Topic: Bitcointalk Merit Winning Methods & Proposals (Read 788 times)

With that being said,no one can honestly state that he/she probably didn't have "earning" at the back of their mind before joining up..
It just happens to be the way one goes about it that matters,its true we're here to discuss about the bitcoin,but that comes with an incentive to earn,thus if the forum is benevolent enough to grant such privileges then it should honestly be treated "sacred",but it's really bad spammers hardly see it that way..

I would like to keep this article up-to-date after a long period of time because I was unfortunately unable to show interest in the article. I don't want to go without commenting that there is an article open to comments, suggestions and any discussion.

Unfortunately, every newly opened membership does not open like you, and it is also known that many new members are multi-membership. I wish every individual who has opened up a new membership can think or think of it as a basic purpose, but there is also a fact that almost all of the new individuals become members with the enthusiasm to earn money here. It does not change according to the nationality of the individual, so it would be wrong to blame a group of nations. But I would like to emphasize again that many new memberships are being opened with enthusiasm for earning money or multi accounts of former members. For that reason, the situation you mentioned is not a good fit for generalization and I do not think it will be a long time. I wish everyone did not fight with spam comments even though you are a member with the aim of getting information as you mentioned.

As a newbie, the essence of joining this forum shouldn't be to make money. I have traversed the various sections of this site and I can say it's a school for anyone who is interested in gaining valuable knowledge about Bitcoin and the cryptocurrency industry in general. Taking out time to read posts and contributions from members with higher ranks is very important in the learning process. Good luck to us all.

Gaining information before income is earned and using it correctly will certainly contribute to better results. It is not possible to earn income unless there is information, and the users who register here with only the incentive of income are not very good either. For that reason, it is important to obtain information in the first stage, while income in the other stage will come automatically. The first plan should always be information exchange, the second plan must remain enthusiastic about earnings.

I do not really think it would be such distributions or applications on a monthly basis, because many members of the forum will misuse this system. When there are many bad uses such as swaps, sales, etc., it will be difficult to deal with these memberships again and the forum management will have to go to a new application again. For that reason, I think it is beneficial for the current system to continue this way. Of course it will be nice to have an increase in merit resources.

Reading to comprehend the inside out of this forum is keen for all newbies  .

Does anyone save me, I have read articles like this hundreds of times but still someone pulls it out to create more topics.

I think it would be good, if every member receives per month x smerits according to their rank. E.g. newbies 4, jr members 10, members 25, and so on. This would be in addition to the 1/2 smerits received when your posts are merited.

I like merit as a way to thank or like posts and it would be good if there is more merit in circulation and every user can like/thank posts that are useful to them. I see good posts often, but hesitate to give merit, in case I find a different post that I want to merit (low supply of smerits). With automatic monthly smerits this wouldnt be a problem.


I dont agree with these suggestions. Some people register to ask a question that they cant find in google or in reddit (other major bitcoin community) and to make these people wait almost 1 week to ask a question is unwelcoming. Bitcoin should be an open community for anyone who has interest in crypto, and forcing people to lurk 1 week before they can ask questions or contribute is counterproductive.

The most frequent mistake and the most annoying mistake of the new members are the ridiculous and empty messages they have written with the willingness to win. Beside the creation of unnecessary message pollution, there is no respect for labor and many subjects are filled with trash messages. Very rarely, there are some members whose content they produce is of extremely high quality and they have the value they deserve. I can also point out that I am not complaining with the system if I think that many new members have received a red notification with merit fervor. We need memberships that are really laboring and producing quality content, not ours, polluting the forum for three cents.

I appreciate this feature of merit points as I believe it will promote the qualitative content. However, most of the newbies are looking for the quickest ways to earn merits that results in the possibility of red feedback on their wall if they found guilty in the attempt of acquiring merit points in a wrong way. However, I believe that we should not completely restrict the ability to create content as that is the only way to gain merits in the case of the quality content. This feature is still new and hence it might take some more time to inculcate the habit of giving merit points to others for their quality posts and hence anyone should not stop sharing their knowledge just because they are not getting expected amount of merit from others.

You don't have to agree but it makes sense and fair to start from start. People abused the system before merit was introduced so they getting merit because of spams is one example of why this system should have reset for everyone.

The most ridiculous 2 comments made on this forum are probably these. Sorry, what kind of head do you have? Have you been holding your own memberships with members who have contributed to the labor and have contributed to the forum until this time? The old members, who had reached a certain level before the merit system, were here while you were away and were using this forum for information, not for money. Unless you go as far as paragliding, it will be much harder to get the systems and if everyone wishes to be limited to the merit system these conditions will be called. It is not a question of resetting the Merit system, but it is a great rudeness that you have to look down on the members of these people and see how much you are dismissed. If you spend a little effort, you can win something, but you can not make a profit by pretending like a vase. A little labor, then criticism!

