Clarifications on Pool vs Solo Mining
There seems to be a lot of (common) misconceptions when it comes to "block finding". Mainly with the pool-miner who "found the block" regretting that they didn't solo-mine because "look, i'd have 25btc now all for me". Firstly, if every pool only paid out the blockfinder, there would be little point in mining in a pool - you would be better off just solo mining like everyone else - so it works both ways - you all get paid for the shares you submit.
Anyway, now more to the main point.
When you "stratum mine" on a pool (https://mining.bitcoin.cz/stratum-mining) - You're given parts of the pool's block template, with which to "work" - which contains unique header information different to all the other miners on the pool - then you add the nonce/extranonces and so on for your asic to increment and test the hashes are below the difficulty target - meaning that you are only checking a part of the entire possibility of all variations. So finding a block in this scenario is entirely different to "solo mining", in which you would have to check all parts of the block together.
Topic: I found a block !!! (Read 8905 times)
You may have had to split with others but it's still an achievement.
I wish i would mine one someday
I wish i would mine one someday
well finding a block on the pool sure its deprecianting but in a solo mode its like 25 BTCs in one day damn could get to 7000 dollars good job
Are there any waye to grab found block totally for youself while mining in a pool?
No, you're mining towards the pool's wallet and there is absolutely no way to redirect it. 
Are there any waye to grab found block totally for youself while mining in a pool?
Still have yet to find a block myself since the ASIC revolution, and I'm hashing 5 THash. Back when I was hashing 3 or so GHash on GPUs, I wound up discovering 11 blocks as part of a pool. It is luck and risk really. I look back and do the math thinking I could have earned 550 BTC at that time, but reality due to pool mining is I earned half that. I miss the days of pulling in 10 BTC a week... 
GPU mining back in 2010 would porbably be really cool and easy. When was the pool system intrduced?How did you earn only 50% of what you should have earned because of pool mining??
Still have yet to find a block myself since the ASIC revolution, and I'm hashing 5 THash. Back when I was hashing 3 or so GHash on GPUs, I wound up discovering 11 blocks as part of a pool. It is luck and risk really. I look back and do the math thinking I could have earned 550 BTC at that time, but reality due to pool mining is I earned half that. I miss the days of pulling in 10 BTC a week...
GPU mining back in 2010 would porbably be really cool and easy. When was the pool system intrduced? 
Still have yet to find a block myself since the ASIC revolution, and I'm hashing 5 THash. Back when I was hashing 3 or so GHash on GPUs, I wound up discovering 11 blocks as part of a pool. It is luck and risk really. I look back and do the math thinking I could have earned 550 BTC at that time, but reality due to pool mining is I earned half that. I miss the days of pulling in 10 BTC a week...
Amazing guys
Hitting the block solo on an altcoin is a nice rush too. It's exciting to be the moving part in the blockchain process.
There is no way to compare finding block BTC to Alts
Difference is far too big But it's true - it is always exciting 
FInding a block is amazing and rare, you could have got 25 BTC reward, if you werent part of a pool.
But its hard to predict, if you ever will.
But its hard to predict, if you ever will.
I found some blocks years ago 
With solomining.com you would have won a block for you haha
Good luck in the future
With solomining.com you would have won a block for you haha
Good luck in the future
and ur overlcocked too. amazing. just amazing!!
few months ago, I found three blocks on slush pool. 
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Would of been a lot better if it was solo mining but then again might of never found the block solo mining as pool mining is combined power so its tough one to judge but none the less good one for finding the block would be nice if you actually got the 25 BTC for it would be nice Christmas for you
Maybe back in 2010 you could have, but now its like a jackpot if you do so.
Without a pool chances are almost none.
Old good times!!
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Would of been a lot better if it was solo mining but then again might of never found the block solo mining as pool mining is combined power so its tough one to judge but none the less good one for finding the block would be nice if you actually got the 25 BTC for it would be nice Christmas for you
Maybe back in 2010 you could have, but now its like a jackpot if you do so.
Without a pool chances are almost none.
Old good times!!
Thats awesome! Frame a screen shot on the wall lol
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Would of been a lot better if it was solo mining but then again might of never found the block solo mining as pool mining is combined power so its tough one to judge but none the less good one for finding the block would be nice if you actually got the 25 BTC for it would be nice Christmas for you
Maybe back in 2010 you could have, but now its like a jackpot if you do so.
