Isn't there a way to use fake data to create a transaction?
Use TestNet. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Testnet
Here is 2 faucets: https://coinfaucet.eu/en/btc-testnet/ http://bitcoinfaucet.uo1.net/
Topic: bitcoin multisig transaction (not able to sign) (Read 238 times)
Use TestNet. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Testnet
Here is 2 faucets: https://coinfaucet.eu/en/btc-testnet/ http://bitcoinfaucet.uo1.net/
Isn't there a way to use fake data to create a transaction?
When signing a transaction you need to have a valid previous output. So when you pass tx hex into your bitcoin-cli signrawtransaction function you need to get scriptPubKey from previous tx aka the transaction you are spending which in this case is df360<...>19b0 which you say is fake. So you can't really spend it!
I think this should be the right one (I am really not familiar with P2SH yet):
I think this should be the right one (I am really not familiar with P2SH yet):
Code:
a914dfef1d923975d18237d655068041f666ad2bd3e687
I'm working on a short multisig demo, for this demonstration I WONT USE valid transaction data.
Details:
User1
address: 18Vp4TR9ge77G6G5qc4duAt6CcTckJzeev
pubkey: 02ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9
privkey: L5ZQpAvvMVuMkbzu8FotsHAns6pXhsjXpQN76g3vGGTyPJ55yB7F
User2
address: 1LbhrdNvvw14nW725Zy5TepVm2vzinubQ9
pubkey: 026401fa4620e2bba87d60be6417e54088cdfefa6b82f34e23853ec12169bc64b4
privkey: Kx4pxXiUiTJJGUWHekkwSEidmRy76feqn2AJzhsUqhUtG6Ye4Bfo
---
random TXID (64 char long HEX string): df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0
vout: 0 (faked too)
receiver address: 1Lb4davQ5spNdtPD2Up2BkKk7M2cySqmJE
---
Using bitcoin-cli / bitcoind for this:
1.) generate multisig address:
2.) create a transaction (we can't use the reedemScript here at the moment)
0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 00000ffffffff0100c2eb0b000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb643 88ac00000000
3.) now signing this transaction (using https://coinb.in/#sign) with User1 key
returns
0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 0006b483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e0 0f02207a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9 e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9ffffffff0100c2eb0b 000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac00000000
4.) decode the transaction using bitcoind
returns
as you can see our reedemScript from the generated multisig address is NOT included
5.) try to sign this transaction now from bitcoin-cli (to make it "final") using the scriptPubKey 483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f022 07a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9e597c bcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9 from the decoded TX and the reedemScript from our generated multisig address (see above) and privkey of user2
returns
Any idea where things go wrong?
Details:
User1
address: 18Vp4TR9ge77G6G5qc4duAt6CcTckJzeev
pubkey: 02ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9
privkey: L5ZQpAvvMVuMkbzu8FotsHAns6pXhsjXpQN76g3vGGTyPJ55yB7F
User2
address: 1LbhrdNvvw14nW725Zy5TepVm2vzinubQ9
pubkey: 026401fa4620e2bba87d60be6417e54088cdfefa6b82f34e23853ec12169bc64b4
privkey: Kx4pxXiUiTJJGUWHekkwSEidmRy76feqn2AJzhsUqhUtG6Ye4Bfo
---
random TXID (64 char long HEX string): df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0
vout: 0 (faked too)
receiver address: 1Lb4davQ5spNdtPD2Up2BkKk7M2cySqmJE
---
Using bitcoin-cli / bitcoind for this:
1.) generate multisig address:
Quote
./bitcoin-cli createmultisig 2 "[\"02ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9\",\"026401fa4620e2bba87d60be6417e54088cdfefa6b82f34e23853ec12169bc64b4\"]"
returnsQuote
{
"address": "3N754Mmx9yy3EkywNZfaayxae1hWLjY8px",
"redeemScript": "522102ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c921026401f a4620e2bba87d60be6417e54088cdfefa6b82f34e23853ec12169bc64b452ae"
}
"address": "3N754Mmx9yy3EkywNZfaayxae1hWLjY8px",
"redeemScript": "522102ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c921026401f a4620e2bba87d60be6417e54088cdfefa6b82f34e23853ec12169bc64b452ae"
}
2.) create a transaction (we can't use the reedemScript here at the moment)
Quote
./bitcoin-cli createrawtransaction "[{\"txid\":\"df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0\",\"vout\":0}]" "{\"1Lb4davQ5spNdtPD2Up2BkKk7M2cySqmJE\": \"2.00000000\"}"
returns0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 00000ffffffff0100c2eb0b000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb643 88ac00000000
3.) now signing this transaction (using https://coinb.in/#sign) with User1 key
returns
0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 0006b483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e0 0f02207a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9 e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9ffffffff0100c2eb0b 000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac00000000
4.) decode the transaction using bitcoind
Quote
./bitcoin-cli decoderawtransaction "0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 0006b483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e0 0f02207a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9 e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9ffffffff0100c2eb0b 000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac00000000"
