Best CPU and GPU choices for a mining rig?

bluedeep

legendary

Activity: 977

Merit: 1011

Quote from: btcgolong on June 22, 2017, 04:14:44 PM

Quote from: bluedeep on June 22, 2017, 06:12:53 AM

Quote from: wilkas on June 22, 2017, 12:54:22 AM

I have a RX480 that I would like to put on separate PC build from cheap second hand components. What is the cheapest/olded CPU that would not cause bottleneck? I think AMD is preferable as these were always cheaper.

Yeahh, AMD is a good option for "cpu mining" I'm using two FX 8350 with no problem, for more than two years. For GPU mining I recommend RX470 and RX480.

What are you mining?

Well, right now I'm not mining. Some technical problems. In the past I've been mined Magi, Monero, and other cryptonote currencies. Ahh I forgot about Hodl coin.

PS: I mean, CPU mining, for GPU mining I intend to mine some MNX ( right now I' mining ZEC , Ether, ZCL, Zen )

btcgolong

sr. member

Activity: 451

Merit: 269

Quote from: bluedeep on June 22, 2017, 06:12:53 AM

Quote from: wilkas on June 22, 2017, 12:54:22 AM

I have a RX480 that I would like to put on separate PC build from cheap second hand components. What is the cheapest/olded CPU that would not cause bottleneck? I think AMD is preferable as these were always cheaper.

Yeahh, AMD is a good option for "cpu mining" I'm using two FX 8350 with no problem, for more than two years. For GPU mining I recommend RX470 and RX480.

What are you mining?

bluedeep

legendary

Activity: 977

Merit: 1011

Quote from: Megaquake on June 22, 2017, 06:14:26 AM

Any good priced GPU's left? if not going to get some asic's

It depends what you want to mine. There are still a few coins which can be mined with GPU's and CPU's. Right now a good option is asic miner for DASH if you cand get one for a good price.

Megaquake

hero member

Activity: 630

Merit: 506

Any good priced GPU's left? if not going to get some asic's

bluedeep

legendary

Activity: 977

Merit: 1011

Quote from: wilkas on June 22, 2017, 12:54:22 AM

I have a RX480 that I would like to put on separate PC build from cheap second hand components. What is the cheapest/olded CPU that would not cause bottleneck? I think AMD is preferable as these were always cheaper.

Yeahh, AMD is a good option for "cpu mining" I'm using two FX 8350 with no problem, for more than two years. For GPU mining I recommend RX470 and RX480.

Heimer

sr. member

Activity: 518

Merit: 250

If you have money then simply buy Ryzen 1600 and mine with monero.

evader11

full member

Activity: 434

Merit: 100

Hexhash.xyz

Quote from: linklinklink on January 09, 2017, 06:27:03 PM

Hi everyone, just curious what your recommendations are for CPU mining and GPU mining.

For me, it depends on price of CPU and GPU.

wilkas

member

Activity: 104

Merit: 10

I have a RX480 that I would like to put on separate PC build from cheap second hand components. What is the cheapest/olded CPU that would not cause bottleneck? I think AMD is preferable as these were always cheaper.

Emoclaw

sr. member

Activity: 420

Merit: 251

Quote from: Biodom on January 10, 2017, 02:35:54 PM

Quote from: Cubirez on January 09, 2017, 10:41:19 PM

470 / 480 are the best choices currently.
If you've got cheap electricity you could also take a look to the Fury which is selling @ 260 usd on newegg and mining @ ~ 380 sol/s on ZEC makes it quite interesting.
However these don't perform as well on CN or ethhash so you have to rely on ZEC exclusively.

I also thought that 470/480 are the best, but you can get 1060 for $200 and it does 260-270h/s in ZEC and 22mh in eth and you can get a smaller (one fan) short unit, which is relevant for a minority who use PCs instead of large rigs.

It's not relevant really. All card sizes fit in most PC cases of todays market. The only exceptions being those REALLY tiny ITX cases which you can only fit an R9 Nano. But you wouldn't be mining with such a PC anyways, because temperatures are a huge issue then. Really, small graphics cards are too niche these days.

m1n1ngP4d4w4n

full member

Activity: 224

Merit: 100

CryptoLearner

Quote from: ccccccc7 on January 10, 2017, 02:32:18 PM

Quote from: Emoclaw on January 09, 2017, 06:38:36 PM

Right now, the RX 470 is the best value. It has the quickest ROI and is not much slower than the RX 480. However AMD's Vega GPUs are underway so if you're thinking of setting up a RIG right now, you should wait because they are right around the corner.
As for the CPU, the new Z270 platform is the best for multiple GPUs because it has 4 more PCIE lanes than Z170. Though right now there aren't any Kaby Lake i3s or Pentiums so you HAVE to buy an i5 7600K which is expensive. Alternatively you can get a Z170 but you'll have to search if the motherboard supports 6 GPUs because it's kind of a hit and miss, paired with an i3 6100 CPU (to avoid any bottlenecks that might occur with a Pentium).
If you don't want 4+ GPUs, any CPU + motherboard combo will do as long as there are enough slots.

