Hardware Wallet support for Windows in Electrum?

ColderThanIce

sr. member

Activity: 373

Merit: 252

Quote from: jbrnt on July 31, 2015, 05:41:20 PM

HW.1 is so cheap I am eager to buy one for every day use. I am still waiting for better support for HW.1 from Electrum before I buy one to test.

Quote from: Muhammed Zakir on July 25, 2015, 09:05:50 AM

HW.1 is working fine for me but I compiled Electrum 2.0 myself. I can help you setting it up if you want.

What is the different between the download executable and one compiled myself. Aren't they essentially the same code? Are some parts of the code excluded from a windows compile? Why would they do that?

They should be the same code. If you compile the source code yourself then you can verify the code and double check to make sure that there's no malicious code in the software. For the average user using the executable is much easier than compiling the source code into an executable.

Basically they offer the source code for users to read through, modify if they like, and compile for themselves if they wish. Launching an installer is much easier than compiling all the code.

jbrnt

hero member

Activity: 672

Merit: 500

HW.1 is so cheap I am eager to buy one for every day use. I am still waiting for better support for HW.1 from Electrum before I buy one to test.

Quote from: Muhammed Zakir on July 25, 2015, 09:05:50 AM

HW.1 is working fine for me but I compiled Electrum 2.0 myself. I can help you setting it up if you want.

What is the different between the download executable and one compiled myself. Aren't they essentially the same code? Are some parts of the code excluded from a windows compile? Why would they do that?

wosch76

legendary

Activity: 942

Merit: 1026

Quote from: Muhammed Zakir on July 25, 2015, 09:05:50 AM

HW.1 is working fine for me but I compiled Electrum 2.0 myself. I can help you setting it up if you want.

If you or someone else could post a dumbass proofed step-by-step guide.
that would be very kind Kiss

otherwise I'll just wait for future versions.

japerry

sr. member

Activity: 306

Merit: 250

Quote from: Muhammed Zakir on July 25, 2015, 09:05:50 AM

HW.1 is working fine for me but I compiled Electrum 2.0 myself. I can help you setting it up if you want.

I responded to you in a PM

Muhammed Zakir

hero member

Activity: 560

Merit: 509

I prefer Zakir over Muhammed when mentioning me!

HW.1 is working fine for me but I compiled Electrum 2.0 myself. I can help you setting it up if you want.

japerry

sr. member

Activity: 306

Merit: 250

Quote from: japerry on July 20, 2015, 08:39:46 AM

Quote from: wosch76 on July 20, 2015, 06:29:52 AM

Quote from: japerry on July 19, 2015, 11:19:49 AM

Quote from: ColderThanIce on July 19, 2015, 09:44:23 AM

I use a Trezor with Electrum and I have the Trezor plugged in before Electrum starts. I've never run into any issues with it before, and Electrum definitely works better than the MyTrezor site. If you're having issues with the latest Electrum release try using the 2.0 version as suggested because it seems to fix problems that users have with later releases.

Thanks for the report. I looked at 2.0 and saw that it doesn't support the HW.1. But after I re-intalled 2.3.2 it all started working anyway.

So it worked for you to create a hardware wallet?
I'm curious cause I have the same problem (HW.1 Dongle and no programming skills)

I'm actually on Version 2.2 and that didn't work.

1. I backed up my wallet(s) and contacts file.

2. Un-installed Electrum and removed all directories associated with Electrum.

3. Re-installed Electrum.

4. Set up the HW.1 wallet as the *very first* wallet in the new configuration.

5. Restored all the other non-HW wallets.

All is good now!

It turns out I wasn't quite right. Following the steps above will get Electrum to reliably tell you that the HW.1 isn't present if it's not plugged in. But if you have the HW.1 plugged in then it still doesn't work. If I look at the process table I show the Electrum executable still running but there's nothing on the screen. It's as though the process is hung and needs to be killed in the process manager.

The HW.1 I'm using has already been initialized using the default app. I'll set the key back to it's default state and see what happens.

UPDATE: I've attempted installing using a un-initialized HW.1 as well as one that has been initialized. I've tried all Electrum versions from 2.0.3 up to 2.3.2 without success. All versions show that Electrum is running but there is nothing on the screen.

Oh well... Maybe someday someone can get it working and enlighten us.

japerry

sr. member

Activity: 306

Merit: 250

Quote from: wosch76 on July 20, 2015, 06:29:52 AM

Quote from: japerry on July 19, 2015, 11:19:49 AM

Quote from: ColderThanIce on July 19, 2015, 09:44:23 AM

I use a Trezor with Electrum and I have the Trezor plugged in before Electrum starts. I've never run into any issues with it before, and Electrum definitely works better than the MyTrezor site. If you're having issues with the latest Electrum release try using the 2.0 version as suggested because it seems to fix problems that users have with later releases.