I totally agree with you on this, so many people now making good posts but they don't get their right values because f this new system.
If they're making rules then it was better if they've reset it same for everyone.

Getting a merit? good luck. system leaves you at the mercy of others.

Reset everyone's merit to 0 and let them all start from scratch

I totally agree but most people see it as a way of making money through bounties but it is definetely not, you should contribute to the forum.

Well as i am new here i dont want shitposting,which is why i am one of those people who are happy with this new system as it is reduces the spam of those people who only wants to earn not to learn here.I have been reading for quite a while and most of the threads has some stupid comments though it is completely normal when we are talking about forums.I am looking forward to learn here,but i do think the spam level in this place is quite absurd.

It's a great post and i learned something new from it. Have been around for few months but unfortunately i mostly post under Digital Good section which does not brings any help to the community.
To be honest and frank, the merit system is great but not fair enough. "Rich becomes richer while the poor remains the same" - If you have a close look into forum, there are many threads, posts that is being posted by newbies but many of us don't pay much attention neither bother to praise them. Yeah, i agree with the fact that more than average posts that are being put up by newbies are spam or does not reflects any real help to the community.

Thanks for the tips dude. I enjoyed reading your topic, you had a great point. And for other people or for us to get merits, we should make an extra effort not just helping out other people. You need to emphasize what you are pointing out and you need some clearly executed explanations for you to get merits. Being knowledgeable of a certain topic is a must. Also english language is very important for an international communication thats why we need to be at the top of our english to clearly have an understandable communication. Build some good relation with other people here also.

Certainly these systems can be likened to each other. Both systems are being used as a reward mechanism. Members who produce quality content, useful messages and ancillary messages earn the benefits they already earn both monetarily and meritfully. For that reason I do not understand the people who oppose this system, usually they are labor thieves or stingy people. I do not have easy earning so easily now, I think it is necessary to dig it into their heads.

No, dude. The point or goal of having an account here is not to earn an income... While this forum is a good way to earn, that shouldn't be the overall end goal, but rather, a byproduct of being a good poster with genuine interest in the bitcoin field/industry.


That's actually a great comparison! Merit here is very similar to reddit gold in the sense of distribution and rewarding someone for outstanding content. Good reference!

That's similar ro reddit's gold it seems

Here, this is it! I wish everyone who opened a new membership in the forum thinks like you and does not create message pollution with ambition to earn money immediately. Oh, how beautiful would it be ... Members who think like you deserve it until the end to earn profit without noticing the rank. I hope that in a short time you can reach the rank you deserve and start to earn a good income.

This.

I don't know whether yours is a new account after having an existing account tagged for solely hunting merit, or you're an actual newbie who cares, but your statement, as simple as it is, hits the nail on the head.

Merit is a byproduct of great posts and activity on the forums, not a given right. A lot of members tend to believe that they have a RIGHT to 'earn' merits. This thought needs to be eradicated from people's minds.

For us newbies, perhaps before we try to hunt for merit I think it would be best if we should learn more about the forum and its cycle as a whole.

Although these details you mentioned may seem difficult for new members, we can be sure that there are important points in the forum that can prevent message pollution. Although new members will argue that these details are not fair, I would like to state that new memberships can not be held with old memberships. Old memberships were opened in the forum with the purpose of information exchange and used for this purpose. In addition, while these memberships produce extremely high quality content and comments within the forum, new members only produce meaningless messages. Especially for you to comment, I would like to mention that there are limited quality memberships in the forum recently.

In my 7 months here in the forum I've seen so many help topics to help and give new members ideas and gain ranks in the forum,I've also seen so many threads how many old members are so annoyed with how new users spam good topics in this forum.Now,I'm thinking of a way to somehow contribute even a little how we could fight spam post from new members.

These are just my suggestions,i hope it would be a help

1.New members should have a total activity time of 120-150 hours before they could start posting.(there are lots of developers and programmers in this forum,maybe they could help how to implement it in bitcointalk system).This would surely make new users browse the forum and read begginers related topic until they completed the given activity time.

2.After completing the total activity time,new users are limited to post 1/day only.Post allowed per day increase as the rank goes higher.(bounties exempted).

3.Before making a post,the system would ask the user,(something like captcha things)basic questions about bitcoin or anything related in the forum and the user need to answer it correctly before they can proceed.

4.Spam reported post should have penalties.Additional activity time or not allowed to post for some days or weeks.continous doing of spam activities may results for their account to be suspended or permanently banned from this forum.(way of the ironfist).

This may look unfair for new users and would really take them a lot of time to learn.But the time we would spend reading informative post here in the forum would give us great knowledge and advantage in our future crypto careers.

I hope my suggestions could somehow help the forum fight the overpopulated spammers in bitcointalk.

Everybody has different reason by joining this forum, the opinion of each topic of discussion and personality level knowledge of each person certainly cannot be equated, but I agree if it is useful to respect each others, regardless of whether the opinion of your post is useful or not.

Certainly, it is important to know your own personality and never to change that personality. This is an important detail and behavior that should be in our life not in the forum. We can earn merit in the way you mentioned in the forum, and we are getting respect in our real life. Do not sacrifice our own personality, stand behind our own thoughts and defend those thoughts will have given us a different authority. A person who does not change his person in any way means that he has already got good reputation around him.

I thought you'd suggest another proposal for the betterment of the forum as well as contribute to reduce shit post. But yeah, those three (Opening useful topics, help contents, and analysis,interpretation and forecasting) can possibly reward you with merit. I just want to add "being yourself", surely some members who like your personality and mentality would reward you with merit.

Thank you for your valuable comment. Of course, the subject can not be perfect with every detail, but I paid attention to the transfer of the article. Every detail is necessary for all users, thank you for your suggestions and recommendations.

Good informatiin, will surely look into this so as to earn

Not sure the giant Bitcointalk logos are entirely necessary... or are you trying to give yourself more credibility by making it look/sound like you're posting on behalf of Bitcointalk.org?

Unfortunately, there have been about a million posts on this topic... it's been covered fairly well, and your post doesn't really include any new information... and certainly doesn't contain any "fine details about merit winning methods and proposals".

If someone wants merit... it's pretty simple:

1. Don't spam
2. Don't post in mega-threads
3. Don't make redundant "me too", "i agree", "great project!" type posts.
4. Be helpful (this involves having knowledge, which requires that you read and learn!)
5. Try and make thoughtful, reasoned, well constructed posts that contribute to the conversation (same as #4 read+learn)
6. Humour doesn't hurt

Unfortunately, many users with Newbie membership are stray members. New individuals who learn that it is possible to earn money on this forum immediately open an account and write empty, unnecessary, ridiculous messages. For that reason, I do not think such topics are very useful to them. My first goal in creating this title is to create information sharing and really support the users who are working in the forum.

The Bitcointalk administration took a new step to change the rank system over the past few months, bringing the system "Merit". While this system has many improvements and deficiencies, it has reduced the spam comments in the forum to some extent. The unnecessary, ridiculous and irrelevant comments made by new members have become a serious problem in the forum in recent years. These people, who post messages for their signature campaigns, caused the message pollution in the forum, updating old subjects and getting useful information to disappear. The forum management decided to implement the system that gave the name "Merit" in order to get a little bit of these comments. Although this problem has not been solved completely, the number of people coming to earn money and multiple memberships have been reduced.


What is Merit?

Merit is just like the rep points we have encountered in Turkish forums. The first and most obvious difference of this system according to rep point system is that these merits can not be easily acquired. Winning a merit (sMerit) is also quite difficult, as winning a merit is quite difficult. There are also defined merit resources for the system cycle to stop. These resources can produce a certain number of merits per day and send them out. I do not extend much more information about this system than we can find on the main topic.

Opening Useful Topics

Merit is a must to open useful topics to win. We can earn Merit by sharing useful and informative content for users. Of course it will be very difficult to earn merit unless there are fine details, necessary explanations and important information in the topic title. Many details, such as special information, useful tactics, and more, are among the factors that will make Merit a winner.

Help Contents

Many members can not stop complaining about the fact that Merit can not win even though he has made several comments. I would like to give little information about this point which is among the biggest mistakes made. If written messages are out of the question, they are aimless and empty, or if they can not answer the questions asked by the subject, Merit is impossible to win. For that reason, we should make sure that when we make a comment, we should think carefully and produce the content and that the interpretation we write is plain and descriptive. It will be easier if you include examples in the explanations or make it easy to sample them.

Analysis, Interpretation and Forecasting

It is possible to earn Merit by making analysis, fatigue and forecasting, and presenting all this data with visual evidence. Of course, this factor will not be as effective as other factors, since any estimates, analyzes or predictions made will not have any share in accuracy. Whatever it is, it will be much better for you to add evidence to the comments made and, if necessary, keep the visual use at the highest levels.


All the data written in this article has been totally transferred according to my own thoughts and experiences. It is not quoted from any source. Anyone who wishes to write can publish it by stating that it is a quotation and showing the source address. I would like to remind you that the topic will be kept up to date as new experiences, information and ideas are learned.