Can this help in reducing spam? | Bitcointalksearch.org

edgycorner

sr. member

Activity: 1064

Merit: 382

Hurrah for Karamazov!

Quote from: Thirdspace on January 21, 2018, 05:00:20 PM

imagine a smart account farmer who managed to hold 10+ bctalk accounts rank senior
he could then get anyone in trouble just by targeting a user and tagging his posts as spam

Yup, farmers can misuse this to target accounts.
Then how about changing the period from 24 hour to 1 week.
One account can report the other only once a week.
And all the accounts will be checked by mods before a permanent ban.

Or allow only DT members to report a post as spam?

Edit:I don't think we need any solution. DT members are tagging all the shitposters. Kampai!

LoyceV

legendary

Activity: 3290

Merit: 16489

Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021

Quote from: The Sceptical Chymist on January 21, 2018, 05:18:30 PM

Quote from: LoyceV on January 21, 2018, 12:33:40 PM

I've seen several DT-members who start tagging spammers.

I'm doing this, and I'm trying to target the worst of the worst.

I saw your promotion, and I've been following the Reputation section a bit. Suddenly hundreds of accounts have red trust, and all of a sudden they start caring about the trust-rating you left them months ago. Since your promotion you've collected a shitload of retaliation feedback Cheesy

Quote

There are so many borderline shitposters, though, that I don't feel 100% comfortable tagging.

DT2 has the power to instantly destroy an account, and I've seen others tag accounts for much less.

Another thought: how about disabling signatures for anyone with enough red trust on DT2?

The Sceptical Chymist

legendary

Activity: 3500

Merit: 6981

Top Crypto Casino

Quote from: LoyceV on January 21, 2018, 12:33:40 PM

I've seen several DT-members who start tagging spammers.

I'm doing this, and I'm trying to target the worst of the worst. There are so many borderline shitposters, though, that I don't feel 100% comfortable tagging. It'd be so much better if staff would ban these idiots who are only here to earn money from campaigns, but I suspect that Theymos doesn't want them to do it. Hilariousandco has banned a lot, as has mprep...but they can't keep up!

Good job, LoyceV. Getting all those morons identified and nuked is a beautiful thing.

Thirdspace

hero member

Activity: 1232

Merit: 738

Mixing reinvented for your privacy | chipmixer.com

Quote from: edgycorner on January 21, 2018, 11:15:04 AM

Only user's above member(or a certain activity), can report a reply as SPAM. A reply can be reported only once by a user.
Each report will carry a different score(depending upon the rank of the reporter).
For eg:
A legendary/hero/Senior/Full members report will carry a score of 6/5/3/2.
Once a user's spam score reaches(or exceeds) a certain value(maybe 30 in this example) in a day, he/she will get a cooldown period of 7 days and won't be allowed to post on spam protected threads(below).
If a user gets more than 2 CDs in a month, then permanent ban?

imagine a smart account farmer who managed to hold 10+ bctalk accounts rank senior
he could then get anyone in trouble just by targeting a user and tagging his posts as spam

Quote

An addition of spam protection option in the "Additional Options" Sections:

and adding the "Spam Protection" option is like justifying regular threads as spamable threads

LoyceV

legendary

Activity: 3290

Merit: 16489

Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021

Quote from: valiant1 on January 21, 2018, 01:51:32 PM

To be honest I always wondered if my reports ever had any action on them, because I never received follow-up... so I stopped reporting people. Grin

You can check Deletion log to see deleted posts or banned accounts.

edgycorner

sr. member

Activity: 1064

Merit: 382

Hurrah for Karamazov!

Quote

1. Spam protection shouldn't be optional. If you want to stop spam in your thread, make it self-moderated. Anything else should be applied globally.

Yup, applying it globally makes more sense.

Quote

2. Not only Newbies spam, spam happens on higher ranks too. All Newbies who get through without being banned eventually get a higher rank.

All user can be reported regardless of their rank.

Quote

3. The "spam score" shouldn't be a fixed value, it should be a percentage of the posts a user makes. But even then, it can be abused. Suppose I don't like you: I'm Legendary, so I only need to report 5 of your 113 posts as Spam to get you banned for a week!

You can report someone only once in a day.And the score will reset after every 24 hours.

