It appears that the ATM funded the paper wallet with this transaction:
https://blockchain.info/tx/467a0c4fca79413958d180214dce79128f6822ae699db2c0ef5994e80520b23c
Where it sent 0.37985839 BTC to 1F216ru1WPd4avWtE9iJ6QbLyFVHf3btYh on 2016-01-14 at 05:41:16 UTC
Then it appears that you transferred the funds to your blockchain.info address with this transaction:
https://blockchain.info/tx/760836b2293ca60bbc6bf84602cf4595a4bcaa0aedcbf049aac42a265aabedc7
Where you sent 0.37975839 BTC to 1P6Bv7FFLR1gcLYHWJdGNrgaW58a8R1LtW on 2016-01-14 at 12:32:34 UTC and paid a 0.0001 BTC transaction fee.
Then it appears that you transferred the funds to your intended final address with this transaction:
f6ac27ce4e718456da138ccffab0b636c58888c54114745c5855d3b1b62d96a4
Where you:
- Sent 0.37758717 BTC to 1PuBzbjRjURbJEarJw89bZVEt6mkhajzWn on 2016-01-14 at 12:35:45 UTC
- Paid another 0.0001 BTC transaction fee
- Kept 0.00207122 BTC in your blockchain.info wallet at 1P6Bv7FFLR1gcLYHWJdGNrgaW58a8R1LtW
The 0.37758717 BTC that were sent to 1PuBzbjRjURbJEarJw89bZVEt6mkhajzWn are still at that address and have not been spent or stolen by anyone yet.
The 0.00207122 BTC that were left in the blockchain.info wallet at 1P6Bv7FFLR1gcLYHWJdGNrgaW58a8R1LtW are still at that address and have not been spent or stolen by anyone yet.
Therefore:
- If you still have access to the blockchain.info wallet, then you can still access and send the remaining 0.00207122 BTC
- If 1PuBzbjRjURbJEarJw89bZVEt6mkhajzWn is an address in your Armory wallet, then you can still access and send the 0.37758717 BTC that were sent to that address
This means that you potentially still have access to 0.37758717 + 0.00207122 = 0.37965839 BTC.
Note that the exchange rate for bitcoins has dropped a bit since you purchased them, so while you may have paid somewhere around $165 for the bitcoins, the remaining 0.37965839 BTC are only currently worth about $157