I agree and I did not try to contradict you about their impact on the market, just that the impact is largely negative. You could see that on the charts, just look for the date when the first ETF went online and you'll see what happened to bitcoin about 2 weeks later.
The only ETF that we can expect to have a positive effect on the price to a greater extent may be the one in the US, of course the physical one that the SEC still does not want to approve. Yet all of these BTC ETFs, regardless of type, have a role to play if we consider that this is one of the ways Bitcoin is adapting to our society and becoming in some way legitimate among investors.
If we focus on the price we have today, then we could say that it is the result of everything that has happened since the beginning of 2009 until today, not necessarily only good, but also bad things.
Data analysis by companies like blockware suggests the last time holders were selling was in Spring 2021 on the way to 60k and then it was all the same coins being recirculated.
Now, it looks like there's not much sell pressure but not many people want to buy either. Those who had money on the side bought a lot of coins below 40k and are out, while those who were panicking below 40k got out. Seems like we'll need new people to enter the market for it to move up and as long as there's fear of recession they won't come in numbers large enough to make impact.
People are convinced that the crypto winter has begun and that there will be no new bull run until after the next halving - and inflation that is realistically between 10-20% does not encourage most to invest in the long run in something considered risky. I don't think the problem is that there are no new investors to buy BTC for the first time, but that people generally don't have the extra money to invest somewhere. The period of cheap money for ordinary people and institutions is obviously over, now we will return everything we got with interest.
It looks like we have 9 and possibly going to have 10 red weekly candles. This definitely has never happened before but the dumps were very small compared to previous ones.
What would you rather have, 10 red weeks where price falls 4% each week (40% total) or something like 2018 where we had 2 red week followed by a green one but we fell 30% in those 2 weeks then went up to recover half of the loss and then had another 2 red weeks where we fell 60% from the top of that green week, eventually losing about 70% in 5 weeks?
Ultimately (although some will disagree), the past repeats itself in a similar way, after halving followed by ATH then correction, and a period of accumulation it all comes down to everyone waiting for the next opportunity to profit again. What is still uncertain now is whether we have hit rock bottom or it will only happen in the coming months?