Topic: BTC Segwit Address not recognised by my Ledger Nano S Wallet (Read 802 times)

do you think this would also be the case for RDH40's problem? did he ever say anything about pairing Ledger+Electrum?
his seed mnemonic might have been generated by electrum, which might also be a valid BIP39 Mnemonic phrase
so when he tried it on iancoleman's page it gives out the BIP39 version instead of Electrum version

One of the key differences is that the BIP39 spec (and by extension IanColeman tool) uses a passphrase of "mnemonic" + yourpassphrase... whereas Electrum uses a passphrase of "electrum" + yourpassphrase.

I was trying some Electrum seeds from bitcoin quest on iancoleman BIP39 page but the page keeps saying invalid mnemonic

I was thinking maybe the same seed works on BIP39 and Electrum might actually derives different addresses if it was generated by Electrum

Another interesting point is that the seed mnemonic davedee has is actually recognised as a "SegWit" seed by Electrum... Even though it is supposedly a BIP39 seed generated by a Trezor??!?

This leads me to believe that, at least in davedee's case,  the seed they have written down is actually an Electrum seed... and not the actual seed from their Trezor that generated the "3".

Don't give up, exhaust all possibilities. Did you follow the steps i told you to do?

@RHD40, i am still waiting for our reply , did you do exactly what i said? you should have recovered the coins by now, if not you can shoot me a PM.

Unfortunately no, and at this point I'm willing to give out my seed to anyone if they promise to send half back if they can recover the coins. I feel it's better than letting the coins sit there.

Unfortunately no, and at this point I'm willing to give out my seed to anyone if they promise to send half back if they can recover the coins. I feel it's better than letting the coins sit there.

Hi, you still have this problem?

Hi,

I tried this and it only shows my LTC transactions, nothing else. Also there is no option to 'go to the address tab' and look for any addresses.

Unless you tick the "remember my choice" option, the "Ledger Wallet Bitcoin" Chrome App asks on startup:



However, as it displayed a "3" type address (as proven by the posted photo)... the Ledger wallet should only have done this if the OP had selected "SegWit"... it's the only scenario in which you should get P2SH addresses from a Ledger wallet (even if you were using LTC prior to the change to "M" type addresses for LTC).

As things stand, I can only think of a few causes for this issue:

1. Previously unknown (but theoretically possible) malware that changed the "receive" address displayed by the older versions of the wallet. However, given that the 3.3 BTC has NOT been moved from that address, I'd guess that this is somewhat unlikely. Yes, I agree

2. It was actually an old LTC SegWit address using the "3" type addresses before Ledger upgraded. The screenshot says "BTC" but it might have been a graphical glitch in the older wallet... I can't confirm one way or the other as I can't get an old version of the wallet to test. If this is the case, it might be possible to use the solution provided by cryptonerddy. I tried this but nothing

3. Glitch with the derivation path used by the wallet. I've not seen another case of this before, but a lack of evidence does not disprove this theory.

4. The wallet that the address was generated from was NOT "Account 0"... but Account 1 or 2 etc. I'm unsure how likely this is... I believe the Ledger wallet shows an overview of ALL (used) accounts as the default dashboard... but still a possibility.

5. The wallet that the address was generated from was protected by BIP39 passphrase... OP claims they never used passphrase with this wallet (somewhat supported by the fact that they can see the BCH and LTC balances without needing to use a passprhase)

6. Something else... ? ? ?

It seems I'm doomed! Think we've run out of all possibilities!

@HCP you've tried to help him last time back in january
both of you might want to review what has been done and continue from that point

just pointing out some important points for clarification
- you resetted your ledger, written down the new 24 word seed
- obtained one BTC address & one LTC address and give them to your friend to receive some BTC & LTC
- both confirmed on its respective chain, but you no longer see BTC address in your ledger

just my thought on what you should check
- try iancoleman BIP39 with your old seed, I assume you've tried with new seed and not found
I don't have the old seed but I never obtained any addresses from this anyway - I never got that far
- is this 36ezRREz... address exist in your LTC receive address? (probably not but...)
No it doesn't
- then I'm pretty sure you have the wrong seed used (address was from old seed) or LTC/BTC mismatched use
The 24 word seed is definitely correct
- is it possible somehow your Mxxx LTC address was used and translated to its corresponding 3xxx address that you received on BTC chain
No this has not happened

