Curious what I am encountering, need an explanation maybe?

AmeliaCoinSmith

newbie

Activity: 12

Merit: 0

Quote from: HCP on March 06, 2018, 04:36:31 PM

Quote from: DannyHamilton on March 06, 2018, 02:54:53 AM

Per the OP:

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 03:58:30 PM

- snip -
The sender is sending from Coinbase
- snip -

Thanks Danny, Need to get my eyes checked! Embarrassed

It would appear that following their announcement of implementing SegWit, Coinbase have indeed started using bech32 addresses for change... There doesn't seem to be any official announcement on this, the only reference I could locate was a very confusing and poorly structured blog post:

Quote from: http://www.digitalcurrencygrid.com/2018/02/25/announcing-segwit-support-on-coinbase-the-coinbase-blog/

If you look at Coinbase segwit transactions you will notice the change is already using bech32, and sends are already supported for bech32.

Looks like the Bech32 Adoption page needs to be updated Wink

We aren't segwit enable, but my goodess...all the sellers are in a tizzy since their Ads aren't funded instantly @_@

Thank you everyone for input and answers.

HCP

legendary

Activity: 2086

Merit: 4361

Quote from: DannyHamilton on March 06, 2018, 02:54:53 AM

Per the OP:

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 03:58:30 PM

- snip -
The sender is sending from Coinbase
- snip -

Thanks Danny, Need to get my eyes checked! Embarrassed

It would appear that following their announcement of implementing SegWit, Coinbase have indeed started using bech32 addresses for change... There doesn't seem to be any official announcement on this, the only reference I could locate was a very confusing and poorly structured blog post:

Quote from: http://www.digitalcurrencygrid.com/2018/02/25/announcing-segwit-support-on-coinbase-the-coinbase-blog/

If you look at Coinbase segwit transactions you will notice the change is already using bech32, and sends are already supported for bech32.

Looks like the Bech32 Adoption page needs to be updated Wink

DannyHamilton

legendary

Activity: 3472

Merit: 4801

Quote from: HCP on March 05, 2018, 10:04:44 PM

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 06:22:09 PM

If your customer sent 0.0350349 BTC to 14JW3BCbe2CE4gBESSevpUqSwggUsxVfsT, the wallet probably sent the remaining balance to another address in his wallet(bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje) aka change address.

As far as I'm aware, the only two wallets that support "bech32" (aka "bc1") addresses are Electrum and now (as of v0.16.0) Bitcoin Core...
- snip -
Who initiated that transfer? And what wallet were they sending from?

Per the OP:

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 03:58:30 PM

- snip -
The sender is sending from Coinbase
- snip -

HCP

legendary

Activity: 2086

Merit: 4361

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 06:22:09 PM

If your customer sent 0.0350349 BTC to 14JW3BCbe2CE4gBESSevpUqSwggUsxVfsT , the wallet probably sent the remaining balance to another address in his wallet(bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje) aka change address.

As far as I'm aware, the only two wallets that support "bech32" (aka "bc1") addresses are Electrum and now (as of v0.16.0) Bitcoin Core...

Electrum doesn't allow mixing legacy and SegWit addresses in the same wallet... so if the user was using Electrum, there is no way that "bc1qed" can be a change address.

I'm not sure if Bitcoin Core would generate a "bc1" change address for a transaction sent from a "P2SH-P2WPKH" (SegWit "3" address)... It's possible, but I suspect that it would not.

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 04:46:26 PM

Alright, so therein lies the issue. I do not know where the wallet for bc1q...exists. It was suppose to be 32kJ --> 14JW, but this has occurred instead, and now 0.6 is missing. How do I view the location, because it will not populate on blockchain.info No one in this equation has access to bc1q.

Who initiated that transfer? And what wallet were they sending from?

Thirdspace

hero member

Activity: 1232

Merit: 738

Mixing reinvented for your privacy | chipmixer.com

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 04:46:26 PM

Alright, so therein lies the issue. I do not know where the wallet for bc1q...exists. It was suppose to be 32kJ --> 14JW, but this has occurred instead, and now 0.6 is missing. How do I view the location, because it will not populate on blockchain.info No one in this equation has access to bc1q.

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 06:01:21 PM

It wasn't mine, I was assisting a customer...and something went terribly wrong. I think he was hacked internally from his source website.

if it is coinbase, I think bc1qeda belongs to coinbase. they just recently started supporting bitcoin segwit
https://blog.coinbase.com/announcing-segwit-support-on-coinbase-4e51117857c7
though the blog shows image with 3xx address for example not bech32 address
https://btc.com/bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje
might want to ask him whether 32kJ owned by him or just (his) sender address owned by coinbase

kahc

member

Activity: 350

Merit: 13

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 06:01:21 PM

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 05:54:41 PM

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 05:45:29 PM

So how to access the wallet... so even though it was told go to 14JW... it went to bc1q... but part of it was left over? The wallet it was sent to was also not segwit enable(is that make sense?), so how does that impact the situation?

Is difficult to say without knowing the exact details.
So did you make the transaction yourself? Using which wallet?

It wasn't mine, I was assisting a customer...and something went terribly wrong. I think he was hacked internally from his source website.

Can't say for sure if he's hacked or not.
Do you know what kind of wallet your customer used?

For me the transaction looked normal.

If your customer sent 0.0350349 BTC to 14JW3BCbe2CE4gBESSevpUqSwggUsxVfsT , the wallet probably sent the remaining balance to another address in his wallet(bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje) aka change address.

AmeliaCoinSmith

newbie

Activity: 12

Merit: 0

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 05:54:41 PM

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 05:45:29 PM

So how to access the wallet... so even though it was told go to 14JW... it went to bc1q... but part of it was left over? The wallet it was sent to was also not segwit enable(is that make sense?), so how does that impact the situation?

Is difficult to say without knowing the exact details.
So did you make the transaction yourself? Using which wallet?

It wasn't mine, I was assisting a customer...and something went terribly wrong. I think he was hacked internally from his source website.

kahc

member

Activity: 350

Merit: 13

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 05:45:29 PM

So how to access the wallet... so even though it was told go to 14JW... it went to bc1q... but part of it was left over? The wallet it was sent to was also not segwit enable(is that make sense?), so how does that impact the situation?

Is difficult to say without knowing the exact details.
So did you make the transaction yourself? Using which wallet?

AmeliaCoinSmith

newbie

Activity: 12

Merit: 0

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 05:22:11 PM

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 04:46:26 PM

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 04:18:21 PM

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 03:58:30 PM

So I am observing a transaction, and something isn't matching up...

The sender is sending from Coinbase BTC addy 32kJ... to address start 14JW....but the first transaction shows 14JW sending, and 32kJ receiving first. Then almost 8 minutes later, is then it is reversed...but it's split into transactions; one to b23b...(which I am understanding it as a part of segwit, and cannot click link, does not give information otherwise!), which received the majority of the funds. The remainder of the balance, as you can see, remains in 14JW.

Help me understand? Viewing 14JW, where did the BTC go?

https://blockchain.info/address/32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

Nothing is wrong here.

First
14cQRmViAzVKa277gZznByGZtnrVPQc8Lr sent 0.67043102 BTC to 32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

then

32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2 sent 0.63535701 BTC to bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje
and probably 0.0350349 BTC as change to 14JW3BCbe2CE4gBESSevpUqSwggUsxVfsT .

Alright, so therein lies the issue. I do not know where the wallet for bc1q...exists. It was suppose to be 32kJ --> 14JW, but this has occurred instead, and now 0.6 is missing. How do I view the location, because it will not populate on blockchain.info No one in this equation has access to bc1q.

You will need a blockchain explorer that supports SegWit.

Like this one https://btc.com/32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

Alright, so thank you SO MUCH! I work at an exchange...this guy looks hacked. I needed an answer....

kahc

member

Activity: 350

Merit: 13

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 04:46:26 PM

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 04:18:21 PM

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 03:58:30 PM

So I am observing a transaction, and something isn't matching up...

The sender is sending from Coinbase BTC addy 32kJ... to address start 14JW....but the first transaction shows 14JW sending, and 32kJ receiving first. Then almost 8 minutes later, is then it is reversed...but it's split into transactions; one to b23b...(which I am understanding it as a part of segwit, and cannot click link, does not give information otherwise!), which received the majority of the funds. The remainder of the balance, as you can see, remains in 14JW.