Quote

To be honest I always wondered if my reports ever had any action on them, because I never received follow-up... so I stopped reporting people

Exactly.
Mods aren't robots, it's impossible for them to ban every spammer.

valiant1

full member

Activity: 219

Merit: 121

Lethean Developer

Quote from: LoyceV on January 21, 2018, 12:33:40 PM

My 2 ~~cents~~ Satoshis:
1. Spam protection shouldn't be optional. If you want to stop spam in your thread, make it self-moderated. Anything else should be applied globally.
2. Not only Newbies spam, spam happens on higher ranks too. All Newbies who get through without being banned eventually get a higher rank.
3. The "spam score" shouldn't be a fixed value, it should be a percentage of the posts a user makes. But even then, it can be abused. Suppose I don't like you: I'm Legendary, so I only need to report 5 of your 113 posts as Spam to get you banned for a week!

I appreciate you trying, but most ideas have downsides too.

Quote from: edgycorner on January 21, 2018, 11:15:04 AM

This will help people to differentiate between a serious and a BS topic.

Ideally, this shouldn't be necessary. All topics should be serious topics.

My new personal favourite: report more posts than you make! In the past week I got about 800 accounts banned, on top of my "normal" reports.

Quote from: Chris314 on January 21, 2018, 12:33:39 PM

Or maybe give this option only to moderators or DT members?

Moderators already have a ban-button to deal with spammers, and recently I've seen several DT-members who start tagging spammers. If that happens enough, spammers may fear for their accounts and spam less!

To be honest I always wondered if my reports ever had any action on them, because I never received follow-up... so I stopped reporting people. Grin

LoyceV

legendary

Activity: 3290

Merit: 16489

Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021

My 2 ~~cents~~ Satoshis:
1. Spam protection shouldn't be optional. If you want to stop spam in your thread, make it self-moderated. Anything else should be applied globally.
2. Not only Newbies spam, spam happens on higher ranks too. All Newbies who get through without being banned eventually get a higher rank.
3. The "spam score" shouldn't be a fixed value, it should be a percentage of the posts a user makes. But even then, it can be abused. Suppose I don't like you: I'm Legendary, so I only need to report 5 of your 113 posts as Spam to get you banned for a week!

I appreciate you trying, but most ideas have downsides too.

Quote from: edgycorner on January 21, 2018, 11:15:04 AM

This will help people to differentiate between a serious and a BS topic.

Ideally, this shouldn't be necessary. All topics should be serious topics.

My new personal favourite: report more posts than you make! In the past week I got about 800 accounts banned, on top of my "normal" reports.

Quote from: Chris314 on January 21, 2018, 12:33:39 PM

Or maybe give this option only to moderators or DT members?

Moderators already have a ban-button to deal with spammers, and recently I've seen several DT-members who start tagging spammers. If that happens enough, spammers may fear for their accounts and spam less!

Chris314

sr. member

Activity: 672

Merit: 266

What about the abusers, accounts that bans every message to annoy some users? There should be a limit with number of posts reported, increasing with grade. Mods could have infinite report number, but anyone else haven't. Or maybe give this option only to moderators or DT members?

edgycorner

sr. member

Activity: 1064

Merit: 382

Hurrah for Karamazov!

I have thought of a way to discourage campaign spammers and might help the forum maintain its integrity.

An addition of spam protection option in the "Additional Options" Sections:

https://i.imgur.com/io5QP2B.png

Each reply on such spam protected topics will have an option of reporting it as a spam
https://i.imgur.com/uRyLaJG.jpg

Only user's above member(or a certain activity), can report a reply as SPAM. A reply can be reported only once by a user.
Each report will carry a different score(depending upon the rank of the reporter).
For eg:
A legendary/hero/Senior/Full members report will carry a score of 6/5/3/2.
Once a user's spam score reaches(or exceeds) a certain value(maybe 30 in this example) in a day, he/she will get a cooldown period of 7 days and won't be allowed to post on spam protected threads(below).
If a user gets more than 2 CDs in a month, then permanent ban?

Spam protected threads will stand out from other threads, maybe like this :

https://i.imgur.com/icfShm7.jpg

This will help people to differentiate between a serious and a BS topic.

Or we can apply this spam reporting globally, without the spam protection option.

Topic: Can this help in reducing spam? (Read 231 times)