How important in anonymity in Bitcoin transaction for the users?

NikolaTesla

newbie

Activity: 28

Merit: 0

Quote from: Beepbop on April 07, 2013, 05:07:29 PM

Hate to break it to you, NikolaTesla, but every Bitcoin transaction is a public matter. All full scale clients are sent all transactions. The randomness of the addresses provide some obfuscation, but it doesn't take much forensic accounting to trace where money is flowing. If you want more privacy, you'd be better served by cash, or even an old fashioned bank or wire transfer.

But each intermediate address in the flow provides plausible deniability. If I transfer $ from my bank account to Coinbase, then transfer those BTC from my Coinbase account to my local wallet, then buy something on silk road, there's no way they could know that the intermediate wallet step was mine or if I was just sending it to someone else who bought on silk road.

mobile4ever

hero member

Activity: 546

Merit: 500

Quote from: silzero on April 07, 2013, 03:31:28 PM

One of the issues that widespread use of Bitcoin is the irrevocability of the transaction. This itself is a good feature. But in absence of trust, this is feature is an additional hurdle. I'm trying to see if anonymity were to lessened (more like how Amazon/Paypal validates users) would this be a deal breaker for Bitcoin?

Now that mainstream population is aware of Bitcoin, this might be a chance for Bitcoin to become more mainstream.

Thanks,
-SZ

I think it should match other forms of money, but also be able to be tracked if a person wants their transaction history public. In other words, users can make their own choices.

Elwar

legendary

Activity: 3598

Merit: 2386

Viva Ut Vivas

Quote from: silzero on April 07, 2013, 04:35:13 PM

Quote from: Elwar on April 07, 2013, 04:19:09 PM

In some ways, Bitcoin is less anonymous than the dollar.

All of your transactions are right there for the world to see.

And you mention Amazon, PayPal, etc. for the non-anonymity of the dollar.

I see your third party services and return with BitMit, bitcoin-otc, bitcointalk.

You can look at the address in my signature and see exactly where I have received and spent bitcoins. Can you do that with your dollars?

Valid points... My poll question is do you care if someone sees the transaction invloved Elwar? In this poll, I'm just trying to get a sense of what people care about in Bitcoin transactions.

If I cared if someone saw my transactions I would just take steps to make them anonymous.

At the moment I do not care, just as must as I am willing to put my real name out on the Internet via facebook and other sites.

But if I wanted to have a private transaction (bitcoin cams or silk road etc.) I would want the ability to have some anonymity in those transactions and thus maybe buy bitcoins locally or run my coins through an anonymizing service or whichever.

Just as I would start creating fake names on the Internet or block access to my identity on various websites as that information starts to get used for darker purposes (ie. government/corporate/criminal tracking).

Beepbop

full member

Activity: 126

Merit: 100

Hate to break it to you, NikolaTesla, but every Bitcoin transaction is a public matter. All full scale clients are sent all transactions. The randomness of the addresses provide some obfuscation, but it doesn't take much forensic accounting to trace where money is flowing. If you want more privacy, you'd be better served by cash, or even an old fashioned bank or wire transfer.

NikolaTesla

newbie

Activity: 28

Merit: 0

The inherent privacy (and allowance for anonymity) is what makes Bitcoin what it is, IMO.

No way would I still use it if I thought spooks were monitoring everything I do.

silzero

newbie

Activity: 40

Merit: 0

Quote from: Elwar on April 07, 2013, 04:19:09 PM

In some ways, Bitcoin is less anonymous than the dollar.

All of your transactions are right there for the world to see.

And you mention Amazon, PayPal, etc. for the non-anonymity of the dollar.

I see your third party services and return with BitMit, bitcoin-otc, bitcointalk.

You can look at the address in my signature and see exactly where I have received and spent bitcoins. Can you do that with your dollars?

Valid points... My poll question is do you care if someone sees the transaction invloved Elwar? In this poll, I'm just trying to get a sense of what people care about in Bitcoin transactions.

Elwar

legendary

Activity: 3598

Merit: 2386

Viva Ut Vivas

In some ways, Bitcoin is less anonymous than the dollar.

All of your transactions are right there for the world to see.

And you mention Amazon, PayPal, etc. for the non-anonymity of the dollar.

I see your third party services and return with BitMit, bitcoin-otc, bitcointalk.

You can look at the address in my signature and see exactly where I have received and spent bitcoins. Can you do that with your dollars?

lassdas

legendary

Activity: 3676

Merit: 1495

Quote

I'll liquidate all Bitcoins if this feature were removed

Anonymity is not a feature of Bitcoin, so how could it be removed?

If you don't like to deal with anonymous users, just don't.
What currency, or payment system you use doesn't really matter.

silzero

newbie

Activity: 40

Merit: 0

@Akka: Nice points. Privacy a viewpoint I had not come across before (I'm still new and learning)

Thanks.

Akka

legendary

Activity: 1232

Merit: 1001

Anonymity not necessarily.

But Privacy. IMO People have a right to engage in private Transactions and it's a necessity for a non repressive society to function.

And that's a function Bitcoin has. Bitcoin transactions are not anonymous, they are pseudonymous. As soon as a person can be linked to an address all transaction this person has ever made with this address are known and they are stored in the Blockchain for eternity.

Imagine a criminal using Bitcoin to launder his money. When his PC is seized for example an his addresses are now known than the authorities have a perfect record of all transactions he has ever made.

silzero

newbie

Activity: 40

Merit: 0

Quote from: mai77 on April 07, 2013, 03:33:59 PM

you are starting a FUD campaign ? Huh

No. This is to try to clear the FUD that's being pumped by mainstream media.

mai77

newbie

Activity: 28

Merit: 0

you are starting a FUD campaign ? Huh

silzero

newbie

Activity: 40

Merit: 0

One of the issues that widespread use of Bitcoin is the irrevocability of the transaction. This itself is a good feature. But in absence of trust, this is feature is an additional hurdle. I'm trying to see if anonymity were to lessened (more like how Amazon/Paypal validates users) would this be a deal breaker for Bitcoin?

Now that mainstream population is aware of Bitcoin, this might be a chance for Bitcoin to become more mainstream.

Thanks,
-SZ

Topic: How important in anonymity in Bitcoin transaction for the users? (Read 1068 times)