Without a pool chances are almost none.
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Would of been a lot better if it was solo mining but then again might of never found the block solo mining as pool mining is combined power so its tough one to judge but none the less good one for finding the block would be nice if you actually got the 25 BTC for it would be nice Christmas for you
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
I am new to mining. Whats the approximate amount you get if you find a block? Isn't it around 50 BTC?
25 BTC per block
Thats really nice. Would be much cool, if you were not part of a pool
Finding a block is really lucky speciialy with so many miners.
That's unreal, congrats 
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
I am new to mining. Whats the approximate amount you get if you find a block? Isn't it around 50 BTC?
25 BTC per block
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
https://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
I am new to mining. Whats the approximate amount you get if you find a block? Isn't it around 50 BTC?
Congratulation ! I wish i could mine bitcoin too but i dont have the hardware for it ...
You really lucky ^^ enjoy dat ! ^^Hope you gonna found more block !
You really lucky ^^ enjoy dat ! ^^Hope you gonna found more block !
congratulations.. wishing i could find a block myself too
I found 4 all in the same day with the same S3+. I wish I was solo mining but it was on a pool. I was like mother f***** but I'm happy I contributed.
Whoo! 4 in a day!!! On which pool?It wasn't really a pool but it was on a hash renting site. I don't want to name names because I don't want to be looked at like a shill. I use M's Ant monitor for all 12 of my S3s, I went to bed and didn't bother to watch the monitor at all the following day. When I finally looked at it in the evening, it showed 4 blocks found all on the same S3+. I couldn't believe it so I checked in the Antminer Web UI for that miner and sure as shit, it also showed 4 blocks found on the status tab. Whoever rented my rigs made out like a mofo.
I found 4 all in the same day with the same S3+. I wish I was solo mining but it was on a pool. I was like mother f***** but I'm happy I contributed.
Whoo! 4 in a day!!! On which pool? 
Block 234,956 found by me using 7970 on 5/17/2013
the diff there was more affordable, i remember it , i was mining at that time, it was around 7 M
I found 4 all in the same day with the same S3+. I wish I was solo mining but it was on a pool. I was like mother f***** but I'm happy I contributed.
You should have bought a lottery ticket on the day it happened.
I found 4 all in the same day with the same S3+. I wish I was solo mining but it was on a pool. I was like mother f***** but I'm happy I contributed.
Block 234,956 found by me using 7970 on 5/17/2013
it's it close to a miracle considering it's from an Antminer.
I just checked up my eclipsemc account and saw that I already found 2 blocks for this pool.
And I use 2 Antminers S3 here.
Congrats - you are insane to have that many tabs open in chrome BTW
Congrats DarkRavenGamer, I remember when I found my first block!
haha very nice, good luck you have there.
CONGRADS 
It was really lucky that if you could find a block, too shame you were not solo mining...
It was really lucky that if you could find a block, too shame you were not solo mining... 
Since I'm not in the club, I don't know how it works.
Does your pool send you a notification with congratulations?
Do they send balloons to your workplace and help you celebrate?
Does your pool send you a notification with congratulations?
Do they send balloons to your workplace and help you celebrate?
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
http://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've noticed that ghash.io isn't paying as much as the calculators are saying I should get. I will give it a few more days to get it confirmed, but, any pool recommendations?
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
http://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've noticed that ghash.io isn't paying as much as the calculators are saying I should get. I will give it a few more days to get it confirmed, but, any pool recommendations?
Did you get a bonus for finding a block?
ops.. there is one more option.. cheating.. but this is short way to win in this business anything
care to expand your knowledge of "cheating"?I'm not aware of any methods of "cheating" in mining that don't end up being unprofitable in the long run...
I write it here just because author of this thread is newbie.. and it may be useful for him ..Don't take it personally please..
. I just wanted to clarify that all of the methods that I have read about that one would label as "cheating" when it comes to mining seem to be more expensive than just mining "fairly". Unless you can predict the future or have a secret charm for luck, that is. I'm a bit worried to aswering
you know why.. ) but in short way - this is abouy cloud meaning stuff..