returns
Quote
{
"result": {
"txid": "fd21a05b0727388a76b24efb1fc50f01c4b57278719fd872a55c8938f4869637",
"hash": "fd21a05b0727388a76b24efb1fc50f01c4b57278719fd872a55c8938f4869637",
"version": 2,
"size": 192,
"vsize": 192,
"locktime": 0,
"vin": [
{
"txid": "df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0",
"vout": 0,
"scriptSig": {
"asm": "3045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f02207 a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d[ALL] 02ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9",
"hex": "483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f022 07a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9e597c bcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9"
},
"sequence": 4294967295
}
],
"vout": [
{
"value": 2.00000000,
"n": 0,
"scriptPubKey": {
"asm": "OP_DUP OP_HASH160 d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb643 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG",
"hex": "76a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac",
"reqSigs": 1,
"type": "pubkeyhash",
"addresses": [
"1Lb4davQ5spNdtPD2Up2BkKk7M2cySqmJE"
]
}
}
]
},
"error": null,
"id": null
}
"result": {
"txid": "fd21a05b0727388a76b24efb1fc50f01c4b57278719fd872a55c8938f4869637",
"hash": "fd21a05b0727388a76b24efb1fc50f01c4b57278719fd872a55c8938f4869637",
"version": 2,
"size": 192,
"vsize": 192,
"locktime": 0,
"vin": [
{
"txid": "df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0",
"vout": 0,
"scriptSig": {
"asm": "3045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f02207 a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d[ALL] 02ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9",
"hex": "483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f022 07a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9e597c bcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9"
},
"sequence": 4294967295
}
],
"vout": [
{
"value": 2.00000000,
"n": 0,
"scriptPubKey": {
"asm": "OP_DUP OP_HASH160 d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb643 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG",
"hex": "76a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac",
"reqSigs": 1,
"type": "pubkeyhash",
"addresses": [
"1Lb4davQ5spNdtPD2Up2BkKk7M2cySqmJE"
]
}
}
]
},
"error": null,
"id": null
}
as you can see our reedemScript from the generated multisig address is NOT included
5.) try to sign this transaction now from bitcoin-cli (to make it "final") using the scriptPubKey 483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f022 07a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9e597c bcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9 from the decoded TX and the reedemScript from our generated multisig address (see above) and privkey of user2
Quote
./bitcoin-cli signrawtransaction '0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 0006b483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e0 0f02207a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9 e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9ffffffff0100c2eb0b 000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac00000000' '[{"txid":"df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0","vout":0,"scriptPubKey":"483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f022 07a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9e597c bcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9","redeemScript":"522102ca9e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c921026401f a4620e2bba87d60be6417e54088cdfefa6b82f34e23853ec12169bc64b452ae"}]' '["Kx4pxXiUiTJJGUWHekkwSEidmRy76feqn2AJzhsUqhUtG6Ye4Bfo"]'
returns
Quote
{
"hex": "0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 0006b483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e0 0f02207a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9 e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9ffffffff0100c2eb0b 000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac00000000",
"complete": false,
"errors": [
{
"txid": "df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0",
"vout": 0,
"witness": [
],
"scriptSig": "483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f022 07a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9e597c bcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9",
"sequence": 4294967295,
"error": "Extra items left on stack after execution"
}
]
"hex": "0200000001b019a7903ca00dfe4ab54ba7c32059d3b4884ce424167f7cb75a0939e70b36df00000 0006b483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e0 0f02207a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9 e597cbcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9ffffffff0100c2eb0b 000000001976a914d6db903b985b5c08d802ed5a928435eeb35cb64388ac00000000",
"complete": false,
"errors": [
{
"txid": "df360be739095ab77c7f1624e44c88b4d35920c3a74bb54afe0da03c90a719b0",
"vout": 0,
"witness": [
],
"scriptSig": "483045022100c0667a1659de526e7f5bf877e4d14bb0f2b62da61540df1605cb35701b05e00f022 07a181731dac3898d24f714808a6671f11f2a17ff092728760c4c8932569aec8d012102ca9e597c bcbffca277b6adb4275b801cd3b915a8606df0efe4034230356494c9",
"sequence": 4294967295,
"error": "Extra items left on stack after execution"
}
]
Any idea where things go wrong?
Jump to: