Author

Topic: Difference - COINBASE - CAMPBX - BITSTAMP (Read 837 times)

legendary
Activity: 1274
Merit: 1000
Personal text my ass....
January 28, 2014, 02:08:05 PM
#4
I'm verified on all three of these services and have found out that CampBX and Bitstamp don't actually buy your bitcoin. You put a trade out there and hope someone buys it. I've always used COINBASE previously where COINBASE themselves would buy whatever I was selling. For those that use CampBX and Bitstamp when you want to sell bitcoin and make a sell order, is it sold up quickly or do you have to wait a while? I'm just talking if I were to use the average going rate at that time. I may want to sell some bitcoin I have and have always used COINBASE but wouldn't mind trying another service. I know they all have fees....and I don't use COINBASE a lot, so I'm looking for experts out there that are familiar with each service and can pin point the differences easily. I may try to sell just a little at each place to try it out just for the heck of it. I've heard bad news about all three services, so who knows.

Exchanges (such as Bitstamp) and sites that buy/sell Bitcoin (such as Coinbase) function in quite different ways. Coinbase just provides you with a price to buy at (or sell at) and then it's take it or leave it.

On Bitstamp you can provide your own price and if there are people on the other side of the offer that have the same price in mind, a trade is made. If there are sell orders for $820 in the books, then my buy order at $820 will be executed immediately. However, if I place a buy order at $810, I have to wait for the price to drop and for people willing to sell at that price to place their orders.

Well I'm already having problems with CampBX. Very first time I sold a little bitcoin and the transaction was done in like minutes but the money is now stuck in limbo and hasn't been deposited into my bank account. I thought it was illegal to just hold onto people's money and then not pay them back without some kind of interest on it? The transaction was January 22nd and today is January 28th. You'd think on the very first time you use the service things would work, but this is an easy decision...never to use these guys again.
hero member
Activity: 728
Merit: 500
January 22, 2014, 06:12:55 AM
#3
I'm verified on all three of these services and have found out that CampBX and Bitstamp don't actually buy your bitcoin. You put a trade out there and hope someone buys it. I've always used COINBASE previously where COINBASE themselves would buy whatever I was selling. For those that use CampBX and Bitstamp when you want to sell bitcoin and make a sell order, is it sold up quickly or do you have to wait a while? I'm just talking if I were to use the average going rate at that time. I may want to sell some bitcoin I have and have always used COINBASE but wouldn't mind trying another service. I know they all have fees....and I don't use COINBASE a lot, so I'm looking for experts out there that are familiar with each service and can pin point the differences easily. I may try to sell just a little at each place to try it out just for the heck of it. I've heard bad news about all three services, so who knows.

Exchanges (such as Bitstamp) and sites that buy/sell Bitcoin (such as Coinbase) function in quite different ways. Coinbase just provides you with a price to buy at (or sell at) and then it's take it or leave it.

On Bitstamp you can provide your own price and if there are people on the other side of the offer that have the same price in mind, a trade is made. If there are sell orders for $820 in the books, then my buy order at $820 will be executed immediately. However, if I place a buy order at $810, I have to wait for the price to drop and for people willing to sell at that price to place their orders.
sr. member
Activity: 1097
Merit: 310
Seabet.io | Crypto-Casino
January 22, 2014, 05:56:37 AM
#2
Unfortunately I am not an expert but use all of them. If you ignore the bid-ask spread or submit market order you can trade soon. It is trade off with the maximizing profit/minimize loss. You cannot specify "the average going rate" for all.

Coinbase use bitstamp as an exchange to process their order and thus tends to be identical to submit market order to bitstamp. Comparing bitstamp with camp BX, generally spread is wider in Camp BX. So if you prefer to trade immediately ignoring small cost, you should choose bitstamp. If you are patient, Camp BX could be better. Trade fee is similar but for me Camp BX is reasonable for deposit and withdrawals. However bitstamp is faster to process for deposit/withdrawals too. I think overall it is speed vs cost.
legendary
Activity: 1274
Merit: 1000
Personal text my ass....
January 21, 2014, 08:32:03 PM
#1
I'm verified on all three of these services and have found out that CampBX and Bitstamp don't actually buy your bitcoin. You put a trade out there and hope someone buys it. I've always used COINBASE previously where COINBASE themselves would buy whatever I was selling. For those that use CampBX and Bitstamp when you want to sell bitcoin and make a sell order, is it sold up quickly or do you have to wait a while? I'm just talking if I were to use the average going rate at that time. I may want to sell some bitcoin I have and have always used COINBASE but wouldn't mind trying another service. I know they all have fees....and I don't use COINBASE a lot, so I'm looking for experts out there that are familiar with each service and can pin point the differences easily. I may try to sell just a little at each place to try it out just for the heck of it. I've heard bad news about all three services, so who knows.

Jump to: