Best darn idea since pool hopping! | Bitcointalksearch.org

muyuu

donator

Activity: 980

Merit: 1000

Quote from: DeathAndTaxes on August 20, 2012, 11:34:30 PM

You do realize that:
The payout address is part of the coinbase tx?
The coinbase tx is part of the merkle tree?
The merkle tree produces the merkle root?
The merkle root is one of the 6 components in the block header?
The specific block header is what is hashed and compared against the target?

Thus the found block hash is only valid for that EXACT block. Change any element of the block (like say the payout address) by even a single bit and the found block hash no longer "solves" the modified block.

TL/DR:
You didn't honestly think nobody thought of this till now right? I mean 4 years of mining and nobody, not a single miner said. Hey why give it to the pool when I can keep 50 BTC for me? If you could do this pools could do it to each other too. DeepBit takes every other miners blocks changes the reward address to their reward address and claims credit. Of course if you could change the coinbase you could change any tx so double spends would be trivially easy and the proof of work would be proof of absolutely nothing.

Quote

but they each still have the data leading up to the block.

There is no "leading up to a block". Each hash is unique and independent. Like a lottery ticket. The hash/ticket is either a winner (solves a block) or it isn't (worthless and thus doesn't improve the odds of any other hash).

End of thread.

Cannot be done as described.

ShadesOfMarble

donator

Activity: 543

Merit: 500

Because you are a bad person?! (why would somebody DDoS a pool?)

-ck

legendary

Activity: 4088

Merit: 1631

Ruu \o/

Quote from: Zotia on August 23, 2012, 07:24:12 PM

Is it possible to know if you are going to solve a block, then just not pass that information on to the pool's server (just to be a jerk)?

Yes, that's a withholding attack. But all you're doing is making the pool poorer. Why would you want to do that?

Zotia

hero member

Activity: 686

Merit: 501

TokenUnion-Get Rewarded for Holding Crypto

Is it possible to know if you are going to solve a block, then just not pass that information on to the pool's server (just to be a jerk)?

420

hero member

Activity: 756

Merit: 500

Quote from: DrG on August 22, 2012, 05:32:50 AM

Quote from: 420 on August 22, 2012, 03:29:49 AM

Quote from: DrG on August 22, 2012, 12:02:03 AM

Quote from: -ck on August 21, 2012, 09:33:40 PM

Further side note: cgminer DOES check for block solves when you are mining for bitcoin. It will say BLOCK! next to the share if it solves it, and will include block solves in the summary when you shut it down. However there is no way to magically make that block suddenly belong to your own wallet.

And here I was waving my hand saying "This is not the pool you want to submit to". Grin

which one? And I believe that is a picture of you as much as I believe mine is a picture of me.

Haha, not sure who Oat Hay is since I'm not into the meme stuff (didn't even know what meme was until learning about it here). The "chick" used for my avatar is Maggie Q - looks a lot like my wife. My 2 year was calling her mommy so I used her pic for my profile so I could get Freddie Prinz out of my head. If that reference doesn't make sense you probably weren't here when 1/2 the board had the same avatar as we were all whoring for 0.05BTC for changing out avatars.

bitcoiner on here created this meme with me about two days ago.

beautiful i bet she is.

interesting

DrG

legendary

Activity: 2086

Merit: 1035

Quote from: 420 on August 22, 2012, 03:29:49 AM

Quote from: DrG on August 22, 2012, 12:02:03 AM

Quote from: -ck on August 21, 2012, 09:33:40 PM

Further side note: cgminer DOES check for block solves when you are mining for bitcoin. It will say BLOCK! next to the share if it solves it, and will include block solves in the summary when you shut it down. However there is no way to magically make that block suddenly belong to your own wallet.

And here I was waving my hand saying "This is not the pool you want to submit to". Grin

which one? And I believe that is a picture of you as much as I believe mine is a picture of me.

Haha, not sure who Oat Hay is since I'm not into the meme stuff (didn't even know what meme was until learning about it here). The "chick" used for my avatar is Maggie Q - looks a lot like my wife. My 2 year was calling her mommy so I used her pic for my profile so I could get Freddie Prinz out of my head. If that reference doesn't make sense you probably weren't here when 1/2 the board had the same avatar as we were all whoring for 0.05BTC for changing out avatars.

420

hero member

Activity: 756

Merit: 500

Quote from: DrG on August 22, 2012, 12:02:03 AM

Quote from: -ck on August 21, 2012, 09:33:40 PM

Further side note: cgminer DOES check for block solves when you are mining for bitcoin. It will say BLOCK! next to the share if it solves it, and will include block solves in the summary when you shut it down. However there is no way to magically make that block suddenly belong to your own wallet.

And here I was waving my hand saying "This is not the pool you want to submit to". Grin

which one? And I believe that is a picture of you as much as I believe mine is a picture of me.

DrG

legendary

Activity: 2086

Merit: 1035

Quote from: -ck on August 21, 2012, 09:33:40 PM

Further side note: cgminer DOES check for block solves when you are mining for bitcoin. It will say BLOCK! next to the share if it solves it, and will include block solves in the summary when you shut it down. However there is no way to magically make that block suddenly belong to your own wallet.

And here I was waving my hand saying "This is not the pool you want to submit to". Grin

crazyates

legendary

Activity: 952

Merit: 1000

Quote from: -ck on August 21, 2012, 09:33:40 PM

Further side note: cgminer DOES check for block solves when you are mining for bitcoin. It will say BLOCK! next to the share if it solves it, and will include block solves in the summary when you shut it down. However there is no way to magically make that block suddenly belong to your own wallet.

Really?! Wow totally did not know that.

Vladimir

hero member

Activity: 812

Merit: 1001

-

Genius! All those hundreds of pros could not figure this out in years!

-ck

legendary

Activity: 4088

Merit: 1631

Ruu \o/

Further side note: cgminer DOES check for block solves when you are mining for bitcoin. It will say BLOCK! next to the share if it solves it, and will include block solves in the summary when you shut it down. However there is no way to magically make that block suddenly belong to your own wallet.

crazyates

legendary

Activity: 952

Merit: 1000

Quote from: DeathAndTaxes on August 20, 2012, 11:34:30 PM

You do realize that:
The payout address is part of the coinbase tx?
The coinbase tx is part of the merkle tree?
The merkle tree produces the merkle root?
The merkle root is one of the 6 components in the block header?
The specific block header is what is hashed and compared against the target?

Thus the found block hash is only valid for that EXACT block. Change any element of the block (like say the payout address) by even a single bit and the found block hash no longer "solves" the modified block.

TL/DR:
You didn't honestly think nobody thought of this till now right? I mean 4 years of mining and nobody, not a single miner said. Hey why give it to the pool when I can keep 50 BTC for me? If you could do this pools could do it to each other too. DeepBit takes every other miners blocks changes the reward address to their reward address and claims credit. Of course if you could change the coinbase you could change any tx so double spends would be trivially easy and the proof of work would be proof of absolutely nothing.

Quote

but they each still have the data leading up to the block.

There is no "leading up to a block". Each hash is unique and independent. Like a lottery ticket. The hash/ticket is either a winner (solves a block) or it isn't (worthless and thus doesn't improve the odds of any other hash).

I was just about to reply saying that mining software doesn't actually check to see if a hash is a valid block (that's the pools job), but it looks like someone mush more knowledgeable than me has already debunked the OP's little spurt of whishful thinking.

Side note: I've been mining for about 11 months now. I've varied anywhere from 0.03-1.5GH/s. Never found a block Cry

DeathAndTaxes

donator

Activity: 1218

Merit: 1079

Gerald Davis

You do realize that:
The payout address is part of the coinbase tx?
The coinbase tx is part of the merkle tree?
The merkle tree produces the merkle root?
The merkle root is one of the 6 components in the block header?
The specific block header is what is hashed and compared against the target?

Thus the found block hash is only valid for that EXACT block. Change any element of the block (like say the payout address) by even a single bit and the found block hash no longer "solves" the modified block.

TL/DR:
You didn't honestly think nobody thought of this till now right? I mean 4 years of mining and nobody, not a single miner said. Hey why give it to the pool when I can keep 50 BTC for me? If you could do this pools could do it to each other too. DeepBit takes every other miners blocks changes the reward address to their reward address and claims credit. Of course if you could change the coinbase you could change any tx so double spends would be trivially easy and the proof of work would be proof of absolutely nothing.

Quote

but they each still have the data leading up to the block.

There is no "leading up to a block". Each hash is unique and independent. Like a lottery ticket. The hash/ticket is either a winner (solves a block) or it isn't (worthless and thus doesn't improve the odds of any other hash).

Snapman

sr. member

Activity: 291

Merit: 250

BTCRadio Owner

Doesnt work like that... If your attempting for two sources, your hash power will need to be split. Work produced under one pool cant be submitted to another.

d3m0n1q_733rz

sr. member

Activity: 378

Merit: 250

Ever get that block solved that you wish you had been able to hold onto yourself?
Well, why not?
Solo mining won't accept the partial results that pools will, but they will accept the solved block. SO, why not have your miner mining for both your solo miner and your pool miner at the same time? Only, when you get that block solved, submit it to your solo miner for the full 50 BTC!
Yes, I know that this may cheat some pools out of BTC, but they each still have the data leading up to the block.
However, if done right, this might help to even the playing field for those with slow miners. Grin

Topic: Best darn idea since pool hopping! (Read 2735 times)