Topic: Centralized vs. Decentralized Exchanges: Which is Right for You? (Read 130 times)

Decentralised means no central authority so no one owns it and it's like running non profitable charity program so it's only community driven whereas centralized exchanges pump millions for advertisement itself because it's a profit making business for them.

As most others said the fees on DEX isn't lower either especially one who trades erc20 tokens knows it and that's why they prefer centralized exchanges if they are trading actively like too often so they can make money whereas in dex it's close to impossible to make a life out of trading there.

I actually love Dexes since I have played with Decentralized Finance a lot. But yeah most of the problem with Dex is limited by chain, and people start to made a wrapped version of anything to made available on those evm chain.

Tho some of Dex developer already figure it out to do transaction across the chain

Lower fees is not accurate.

The fees on using a decentralized exchange are not always low and depending on the chain, fees can go as high as more than $50 per trade similar to Ethereum during moments when there is high usage.

Also, agreed that limited liquidity might be a problem, however, if you are only a small minnow like me, this would not be that big of a problem. Lower liquidity also implies that tokens can pump higher than usual which would be very advantageous for us hehe.

In any case, small minnow traders in the forum should be encouraged to try DeFi and trade in decentralized exchanges. Trading low liquidity, high volatile tokens that are not listed in centralized exchanges are more profitable if you know what you are doing.

Very good point to add mate! Promotion is the major deal breaker in the cryptocurrency market. It is what the newbies see on the internet that they embrace. You cannot embrace what you are not aware of. To think of it, a truly decentralized exchange has no single team as the head or CEO, so it will be near impossible for there to be promotion for such a project.

Unlike the CEXes that pumps money into promotion. They wouldn't bother much because they make back the money in form of high transaction fees unlike DEXes whose transaction fees are small. So, I do not actually blame newbies when they embrace CEXes with their might. After all, I knew Binance before knowing this forum.

That's what stops me from using the decentralized exchanges. I've come across when the time of trading ERC20 tokens is like one of things that I do and I'm stuck on doing the transaction or not doing it. If I don't do it, I'll have to wait without knowing how long should I wait and if I do it, I'll have to pay and ignore the fees and I did it. Good thing that many of those known altcoins now can also be found in other chains like in BEP20/BSC which makes the fees lower.

Me either but convenience is stronger on this one for me.

This is very true. Not to mention that a lot of these CEXs invest a lot in marketing and they're doing a good job at it.
Take Binance for example, a lot of people who know little about Bitcoin think Binance are the owners of Bitcoin.
There are even people that have been in the crypto space for a while but they are still comfortably leaving their coins in a centralized exchange, despite the things that has happened. I just don't understand the hold these CEXs got over people.

In general, a good comparison between centralized exchanges and decentralized exchanges, but I do not agree with you that the fees on decentralized exchanges are cheaper, the fees on the Ethereum network are much higher than the fees on the centralized exchanges and annoying, the fees on the Binance network can be lower.

But in general, the disadvantages of centralized exchanges make them so far unable to replace centralized exchanges.

For me, I prefer decentralized exchanges that protect privacy, do not enforce KYC, and do not ban users based on IP.

I did not verify the validity of your numbers. Managing the servers of the trading exchanges is very expensive, but the problem is not possible in that, but in the short time for the growth of this market, as 3 years to 7 years is the average life of most platforms, so the platforms resort to using hot money to promote and attract ads instead of guaranteeing their deposit money.

You find the platforms burning liquidity more than what they earn, and therefore the slightest news that causes the withdrawal of a lot of money from the platform means the collapse of the platform in a short time. This is assuming we ignore the misuse of customer funds which is a common practice.

Yes, they care about profit but I don't understand why don't really invest a lot in security. Centralized exchanges really generate tons of profit, for example, Binance charges 0.1000% / 0.1000%   to Makers / Takers. So, their standard fee is 0.1% which lowers when your 30d trading volume increases or when you hold certain number of BNB coin.
But let's assume on average they profit 0.05% from spot trading. At the moment, their 24h spot trading volume is 282,267 BTC, so their estimated profit may be around 3,500,000 USD and that's only from spot trading. There we have profit from futures, mining, liquidity, stacking, etc.
So, crypto exchanges really make tons of money, I don't really understand why should someone ignore the security of such a money maker business.

Each has its advantages and disadvantages, which may suit some users and may not suit others, but most of the defects of DEXes can be solved with further development, use, and support for those projects, while most of the defects of CEXex need a regulatory framework and continuous monitoring, which is something that individuals cannot do, or at least It is not an easy thing to do compared to what people can do in DEXes.

these comparisons are now not feasible because the real capabilities of DEXes have not yet been shown.

If banks fail to guarantee the deposits of users and resort to federal institutions to hold assets up to a certain ceiling, then no sane person will believe that his funds are 'SAFU' in a centralized exchange.

I'm not sure if security measures is to be listed under pros of centralized exchanges. I think it should fall under cons. After all, it is certainly one of the main reasons why user funds are lost. Many centralized exchanges fail to secure their users' funds and personal information. Billions are lost due to hacks and other security breaches.

If one is to protect his/her funds, security measures of centralized exchanges aren't an added layer of protection. On the contrary, the moment one sends his/her funds to a centralized exchange, security is gone.

Did you calculate the total fee?
With more complex calculations, certain network-based DEXs have high fees for a single order, not to mention they charge a service fee that is afaik almost the same as CEX offers on average (around 0.5 - 1%). There is also a slip tolerance which is often a problem for users to get the desired price.

DEXs are not recommended for active traders, as overusing them can cost them money.

The big gap bey CEXes and DEXes is that, almost every newbie or let's say majority of the newbies in cryptocurrency comes through CEXes and some will never know about DEXes till they exit the crypto space.

This has made CEXex to gain so much popularity to the extent that it competes with non custodial wallets and not even with DEXes. So, it is right to say that anyone who is using DEXes now, have once in a while used the CEXes.
CEXes are widely known and used because of it's simplicity to use. With an email or phone only you can create an account and using it asap

Do not believe that your funds are 'SAFU' in a centralized exchange, or that some of them are too big or established to fail, this is what most people thought about centralized exchanges and services that have bitten the dust in the events that have happened in the last months. Centralized exchanges care more about their profit than the protection of your funds, so don't store your funds there because another one may bite the dust soon, and nobody knows which one it is going to be.

Hey there, crypto enthusiasts! Today, I wanted to delve into the fascinating world of centralized and decentralized exchanges (CEX and DEX) and explore the pros and cons of each.

Let's dive in and discuss which option might be the right fit for you:

Centralized Exchanges (CEX):
Centralized exchanges have been the go-to choice for many traders due to their established user base, high liquidity, and user-friendly interfaces. Here are some key aspects to consider:

Pros:

Liquidity: CEXs generally offer a higher volume of trades, resulting in increased liquidity. This means you can buy and sell cryptocurrencies quickly and at competitive prices.
User-friendly: If you're new to the crypto space or prefer a straightforward trading experience, CEXs typically offer intuitive user interfaces, making it easier for beginners to navigate.

Security measures: Established CEXs often invest heavily in security protocols such as encryption, cold storage, and two-factor authentication, providing an added layer of protection for user funds.

Cons:

Lack of control: With centralized exchanges, you're entrusting a third party with your funds. This reliance raises concerns about potential censorship, hacking risks, and regulatory compliance.
Privacy concerns: CEXs often require users to undergo identity verification procedures, compromising your privacy and anonymity.
Single point of failure: If a centralized exchange encounters technical difficulties or falls victim to a security breach, it can lead to service interruptions, loss of funds, or even closure.

Decentralized Exchanges (DEX):
Decentralized exchanges have gained popularity among crypto enthusiasts seeking greater control over their funds and enhanced privacy. Here are the key aspects to consider:

Pros:

User control: DEXs allow users to retain control over their funds as trades occur directly between individuals using smart contracts. This eliminates the need for intermediaries, reducing the risk of hacks or theft by central authorities.
Privacy: DEXs prioritize privacy by enabling users to trade without revealing their identities or providing excessive personal information.

Lower fees: Without intermediaries, DEXs often have lower transaction fees, making them attractive to frequent traders.
Cons:

Limited liquidity: DEXs face liquidity challenges as they rely on user-generated liquidity. This can result in wider spreads and less favorable prices for certain assets.

Complexity: DEX platforms can be more complex, especially for newcomers to the crypto space. Understanding private key management and interacting with smart contracts requires a learning curve.
Slower transactions: DEXs operate on blockchain networks, which can lead to slower transaction times and higher gas fees during periods of network congestion.

Ultimately, the choice between a centralized or decentralized exchange depends on your preferences and priorities. If convenience, high liquidity, and a user-friendly interface are important to you, a centralized exchange might be your best bet. However, if you prioritize privacy, control over your funds, and lower fees, a decentralized exchange might be the way to go.

Now, I'd love to hear your thoughts on this topic! Have you had any positive or negative experiences with centralized or decentralized exchanges?
Which type of exchange do you prefer, and why?
https://rwaltz.com/services/crypto-exchange-development

Let's discuss and learn from each other's experiences!