Speaking STRICTLY for CPU mining, 4 Intel Xeon E7-8890 CPUs on a Supermicro X10QBL-4CT motherboard for a total of 96 cores and 192 threads, is the best choice.

Sorry but I am now curious to ask. How much, if at all, does your CPU affect the hashrate of GPU?

I have 3 rigs all with celeron g1840 (so I can't compare with anything myself) and I seem to get slightly lower hashrate that what other report on here etc and now I am thinking it may be because of this CPU is not as powerful as perhaps i3 or i5. This happens on zec and xmr, I have 1 rig with 6 GPU and 2 rigs with 2 GPU

CPU does barely nothing in GPU mining, even the cheapest CPU will be loaded @ like 25% average on a 6x gpu rig. If your cpu isn't 100% all the time, no way it will hinder gpu mining.

Biodom

legendary

Activity: 3892

Merit: 4331

Quote from: Cubirez on January 09, 2017, 10:41:19 PM

470 / 480 are the best choices currently.
If you've got cheap electricity you could also take a look to the Fury which is selling @ 260 usd on newegg and mining @ ~ 380 sol/s on ZEC makes it quite interesting.
However these don't perform as well on CN or ethhash so you have to rely on ZEC exclusively.

I also thought that 470/480 are the best, but you can get 1060 for $200 and it does 260-270h/s in ZEC and 22mh in eth and you can get a smaller (one fan) short unit, which is relevant for a minority who use PCs instead of large rigs.

ccccccc7

full member

Activity: 223

Merit: 100

Quote from: Emoclaw on January 09, 2017, 06:38:36 PM

Right now, the RX 470 is the best value. It has the quickest ROI and is not much slower than the RX 480. However AMD's Vega GPUs are underway so if you're thinking of setting up a RIG right now, you should wait because they are right around the corner.
As for the CPU, the new Z270 platform is the best for multiple GPUs because it has 4 more PCIE lanes than Z170. Though right now there aren't any Kaby Lake i3s or Pentiums so you HAVE to buy an i5 7600K which is expensive. Alternatively you can get a Z170 but you'll have to search if the motherboard supports 6 GPUs because it's kind of a hit and miss, paired with an i3 6100 CPU (to avoid any bottlenecks that might occur with a Pentium).
If you don't want 4+ GPUs, any CPU + motherboard combo will do as long as there are enough slots.

Speaking STRICTLY for CPU mining, 4 Intel Xeon E7-8890 CPUs on a Supermicro X10QBL-4CT motherboard for a total of 96 cores and 192 threads, is the best choice.

Sorry but I am now curious to ask. How much, if at all, does your CPU affect the hashrate of GPU?

I have 3 rigs all with celeron g1840 (so I can't compare with anything myself) and I seem to get slightly lower hashrate that what other report on here etc and now I am thinking it may be because of this CPU is not as powerful as perhaps i3 or i5. This happens on zec and xmr, I have 1 rig with 6 GPU and 2 rigs with 2 GPU

Cubirez

full member

Activity: 185

Merit: 100

470 / 480 are the best choices currently.
If you've got cheap electricity you could also take a look to the Fury which is selling @ 260 usd on newegg and mining @ ~ 380 sol/s on ZEC makes it quite interesting.
However these don't perform as well on CN or ethhash so you have to rely on ZEC exclusively.

eckmar

legendary

Activity: 1878

Merit: 1038

Telegram: https://t.me/eckmar

If you want to invest into CPU mining you will basically ROI never. I haven't seen a coin that could be mined with cpu and gave you some reasonable monthly profit because generally good CPUs are expensive and you are much better of forgetting about them in the world of mining and invest into gpu mining. Best gpu overall is RX 470 at this point

linklinklink

member

Activity: 68

Merit: 10

Thanks for the input EyeD and EmoC. Anyone else have some input? Thanks

Eyedol-X

hero member

Activity: 952

Merit: 508

7700K for CPU mining IMO

GPU's wait until RX500 series hits as RX480 price may drop.

CPU to watch for: AMD Ryzen -- might be good for mining.

Emoclaw

sr. member

Activity: 420

Merit: 251

Right now, the RX 470 is the best value. It has the quickest ROI and is not much slower than the RX 480. However AMD's Vega GPUs are underway so if you're thinking of setting up a RIG right now, you should wait because they are right around the corner.
As for the CPU, the new Z270 platform is the best for multiple GPUs because it has 4 more PCIE lanes than Z170. Though right now there aren't any Kaby Lake i3s or Pentiums so you HAVE to buy an i5 7600K which is expensive. Alternatively you can get a Z170 but you'll have to search if the motherboard supports 6 GPUs because it's kind of a hit and miss, paired with an i3 6100 CPU (to avoid any bottlenecks that might occur with a Pentium).
If you don't want 4+ GPUs, any CPU + motherboard combo will do as long as there are enough slots.

Speaking STRICTLY for CPU mining, 4 Intel Xeon E7-8890 CPUs on a Supermicro X10QBL-4CT motherboard for a total of 96 cores and 192 threads, is the best choice.

linklinklink

member

Activity: 68

Merit: 10

Hi everyone, just curious what your recommendations are for CPU mining and GPU mining.

Topic: Best CPU and GPU choices for a mining rig? (Read 18438 times)