I know all these suggestions sound far fetched,
but for 3.30941541 BTC you should try everything, even the unthinkable or impossible

Do this
Download Electrum LTC on your PC
Open it, click new wallet> standard wallet> i have seed> put the right seed there> click next then your wallet will be created. go to the address tab and look for this address MCs8jJexAf8UhxC4KgRneSayAx6Aincbbz
right click and copy the private key.
go to liteaddress.org click on the wallet details tab> paste the private key there. now copy the hexadecimal key given at the bottom of the page.

go to bitaddress.org, also go to the wallet details tab and paste the hexadecimal key there, it should give you two addresses and two different keys. copy the compressed private key and go to segwitaddress.org, scroll down to the last tab and paste the key there, you'll find that it matches the address.

now import the key into electrum and your coins would show

here's my address, leave a big tip 19Q2fJ2qEfLXnYpQU7eqAGCeucK8NVapw6

Is there a way on your ledger to turn on/off segwit address usage?

Hi, i know what your problem is and i will post the guide here on how to recover the coins, if you agree to leave a tip after you've claimed it?

---snip---
It seems that the ledger does not recognise the BTC Segwit Address it gave me for whatever reason.
---snip---
Since then I have learnt that the ledgers xpub does not match the BTC Segwit Address but it does the BCH & LTC - so how is this possible?

Do this
Download Electrum LTC on your PC
...

https://imgur.com/hxhaAfJ

Does this work?

As i said earlier i had the exact same issue with my trezor and the people  here gave me suggestions and it turns out i made an error with my seed phrase, don't give up and try to exhaust all possibilities. Do as they have suggested by posting an image here and i really don't see what the big deal is by posting the image, except you're wrong?

Ahhhhh this brings back memories... not sure why that thread feel off my notifications list? I never noticed that the OP had made the final reply??!? Apologies for that.

Right, I have to ask the obvious question then... Given that you were copying both LTC and BTC addresses... I assume you checked the LTC "sign message" list for what you believe is the BTC address?

Or used the iancoleman.io tool and set the coin to LTC with your seed and checked those addresses for what you think is the BTC address?

Then maybe tell us what you've already tried unsuccessfully? If you've already spent months with Ledger support, you probably should have led with that in the OP...

I did a ledger reset before I sent the 2 addresses to my friend but I don't think this is the problem as my LTC arrived fine.

No, I reset the ledger as I thought it wasn't working properly or I had set it up wrong. It gave me a new 24 word seed. Then I obtained both the BTC & LTC addresses separately - both SegWit. When I check my accounts on the ledger I always select the SegWit options as these were the addresses I obtained. When I got the addresses I got them from the 'Receive' option, not the 'Sign message' option in settings-tools.
Do you think my ledger could be damaged?

Its obvious you can't help me

My Ledger Nano S Wallet does not recognise the initial BTC Segwit Address that it initially gave me.

I transferred the BTC correctly to the Segwit Address given by my Ledger Nano S (Address beginning with: 36ez......) this transaction is confirmed on Blockchain, but for some reason does not show in my Wallet!

I have tried everything including re-setting the device, all the apps, chrome etc but still nothing.

I have also tried exporting the xpub and used iancoleman but this still doesn't produce the Segwit Address my Ledger produced!

I also can't seem to find anyone else who has had the same problem as me - can anyone please help?

Its obvious you can't help me and I have no idea how to post a photo on here. I can What's App it to you if that works?

BTW - When you see the screenshot of it and its correct - how can you help?

Actually that is exactly what posting the photo will prove... Because then we'll be able to know if the photo matches the address you have stated.

It will also show that the address you sent to was displayed within your Ledger wallet.

What you need to understand is that there have been numerous instances of users on this forum claiming that "it was typed 100% correct"... Only to discover later that in fact the password or recovery seed or address was in fact typed incorrectly.

At this moment, we only have your word for it. It's nothing personal, and given how adamant you are, I'm sure it's true... But a copy of the photo would prove it 100%

The address was not mistyped, it is correct. No need to try and post a photo, it won't change or prove anything I have not already stated.

You cannot post images because you are a newbie in this forum.
If you post the photo on some website like imgur.com, just link the address here and I will post for you.

An address can easily be mistyped....
o instead of 0 for example, S and 5, I and l

I never tried to type an address, always ctrl C + ctrl V.

I have no idea how to post the photo on here but this is the BTC Segwit Address:-

36ezRREzDYH3uSvADoSSpoLZrFVigQkmLp

Even if he say checking 5 times before sending,only one character wrong and this is not identical address.

So, they either entered the Bitcoin address incorrectly (although I'm not even sure what the odds of generating a valid address when mistyping an address are? )...

Although, using the "Signed Message" option, you can start typing an address and it shows the partial matches. ("Settings -> Tools -> Sign Message", click the "Address" box and type the first couple of characters of the address).

No

this is a known issue with ledger nano

I had a problem with missing transaction on Ledger app,but it was because I use one of the address from Sign Message option which is not visible to Ledger Bitcoin App,but it was still there and with increase gap address limit in Electrum problem is solved.

It is not possible that address is just disappear like it was never part of that seed...

OP it would be good to post that transaction and photo you take with that specific address.

To summarize it:

You have clicked on the 'receive'-tab on your chrome application, verified the address is correct (on your nano s), scanned the QR code and verified the address again?
And now you don't see the address in your nano s (and balance is also missing) ?

Is this correct? This seems odd. Are you sure you are still using the 'segwit-wallet' of your nano s (and didn't accidentally click on legacy) ?

Sorry I mistyped, QR code.
It's a picture that can be scanned to transfer funds without typing or copying pasting the address.

Ok, as you bought directed from ledger you were not scammed.

Did you use a passphrase? It's like a 25th word. You can unlock a second hidden ledger nano wallet using a different pin. Did you use that?
https://support.ledgerwallet.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000783134-How-to-set-up-and-or-recover-a-hidden-passphrase-and-alternate-PIN-on-your-Ledger-Nano-S-H

There is no problem regarding security when you copy and paste an address, because it's a public address and nobody can take your funds using it.

Exactly.

But when you take a photo, there is the risk you mistyped it... You could have used the we code at least.

I definitely did not mistype it. When you say we code - what do you mean?

Anyway,  have you tried to use iancoleman.io and recover that address privatekey? Yes
If it's not there, it's not part of your wallet and you mistyped it, or you were a victim of a phishing (if you bought from third party seller)

I bought it directly from Ledger.

If you have 24 seed words than you should update to latest firmware because of security vulnerabilities which have been found.Maybe with new firmware your problem can be solved,but I doubt this because of what you wrote.

Yes, it's not a firmware problem.

If address is not show under option "Sign Message", then it is not part of your wallet,and this we can conclude by the fact that you admit you never copy/paste that address which is usual and safe way to do that.You take that address in a photo,and then you typed it manually in the wallet from which you sent BTC to Ledger Nano S.

The BTC Segwit Address definitely came from my Ledger Nano S. It is impossible to make up an address, also the transaction is confirmed ob Blockchain. Copy and pasting the address is not the safest option.

If this is not a problem with wallet sync or outdated firmware,then problem is that you typed that SegWit address incorrectly.

The address was definitely typed correctly.

Please answer the following quetsions (to make it easier for us to help you):

• What versions are you using: Nano s firmware, bitcoin chrome application, bitcoin application (on the nano s)?
  
  I'm using firmware 1.3.1 - I have not updated my Ledger yet in fear of losing anything. I'm also using the standard Chrome Apps.
  
  
• Did you verify the receiving address on your nano s when clicking 'receive' in the bitcoin chrome app?
  
  Yes
  
  
• Does the address show up under 'Options' -> 'Tools' -> 'Sign message' from the drop-down menu?
  
  No
  
  
• Did you verify wether the copied(?) address from the receive-tab matched the address when pasted (to eliminate clipping malware)?
  
  I never copied or pasted the address, I took a photo of it and copied it correctly (checking 5 times before sending)
  
  
• Is this the 'first' time you are using your nano s? Did it work (without a flaw) previously?
  
  It worked fine when others were transferred on the same day (I also transferred BCH & LTC which were received ok).