Finding a block must feel like winning the lottery, congrats
ops.. there is one more option.. cheating.. but this is short way to win in this business anything
care to expand your knowledge of "cheating"?I'm not aware of any methods of "cheating" in mining that don't end up being unprofitable in the long run...
I write it here just because author of this thread is newbie.. and it may be useful for him ..Don't take it personally please..
. I just wanted to clarify that all of the methods that I have read about that one would label as "cheating" when it comes to mining seem to be more expensive than just mining "fairly". Unless you can predict the future or have a secret charm for luck, that is. ops.. there is one more option.. cheating.. but this is short way to win in this business anything
care to expand your knowledge of "cheating"?I'm not aware of any methods of "cheating" in mining that don't end up being unprofitable in the long run...
I write it here just because author of this thread is newbie.. and it may be useful for him ..Don't take it personally please..
ops.. there is one more option.. cheating.. but this is short way to win in this business anything
care to expand your knowledge of "cheating"?I'm not aware of any methods of "cheating" in mining that don't end up being unprofitable in the long run...
ops.. there is one more option.. cheating.. but this is short way to win in this business anything
short - because people already smell scammers from very very far..
short - because people already smell scammers from very very far..
I have never mined but this must have been exciting, like finding treasure, how much did you made exactly?
i agree it's cool to see your miner hit something.. but being in the pool he basically made the same as he would if any of the rigs hit it.. and then move on to the next
It's like to open mining company with 50.. or 500 friends and when you find block you have to split everything between everyone.. but now mining looks like that.. if you want or not..
I have never mined but this must have been exciting, like finding treasure, how much did you made exactly?
i agree it's cool to see your miner hit something.. but being in the pool he basically made the same as he would if any of the rigs hit it.. and then move on to the next
I have never mined but this must have been exciting, like finding treasure, how much did you made exactly?
Since I was mining with a pool, the block with the 25 BTC got split and shared between all the miners.
So how many of that 25 BTC did you get in result? How many people were in that pool anyway? Was it worth it?
You get paid for how much work you have put in, with my mining speed I'm earning just about 0.05 BTC every day. You don't get anything special for finding the block, atleast not with this pool. Ghash.io.
Congrats for finding a block! But you have to think about changing pool .. Ghash.io is one big lottery
Absolutely, I will just get it confirmed with the next difficulty update. I will probably switch to eligius mining pool.
If he still feel good in mining he have to read, read, read and then take a decision where mining is good for him, but now the best move is to change pool... doesn't matter where.. ghash.io is the worst one and everyone know that..
I have never mined but this must have been exciting, like finding treasure, how much did you made exactly?
Since I was mining with a pool, the block with the 25 BTC got split and shared between all the miners.
So how many of that 25 BTC did you get in result? How many people were in that pool anyway? Was it worth it?
You get paid for how much work you have put in, with my mining speed I'm earning just about 0.05 BTC every day. You don't get anything special for finding the block, atleast not with this pool. Ghash.io.
Congrats for finding a block! But you have to think about changing pool .. Ghash.io is one big lottery
Absolutely, I will just get it confirmed with the next difficulty update. I will probably switch to eligius mining pool.
Congrats for finding a block! But you have to think about changing pool .. Ghash.io is one big lottery
I have never mined but this must have been exciting, like finding treasure, how much did you made exactly?
Since I was mining with a pool, the block with the 25 BTC got split and shared between all the miners.
So how many of that 25 BTC did you get in result? How many people were in that pool anyway? Was it worth it?
Congrats on finding a block! That's super impressive with just a single S3. Funny how it displays the best share as 0 though - the number must be too large to display on the Antminer status page.
they also share with you a block that they find....
lotery is corupt, better solo or much better pool!
you made me check my miners and i found 3 bloks!
not!
lotery is corupt, better solo or much better pool!
you made me check my miners and i found 3 bloks!
not!
Cool....you're lucky, but its all right if you were pool mining, you can still pride yourself
This would inspire others to try solo mining.
I would advise them better bet in a lottery ticket rather than go solo mining.
I have never mined but this must have been exciting, like finding treasure, how much did you made exactly?
Since I was mining with a pool, the block with the 25 BTC got split and shared between all the miners.
Good job! U're my Hero!
Congrats for finding the block.
I have never mined but this must have been exciting, like finding treasure, how much did you made exactly?
Congrat, now you can show off your page
This would inspire others to try solo mining.
congrats ! judging by OP's screenshot though, a much bigger achievement was finding the chrome tab that had your mining stats
Congrats, it's it close to a miracle considering it's from an Antminer. You don't need to switch pools, finding another block wouldn't be any time soon
Too bad you weren't mining on P2Pool, you would've gotten a nice 0.125BTC reward for finding a block! (assuming you would have found it there also..)
Congrats on finding a block in any event!
Congrats on finding a block in any event!
... if you're one of them people that are going to cry "omg i shoulda been mining solo!" you'd never get that block like that, it was a block within that pool, you were the lucky one to give the right share
Can you explain this in further detail? Maybe using a different metaphor? I'm not doubting that you are right, but I have often wondered about this myself, as I once found a block on BTCGuild, and of course, who isn't going to have that thought of "Man, if I had been solo mining"? I'll admit I've never even looked at the source code of a pool, maybe I should, but I thought that the shares i submit to a pool would be the same ones that my miner would submit if I were "mining solo", so to speak (of course, unless the pool sets your miner to only submit shares of a certain difficulty, which I suppose the majority of them do). I'm sure I'm missing some technical detail. ... if you're one of them people that are going to cry "omg i shoulda been mining solo!" you'd never get that block like that, it was a block within that pool, you were the lucky one to give the right share
Can you explain this in further detail? Maybe using a different metaphor? I'm not doubting that you are right, but I have often wondered about this myself, as I once found a block on BTCGuild, and of course, who isn't going to have that thought of "Man, if I had been solo mining"? I'll admit I've never even looked at the source code of a pool, maybe I should, but I thought that the shares i submit to a pool would be the same ones that my miner would submit if I were "mining solo", so to speak (of course, unless the pool sets your miner to only submit shares of a certain difficulty, which I suppose the majority of them do). I'm sure I'm missing some technical detail. ... if you're one of them people that are going to cry "omg i shoulda been mining solo!" you'd never get that block like that, it was a block within that pool, you were the lucky one to give the right share
Can you explain this in further detail? Maybe using a different metaphor? I'm not doubting that you are right, but I have often wondered about this myself, as I once found a block on BTCGuild, and of course, who isn't going to have that thought of "Man, if I had been solo mining"? I'll admit I've never even looked at the source code of a pool, maybe I should, but I thought that the shares i submit to a pool would be the same ones that my miner would submit if I were "mining solo", so to speak (of course, unless the pool sets your miner to only submit shares of a certain difficulty, which I suppose the majority of them do). I'm sure I'm missing some technical detail.
i want to find a block! cool even though you were in pool
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
http://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've noticed that ghash.io isn't paying as much as the calculators are saying I should get. I will give it a few more days to get it confirmed, but, any pool recommendations?
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
http://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've noticed that ghash.io isn't paying as much as the calculators are saying I should get. I will give it a few more days to get it confirmed, but, any pool recommendations?
Awersome, just if you are solo mining.
Still awesome even if pool mining. Congrats!
Rare find indeed. Congratulations. It is good to see non industrial miners in the era of huge scale mining farms and cloud mining.
congrats for winning a block lottery 
... if you're one of them people that are going to cry "omg i shoulda been mining solo!" you'd never get that block like that, it was a block within that pool, you were the lucky one to give the right share
its like you a half dozen people walking down the road, you'd be the lucky one to trip on a rock.
go by yourself, you never follow that same path to randomly trip on that rock.
on the other hand, congrats on the find
its like you a half dozen people walking down the road, you'd be the lucky one to trip on a rock.
go by yourself, you never follow that same path to randomly trip on that rock.
on the other hand, congrats on the find
That's great! I don't think I've ever found one myself yet. Your problems with Ghash are not uncommon. Switch to a better pool. I use Eligius.
congratulations
Unfortunately I was pool mining...
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
http://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Note that I did not receive anything extra for finding it!
But still! One of my Antminer S3+ found a block shortly after I restarted them.
Has anyone else found one?
http://i.imgur.com/GV4PThB.png
EDIT: I've switch to eligius.st pool.
Jump to: