Cosigner Pool only react if u reopen the wallet

moejoejay

member

Activity: 138

Merit: 20

@nc50lc

changed, and feel free to take part with ur experience on the issue too.

best regards

nc50lc

legendary

Activity: 2534

Merit: 6080

Self-proclaimed Genius

Quote from: moejoejay on November 02, 2022, 02:39:15 AM

@nc50lc:

Quote

Because in MultiSig; m/n, "m" sets the number of required signatures and "n" indicates the number of cosigners.

So, 2/1 instead 1/2 and 2/2 should be fine or.

The MultiSig setup is 2/2 since you have two cosigners and it requires two signatures.
So it should be "..and if i sent some funds from 2/2 Multisig Wallet to an normal one".

Then, instead of calling cosigner2 as 2/2, just revise it into:
"...pool only reacts if i reopen/close the second cosigner Wallet."

moejoejay

member

Activity: 138

Merit: 20

@nc50lc:

Quote

Because in MultiSig; m/n, "m" sets the number of required signatures and "n" indicates the number of cosigners.

So, 2/1 instead 1/2 and 2/2 should be fine or.

best regards

nc50lc

legendary

Activity: 2534

Merit: 6080

Self-proclaimed Genius

Quote from: moejoejay on October 27, 2022, 11:56:24 AM

edit: GithubIssue

I forgot to mention that writing "1/2" and "2/2" as the cosigner wallets might mislead the readers that you're talking about two unrelated MultiSig wallets.
Because in MultiSig; m/n, "m" sets the number of required signatures and "n" indicates the number of cosigners.

A better term would be "cosigner 1" and "cosigner 2" of a (2/2) MultiSig Electrum wallet or similar.

moejoejay

member

Activity: 138

Merit: 20

@nc50lc

good point
take this into consideration with my own one

thnx for mention

edit: GithubIssue

best regards

nc50lc

legendary

Activity: 2534

Merit: 6080

Self-proclaimed Genius

Quote from: moejoejay on October 26, 2022, 12:26:56 PM

it seems that sometimes the pool popup appears also when u close the wallet and not reopen it, weird.

I tried to reproduce this and it did popped-up after closing the wallet after a few repeats.

I've also saved the log and for some reason, cosigner_pool's "listener" started only after closing the cosigner wallet.
Might be useful if you decided to open a new issue:

Code:

moejoejay

member

Activity: 138

Merit: 20

Quote

Why don't you use QR or exporting file even loading a text form are much easier.

I know this but this is not my intention for using the cosigner pool.
neverthless u right this is quite an other possibility for sign the transaction over multiple wallets.

Quote

(at least from what I can recall in my previous test)

as far as i remember on my test mainnet 2019 at this time it wasnt the case, the pool popup had rised up immediately.

further observations (mainnet):
sometimes its not possible to send the tx to from the 1/2 wallet to the cosigner pool ( there is no button availiable for it), then i closed the 1/2 wallet the popup from the cosigner pool appears on the 2/2 wallet without any interaction.

it seems that sometimes the pool popup appears also when u close the wallet and not reopen it, weird.

Quote

perhaps you might want to open one, the Devs might be able to fix/find-out the issue

i'll think about it

best regards

nc50lc

legendary

Activity: 2534

Merit: 6080

Self-proclaimed Genius

Quote from: moejoejay on October 26, 2022, 10:05:02 AM

could some one reproduce this or any clue why it's so ?

I can reproduce it in testnet, Electrum v4.3.2.
But IIRC, it's always been the case in the older versions (at least from what I can recall in my previous test)

For others who want to try reproducing the issue:
If the other cosigner(s) is open while a cosigner sent a transaction to the cosigner pool server, it wont get prompted for a new partially signed transaction until the wallet get closed and reopened.

-edit-
I've tried to open the second cosigner in v3.3.8 and it worked without reopening the wallet.
But AFAIK, it's always been the case somewhere in v4.x.x, I'll try another older version.

-edit2-
Same behavior in v4.2.0 & v4.0.6, cosigners have to be reopened to retrieve the partially signed transaction.
But works in v4.0.1.

Unfortunately, I can't find a relevant commit in cosigner_pool plugin history (link) and there's no similar open issue in GitHub,
perhaps you might want to open one, the Devs might be able to fix/find-out the issue: github.com/spesmilo/electrum/issues?

AB de Royse777

legendary

Activity: 2464

Merit: 3878

Hire Bitcointalk Camp. Manager @ r7promotions.com

I have not used cosigner pool (not sure but mind is tricking that I once did). Why don't you use QR or exporting file even loading a text form are much easier.

In case you are missing, you will find it under tools.

moejoejay

member

Activity: 138

Merit: 20

Electrum: 4.3.2
Windows Version 10.0.19044 Build 19044
Multisig: 2/2
Main Net

Hey folks,

i tried the cosigner pool plugin again and if i sent some funds from 1/2 Multisig Wallet to an normal one , the cosigner system pool only reacts if i reopen the certain 2/2 Cosigner Wallet.

could some one reproduce this or any clue why it's so ?

best regards

Topic: Cosigner Pool only react if u reopen the wallet (Read 138 times)