vouch for them but i had some asus and those are okay.
If this matters, I would prefer a card that runs colder and can be tuned for the lowest power consumption.

Thanks

Dual are the bad! The cooling is awful. Card quality is like lottery. I have 1 it's running great lowest voltages on same clocks, but the second wasn't even able run at stock settings... 69° and it was crashing...
I've just bought MSI RX 480 Gaming X 4G so will let you know how it is, I will have it next week.

Well really good to know that the asus dual has lower standards
Lets keep this going Grin

Mattthev

sr. member

Activity: 966

Merit: 359

👉MINING-BIOS.eu💲⛏

Quote from: BustyKuroNeko on June 08, 2017, 09:23:52 AM

Hi,
I am about to place an order for some GPU's but wanted to know which one of these is better?
Asus DUAL-RX580-O8G 244.62$ USD
MSI RX 580 GAMING X 8G 267.70$ USD

I read that the msi run cooler but i never had a msi so i cant vouch for them but i had some asus and those are okay.
If this matters, I would prefer a card that runs colder and can be tuned for the lowest power consumption.

Thanks

Dual are the bad! The cooling is awful. Card quality is like lottery. I have 1 it's running great lowest voltages on same clocks, but the second wasn't even able run at stock settings... 69° and it was crashing...
I've just bought MSI RX 480 Gaming X 4G so will let you know how it is, I will have it next week.

mettalmag

legendary

Activity: 1084

Merit: 1003

≡v≡

Quote from: BustyKuroNeko on June 08, 2017, 02:04:03 PM

Well i don't have them yet "there's a 22 day lead time" but if i can actually get some i will gladly tell you and also ask that you mention me so i can get some sweeter deals later on Grin

As for me I managed to get 570 4G gigabyte gaming editions and they are great, got 29Mh/s on eth but only on solo with claymore, it's so sad I have only two of them, but still great deal

BustyKuroNeko

full member

Activity: 125

Merit: 100

Canadian Miner Passing Through~~

Well i don't have them yet "there's a 22 day lead time" but if i can actually get some i will gladly tell you and also ask that you mention me so i can get some sweeter deals later on Grin

mettalmag

legendary

Activity: 1084

Merit: 1003

≡v≡

where are you finding those GPUs

BustyKuroNeko

full member

Activity: 125

Merit: 100

Canadian Miner Passing Through~~

Thank you and also great config running them at 30.5mhs with those fan speed. But I am curious about the temps you are getting off of them.

lsszmeja

newbie

Activity: 13

Merit: 0

Quote from: BustyKuroNeko on June 08, 2017, 09:23:52 AM

Hi,
I am about to place an order for some GPU's but wanted to know which one of these is better?
Asus DUAL-RX580-O8G 244.62$ USD
MSI RX 580 GAMING X 8G 267.70$ USD

I read that the msi run cooler but i never had a msi so i cant vouch for them but i had some asus and those are okay.
If this matters, I would prefer a card that runs colder and can be tuned for the lowest power consumption.

Thanks

See reviews for 580x GPU's here

i just received 20 x rx580 MSI brand and they are hashing at 30.5mhs with the fans only getting up to 10 to 20%
still need a bit more tweaking as i wanna turn the voltage down more

BustyKuroNeko

full member

Activity: 125

Merit: 100

Canadian Miner Passing Through~~

Hi,
I am about to place an order for some GPU's but wanted to know which one of these is better?
Asus DUAL-RX580-O8G 244.62$ USD
MSI RX 580 GAMING X 8G 267.70$ USD

I read that the msi run cooler but i never had a msi so i cant vouch for them but i had some asus and those are okay.
If this matters, I would prefer a card that runs colder and can be tuned for the lowest power consumption.

Thanks

Topic: Asus DUAL-RX580-O8G VS MSI RX 580 GAMING X 8G? (Read 3732 times)