etherdelta & forkdelta buy and get 0 token !

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

Quote from: ice18 on May 16, 2019, 01:39:35 AM

can you show us the txt id? ..

for example this : https://etherscan.io/tx/0x1eda09c3a57512f21f22d5d0d5e2cdee77bd3006c4d98ae5e78b33cfe100bf0b
all txt trade I think the same problem

in etherscan the last Transfers 243 days ago ( 1.52 token ) ! something's wrong here ...

ice18

hero member

Activity: 2492

Merit: 542

First time to I heard about this forkdelta transaction and no token received Im a frequent user of fd and I have never encountered like your problem before the only reason I know if order did not process is no enough gas for execution of contracts but the ether remains in your main wallet if the transaction has succeed can you show us the txt id? You can see it in My transactions and click trade tab, for us to know where the token goes.

sheenshane

legendary

Activity: 2492

Merit: 1232

Quote from: omer-jamal on May 15, 2019, 06:11:31 PM

the problem How they could add a sale order without "TOKEN HOLDER" in EtherDelta address ?! (I think it's a bug in ED/FD)

Like what you see here:

[link] [zoom image]

Probably that coin is a bug I didn't find that token on ED either in FD, is that Bingocoin right?
You can simply ask on the chat box in EtherDelta of Forkdelta to ask your problem and also the mailing address above you should contact the Team.

Their social media account are not so active aside in Reddit.

Ipwich

hero member

Activity: 1050

Merit: 529

Student Coin

This is not possible, if you will initiate the buy and you have enough funds to support your order, you can get your token.
Only risk I know with decentralized exchange are the fake tokens, you should do some research on this part.

rosezionjohn

sr. member

Activity: 882

Merit: 301

It's been one month since the OP, have you tried contacting the team on ForkDelta? If I am not mistaken, the team is pretty much active on discord. If you already did, what was the feedback to you?

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

the problem How they could add a sale order without "TOKEN HOLDER" in EtherDelta address ?! (I think it's a bug in ED/FD)

Like what you see here:

[link] [zoom image]

okala

full member

Activity: 980

Merit: 114

Am still confused at the point you are trying to make is it that you token order on folkdelta have not been fully implemented and if it so why is your balance shown in you wallet I think you have to contact the support and lay your complain to them they will help you fix it.

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

Bump

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

Quote from: Cosbycoin on April 12, 2019, 03:19:16 PM

.. unless something is wrong with the smart contract..

probably This closer analysis of the problem, problem with contract also etherdelta,forkdelta Possibly there is issues
How they were able to add sell order without token in contract this another problem

Cosbycoin

hero member

Activity: 980

Merit: 506

I don't think it is possible to buy a token from a decentralized exchange and see it at 0 when you did all you have to do correctly, unless something is wrong with the smart contract.

Decentralized exchanges are so complex and would take an expert who is very knowledgeable about crypto to understand how to make use of it fully without having to go through any guide whatsoever, this is very bad and need to be worked on so fast in order to bring mass adoption in the crypto space, by creating a user friendly DEX.

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

Quote from: jhenfelipe on April 11, 2019, 07:12:33 PM

@jhenfelipe trade order Succeed, when you try withdraw token tx Fail
You are right this shitToken it does not matter because my order was small and forgot it we want understand the situation and how it happened for learn more...

no need contact dev/team because this shittoken Died a long time ago

Quote from: sctunter on April 11, 2019, 08:18:53 PM

what kind buy that you did there? instan buy or put your order buy on market.

instan, does not matter because my order was small And forgot it ..

Brainnin

jr. member

Activity: 170

Merit: 1

Sorry as I can't fully get your point, did you buy a particular coin with Forkdelta or etherdelta and you are yet to see the reflection of the coin in your wallet? or you are mainly talking about the gas fee charged? Kindly provide a more detailed information probably I could help with more insights

sctunter

member

Activity: 406

Merit: 11

what kind buy that you did there? instan buy or put your order buy on market.
if that buy order then you should wait for someone selling their token on your buy order price

jhenfelipe

hero member

Activity: 1372

Merit: 647

Quote from: omer-jamal on April 11, 2019, 05:47:52 PM

I do not understand how they were able to do that
Is this possible? How avoid these ?..