Help me understand? Viewing 14JW, where did the BTC go?

https://blockchain.info/address/32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

Nothing is wrong here.

First
14cQRmViAzVKa277gZznByGZtnrVPQc8Lr sent 0.67043102 BTC to 32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

then

32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2 sent 0.63535701 BTC to bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje
and probably 0.0350349 BTC as change to 14JW3BCbe2CE4gBESSevpUqSwggUsxVfsT .

Alright, so therein lies the issue. I do not know where the wallet for bc1q...exists. It was suppose to be 32kJ --> 14JW, but this has occurred instead, and now 0.6 is missing. How do I view the location, because it will not populate on blockchain.info No one in this equation has access to bc1q.

You will need a blockchain explorer that supports SegWit.

Like this one https://btc.com/32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

AmeliaCoinSmith

newbie

Activity: 12

Merit: 0

Quote from: kahc on March 05, 2018, 04:18:21 PM

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 03:58:30 PM

So I am observing a transaction, and something isn't matching up...

The sender is sending from Coinbase BTC addy 32kJ... to address start 14JW....but the first transaction shows 14JW sending, and 32kJ receiving first. Then almost 8 minutes later, is then it is reversed...but it's split into transactions; one to b23b...(which I am understanding it as a part of segwit, and cannot click link, does not give information otherwise!), which received the majority of the funds. The remainder of the balance, as you can see, remains in 14JW.

Help me understand? Viewing 14JW, where did the BTC go?

https://blockchain.info/address/32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

Nothing is wrong here.

First
14cQRmViAzVKa277gZznByGZtnrVPQc8Lr sent 0.67043102 BTC to 32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

then

32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2 sent 0.63535701 BTC to bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje
and probably 0.0350349 BTC as change to 14JW3BCbe2CE4gBESSevpUqSwggUsxVfsT .

Alright, so therein lies the issue. I do not know where the wallet for bc1q...exists. It was suppose to be 32kJ --> 14JW, but this has occurred instead, and now 0.6 is missing. How do I view the location, because it will not populate on blockchain.info No one in this equation has access to bc1q.

kahc

member

Activity: 350

Merit: 13

Quote from: AmeliaCoinSmith on March 05, 2018, 03:58:30 PM

So I am observing a transaction, and something isn't matching up...

The sender is sending from Coinbase BTC addy 32kJ... to address start 14JW....but the first transaction shows 14JW sending, and 32kJ receiving first. Then almost 8 minutes later, is then it is reversed...but it's split into transactions; one to b23b...(which I am understanding it as a part of segwit, and cannot click link, does not give information otherwise!), which received the majority of the funds. The remainder of the balance, as you can see, remains in 14JW.

Help me understand? Viewing 14JW, where did the BTC go?

https://blockchain.info/address/32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

Nothing is wrong here.

First
14cQRmViAzVKa277gZznByGZtnrVPQc8Lr sent 0.67043102 BTC to 32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

then

32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2 sent 0.63535701 BTC to bc1qeda79n8et2s5nu6u8gqa5wvhaxj4tmj296xlje
and probably 0.0350349 BTC as change to 14JW3BCbe2CE4gBESSevpUqSwggUsxVfsT .

AmeliaCoinSmith

newbie

Activity: 12

Merit: 0

So I am observing a transaction, and something isn't matching up...

The sender is sending from Coinbase BTC addy 32kJ... to address start 14JW....but the first transaction shows 14JW sending, and 32kJ receiving first. Then almost 8 minutes later, is then it is reversed...but it's split into transactions; one to b23b...(which I am understanding it as a part of segwit, and cannot click link, does not give information otherwise!), which received the majority of the funds. The remainder of the balance, as you can see, remains in 14JW.

Help me understand? Viewing 14JW, where did the BTC go?

https://blockchain.info/address/32kJwNnSWQkt9V4jSYdxyuV9LYDAJD9rD2

Topic: Curious what I am encountering, need an explanation maybe? (Read 241 times)