This is what i mentioned earlier that doesn't make sense.
Even if i receive 0.00065 btc per lisk after lisk goes from 5 dollars to 6 dollars or 0.0007 btc to 0.00065 btc, well im getting less btc than i bought with. However, the btc price is higher than it was before. So the total amount of btc now i have in USD that i withdrew at that moment is higher than the usd value right before i bought the lisk right? Because if that is the case, yes i lose btc. But don't i gain profit here?
Can someone else also comment on this? Because that means even if a coin goes from 1 dollar to 10 dollars, then you could lose money if bitcoin 15 times itself when you sell your altcoin at 10 dollars?
Yes, true. For every altcoin that's not paired with USD(T). Because then you will have to sell back to BTC, and you will get less BTC back than you had invested in this altcoin.
BUT technically you could have made a nett profit. Let me explain, with figurative numbers:
Let's say you're buying altcoin A with 1BTC. BTC is at $5000 and A is at $1. So you're buying 5000 A's.
After 2 months, the value of A went up from $1 to $2 and you want to take profit.
But BTC went up to $20k in the same time.
If you sell them now (back to BTC), you will get only 0.5BTC for your 5000 A's.
Then you can sell your 0.5BTC back to fiat, which will give you $10k. You have certainly made a profit, $5000 to be exact.
BUT: if you hadn't invested in altcoin A and had left your 1 BTC in BTC, you would've owned $20k now instead of $10k. So relatively you've lost money, against the BTC.
Hi there thanks for the response.
Okay so in this example that you used, yes this is the type of example that i like to look at. Yes if altcoin a goes from 1 dollar to 2 dollar and i buy 5000 of it at 1 dollar, it cost me 5000. If it doubles to 2 dollars, i basically doubled my money so i have 10000 total so 5000 profit.
Yes that makes sense if btc went up to 20k at the time... i would only get back 0.5btc for my 5000 altcoins whereas i invested 1 altcoin to buy those 5000 alts earlier so i get back only half of my altcoins.
You say yes i made a profit here of $5000. I know its $5000 minus the buying/selling fees but yes this is what im looking for.
But is there a reason why those other posters kept telling me i lost money here? Both posters kept saying i lost because i received less btc than i bought with. Thus i could buy an altcoin at 0.0007 btc and even if the price went up for the altcoin, if btc goes up a higher percentage, then when i sell that altcoin, i could only receive 0.00065 btc. They said you have to make sure you receive more btc per alt when you sell than when you buy. That did not make sense because if i receive less btc... well if btc price is higher, then well it shouldn't matter.
Yes that makes sense if i have that 1 btc and just hold it as oppose to using it to buy 5000 altcoin in your example, i would make more assuming btc goes up from 5k to 20k and the altcoin went up from 1 dollar to 2 dollar. Yes that make sense i lost money against the btc. However, if you are daytrading and looking to make profits, then does that really matter assuming you are looking to invest in altcoins only with those certain btc?
Is there a reason why those posters kept mentioning im losing money here in this trade with my numbers? Because what you said.. makes absolute sense. The only thing was i didn't think about when looking at profit in that example was hey if you just kept the btc instead... you would have made more assuming btc went up higher percentage than the altcoin. The way those posters spoke.. it was as if okay if you invest in an altcoin, you need to make sure it increased at a higher percentage than btc during that period. For example if you buy an altcoin and it goes up from 1 dollar to 3 dollars... you better make sure btc don't go from 5000 to more than 15000 otherwise you lose money. That made wonder... how is it even possible to make money investing in altcoins then? Such that what would be the point of trying to make 10 percent or even 20 percent profit on a coin from buying it if btc goes higher than that. And the thing was when i read altcoin discussion, i never read anything about this. Everything is which coin will double or 3x or more etc and i didn't read any post about you lose money if btc goes higher percentage than the altcoin.
Can you answer these other questions i just posted? And thanks for your post because your post makes absolute sense. And can others here chime in and comment on fromholland's post and confirm this is true? Because this makes sense to me as he says yes there is profit whereas those other posters say there isn't.