Interesting that you are offering only those payment methods which are highly risky. If not PayPal, Venmo. Either or. No other options which are not reversible.
Then you have those little things which others might not notice:
https://i.imgur.com/pZKkdIY.png
An upper trade limit of EUR 450,000 by PayPal? So hypothetically if someone opens a trade to sell 28 bitcoins, you would be able to send them EUR 450,000 by PayPal?
On account of reviews from new accounts - they do not appear in the profile. In the profile you can see only the verified users.
I use PayPal and Venmo - as they are generally available and easy to use. If necessary - I can add Bank transfers within my country and cash.