You are sure that your order has been filled, right?

The problem is that, you trade an unofficial listed token in that exchange. There might be a mistake on contract address/decimal or might be a problem with the token itself (changes in the eth standard or the token is locked) that's why you are getting an error/didn't see the balance.

The only way to avoid it is to not trade an unofficially listed token on Etherdelta and Forkdelta.

You can contact the dev/team of that coin to know if there were changes or if they have an idea about what happened / what's happening.

Cyptobonds1

jr. member

Activity: 262

Merit: 2

You should probably check your exchange wallet to confirm if the token or coin is truly missing, just saying because I haven't experienced such issues using those sites and maybe it's because am not a frequent user.

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

At the beginning I want to clarify I use The correct links https://forkdelta.app and useing https://metamask.io/

what happened ?

https://forkdelta.app/#!/trade/0x4b317864a05c91225ab8f401ec7be0aeb87e9c12-ETH ( Do not buy this token! )
this contract address : 0x4b317864a05c91225ab8f401ec7be0aeb87e9c12

I bought this token and yes you can see token show in your ForkDelta wallet but when you check ForkDelta/etherdelta contract address (Token Holder) there is no token there! when we check etherdelta contract address and how much token in contract address such as you see below Balance 0 BOC

https://etherscan.io/token/0x4b317864a05c91225ab8f401ec7be0aeb87e9c12?a=0x8d12a197cb00d4747a1fe03395095ce2a5cc6819

when you try Withdraw token:
Fail > Warning! Error encountered during contract execution Reverted

Warning! Error encountered during contract execution [Reverted]

I do not understand how they were able to do that
Is this possible? How avoid these ?..

Quote from: cryptobae10 on April 11, 2019, 04:59:19 PM

Did you buy on etherdelta and forkdelta at the same time ?

Just ForkDelta I think etherdelta same thing ( same contract address used )

Quote from: jhenfelipe on April 11, 2019, 04:56:58 PM

~ and your Eth was gone too? ~

yes Eth was gone like when you trade

mrdeposit

hero member

Activity: 1358

Merit: 509

Are you sure you can use those exchanges? Because it is a little different from the centralized ones. Also, make sure you visit the right site, and check out the made transactions.

terrific

hero member

Activity: 2324

Merit: 513

Catalog Websites

What's the coin that you bought?
Follow the suggestion given by jhenfelipe.
if you can add more details, please do.

cryptobae10

jr. member

Activity: 658

Merit: 5

I think you need to provide more information about the trade and also confirm if you were on the right site

Did you buy on etherdelta and forkdelta at the same time ?
Or interchangeably ?

jhenfelipe

hero member

Activity: 1372

Merit: 647

So, you bought a token, it wasn't credited in your account and your Eth was gone too?
Are you sure that you are in the correct site and your order has been filled? If yes, check your Eth address on Etherdelta here : https://deltabalances.github.io/ to see all your balances and transactions

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

thanks for your reply

Quote from: rosezionjohn on April 11, 2019, 04:00:52 PM

Was it your first time buying on both exchanges?

It's not the first time I think it's a trick or something advanced I do not understand
Okay I will provide more information about this

rosezionjohn

sr. member

Activity: 882

Merit: 301

I think you'll have to provide more data about your transaction in order for the community to help you better. Maybe you can also move this to Beginners and Help for better visibility.

Was it your first time buying on both exchanges?

omer-jamal

sr. member

Activity: 490

Merit: 275

hi everyone Cheesy

is there anyone buy token, However he did not get this token!

That's what happened to me.
I want know more details about this to avoid this problem in the future

I think something related about Data , Hex Data: 356 bytes or contract? ...

Topic: etherdelta & forkdelta buy and get 0 token ! (Read 327 times)