It was indeed a litcoin-qt wallet that I used.
And the reason why opening the file in the wallet didn't work the first time was because I hadn't downloaded the blockchain, after seeing someone say I didn't need to. They were probably referring to an electrum wallet. It also helped that I had not encrypted the file.
So the issue was that i originally didn't use an electrum wallet at all and ended up confusing myself by renaming the original file litecoins.dat
Steps taken:
1. downloaded the litecoin-qt wallet
2. downloaded the blockchain which took about 8 hours
3. went to /Users/
4. replaced the wallet.dat file they had with my own wallet.dat
5. closed out litecoin-qt
6. reopened it with all of them there still
Thanks so much for all your help. Hopefully sheds some light for somebody in the future.