Thanks for the report. I looked at 2.0 and saw that it doesn't support the HW.1. But after I re-intalled 2.3.2 it all started working anyway.

So it worked for you to create a hardware wallet?
I'm curious cause I have the same problem (HW.1 Dongle and no programming skills)

I'm actually on Version 2.2 and that didn't work.

1. I backed up my wallet(s) and contacts file.

2. Un-installed Electrum and removed all directories associated with Electrum.

3. Re-installed Electrum.

4. Set up the HW.1 wallet as the *very first* wallet in the new configuration.

5. Restored all the other non-HW wallets.

All is good now!

wosch76

legendary

Activity: 942

Merit: 1026

Quote from: japerry on July 19, 2015, 11:19:49 AM

Quote from: ColderThanIce on July 19, 2015, 09:44:23 AM

I use a Trezor with Electrum and I have the Trezor plugged in before Electrum starts. I've never run into any issues with it before, and Electrum definitely works better than the MyTrezor site. If you're having issues with the latest Electrum release try using the 2.0 version as suggested because it seems to fix problems that users have with later releases.

Thanks for the report. I looked at 2.0 and saw that it doesn't support the HW.1. But after I re-intalled 2.3.2 it all started working anyway.

So it worked for you to create a hardware wallet?
I'm curious cause I have the same problem (HW.1 Dongle and no programming skills)

I'm actually on Version 2.2 and that didn't work.

japerry

sr. member

Activity: 306

Merit: 250

Quote from: ColderThanIce on July 19, 2015, 09:44:23 AM

I use a Trezor with Electrum and I have the Trezor plugged in before Electrum starts. I've never run into any issues with it before, and Electrum definitely works better than the MyTrezor site. If you're having issues with the latest Electrum release try using the 2.0 version as suggested because it seems to fix problems that users have with later releases.

Thanks for the report. I looked at 2.0 and saw that it doesn't support the HW.1. But after I re-intalled 2.3.2 it all started working anyway.

ColderThanIce

sr. member

Activity: 373

Merit: 252

I use a Trezor with Electrum and I have the Trezor plugged in before Electrum starts. I've never run into any issues with it before, and Electrum definitely works better than the MyTrezor site. If you're having issues with the latest Electrum release try using the 2.0 version as suggested because it seems to fix problems that users have with later releases.

japerry

sr. member

Activity: 306

Merit: 250

Quote from: jackbox on July 19, 2015, 07:41:45 AM

Quote from: japerry on July 19, 2015, 07:31:33 AM

I was wondering if there is/will be a Windows binary of Electrum that supports the Trezor and HW.1 hardware wallets? I have a HW.1 dongle now and from my reading of the Electrum forum, in order to use it with Electrum I would need to compile from scratch with the added libraries?

I'm not a programmer so compiling Electrum from scratch is not an option. I'd dearly LOVE to be able to use my new HW.1 under Windows 7.

If I try to run Electrum and build a hardware wallet Electrum just crashes.

Please advise.

I'm currently using Electrum 2.3.2

Use Electrum 2.0. It works fine with Trezor and does not crash. I stopped upgrading due to many problems and rezor not working after upgrades.

Are you plugging your Trezor in *BEFORE* you start Electrum?

jackbox

legendary

Activity: 1246

Merit: 1024

Quote from: japerry on July 19, 2015, 07:31:33 AM

I was wondering if there is/will be a Windows binary of Electrum that supports the Trezor and HW.1 hardware wallets? I have a HW.1 dongle now and from my reading of the Electrum forum, in order to use it with Electrum I would need to compile from scratch with the added libraries?

I'm not a programmer so compiling Electrum from scratch is not an option. I'd dearly LOVE to be able to use my new HW.1 under Windows 7.

If I try to run Electrum and build a hardware wallet Electrum just crashes.

Please advise.

I'm currently using Electrum 2.3.2

Use Electrum 2.0. It works fine with Trezor and does not crash. I stopped upgrading due to many problems and rezor not working after upgrades.

japerry

sr. member

Activity: 306

Merit: 250

I was wondering if there is/will be a Windows binary of Electrum that supports the Trezor and HW.1 hardware wallets? I have a HW.1 dongle now and from my reading of the Electrum forum, in order to use it with Electrum I would need to compile from scratch with the added libraries?

I'm not a programmer so compiling Electrum from scratch is not an option. I'd dearly LOVE to be able to use my new HW.1 under Windows 7.

If I try to run Electrum and build a hardware wallet Electrum just crashes.

Please advise.

I'm currently using Electrum 2.3.2

Topic: Hardware Wallet support for Windows in Electrum? (Read 1267 times)