Topic: I need an explanation about how mining works (Read 261 times)

You were wrong?

I thought I answered the questions.  Which question didn't I clear up for you?


Yep. I said that.  Twice. There were 4 days between when you were told to watch the video and when you asked more questions.  That's a really long bus ride.  Why bother asking questions if you aren't going to pay attention to the answers?


You're welcome.

Glad we could help.


Great.  Does it have anything to do with the video that I posted a link to?


In what way do you mean that it is a "page"?  This isn't a book.  It isn't typically printed on paper.

A block is a selection of one or more bitcoin transactions and an 80 byte header that contains about the block.


Did you even watch the video?

New blocks are created continuously and constantly.  On average, the necessary proof-of-work is completed on one new block every 10 minutes.

The miner earns the transaction fees from the transactions that are included in their block if their block is added to the blockchain.  Therefore, if there are enough unconfirmed transactions, a miner will typically fill their block with transactions (more transactions = more total fees).  However, a miner is allowed to create a block that is smaller than the maximum allowed size, and they may do so for various reasons (such as if there are not enough transactions waiting to be confirmed).


Ok, it is clear that you did not watch the video.

Go watch it, then let me know if you still have some questions.

The miner includes a special transaction in his block that is not funded with any existing bitcoins and which pays himself the allowable reward (block subsidy plus fees)


These questions were answered in that video that I linked to.  Why didn't you watch the video before wasting time asking these questions.

The block "completes" when the miner finds a nonce value that results in a block hash which is below the target value.  At that point the miner can brodcast his block to all connected peers.

A new one is created whenever a completed block is received, or whenever the miners decides to abandon the block they are working on and start over with new data.


Please go watch the video.  Then come back and ask any questions that you still have.

The amount of time that it takes to complete the proof-of-work on a block is not meaningfully effected by the number of transactions.


The problem isn't that they are "obvious".  The problem is that they've already been answered (if you watched the video at the link that was provided).

I guess you could call it 'page' under given circumstances, yes.




Thats not how it works.
Blocks are 'created' when a miner finds a valid hash (linking to the previous block).
A miner can inlcude as much unconfirmed transactions as he wishes into a block (block size (non-witness part) has to be < 1 MB).
In addition to the unconfirmed transactions from the mempool a miner (usually) includes the coinbase transaction (block reward, currently 12.5 btc).




A new block is 'completed' each time a miner has calculated a block.
When a new block is published all miner start working on a new block (with a link to the previous block).
Basically its a probabilitygame. The difficulty of the network adjusts to have a block generation time of about 10 minutes (on average).

If you want to put it that way, yes.

Sort of.
The "page" doesn't have to be full.
The miner can decide to put only the Coinbase transaction (the one paying himself the block reward) and leave the rest of the rest of the "page" blank (i.e include no other transactions in the block)
No.
There's no specific number of transactions.
Actually there is, but it's relative, not absolute.
There's a block weight limit (previously a block size)
Transactions can be different sizes, but the total size of a block is limited, so the number of transactions that can fit in a block depends on the size of the transactions.
(That's the basis of how Segwit is a block size increase: it reduces the sizes of transactions so more transactions can fit in a block)
So a block can have either 1 transaction, or (theoretically) ~12,000 if all transactions were segwit transactions with 1 input and 1 output.

TL;DR: A block can be any size less than or equal to 4MB (kWU)
Any block must include the Coinbase transaction
So a block can have only the Coinbase transaction and be valid

Yep, this is correct and I cannot argue. From the way the question looked I had the feeling it's indeed another section.

This is the Technical Support sub-forum, isn't it?

If you ask questions in the Technical Support sub-forum, you should expect (and should receive) technically correct answers.

If you don't want details or you want a good sense of what happens which is not 100% correct, then you should ask in the Beginners and Help or the Bitcoin Discussion sub-forums.

I still believe that what I provided is just fine for OP. Although the explanations I linked are not 100% accurate, they give a good sense of what happens there to somebody who don't want to spend more than 5 minutes to understand the big picture.
I don't know the deep details as good as maybe I should (and you know that maybe even better than myself) and imho most users don't need them for normal use of Bitcoin.

Your details are great, accurate, but too many and too deep for OP, no offense.

PS. At the first occasion I get enough time I will clearly watch that video, not just "scan" it.

"Random" makes it sound like it is different every time.  If you use the exact same input, you will get the exact same output, every time you calculate it.  It might be better to describe it as "unpredictable".  There is no known way to predict what the output will be without actually performing the calculation. Even the smallest possible change (one bit) to the input will completely change the output in unpredictable ways.


More specifically, the BLOCK HEADER as the input.  The 80 byte block header consists of 6 pieces of information:

• The 4 byte version number
• The 32 byte SHA256 hash of the previous block in the chain
• The 32 byte Merkle Root (calculated by hashing the transactions that are included in the block)
• The 4 byte timestamp (represented as number of seconds since Midnight the morning of January 1, 1970)
• The 4 byte representation of current mining difficulty
• The 4 byte nonce (a value that has no meaning and exists solely so that you can change the input to the mining function)

The miner manipulates the value of the nonce prior to each hashing attempt so that they can get a new hash result.


Actually, you are looking for a hash that has a lower value than the current difficulty target.  Smaller targets do result in more leading zeros (0000123 has 4 leading zeros and is less than 0001234), but it is possible that two values could have the same number of leading zeros and only one of them is a valid proof-of-work (imagine that the target is 0004567, in that case 0005678 and 0003210 BOTH have 3 leading zeros, but only one of them is lower than the target)


Actually, the difficulty adjusts every 2016 blocks.  If the blocks are being solved at an average rate of 10 minutes per block, then that works out to 20160 minutes (which is 14 days).  If blocks are being solved faster than an average of ten minutes each, then the adjustment will happen sooner. If blocks are being solved slower than an average of ten minutes each, then the adjustment will happen later. The adjustment is proportional to the difference between 20160 minutes and the actual amount of time that it takes to solve the 2016 blocks.  That way the new difficulty should result in an average amount of time to solve a block which is closer to 10 minutes.


Correct.  It is also sometimes called the "generation transaction" or the "block reward".  In addition to the block subsidy, aka "freshly minted BTC's" (currently 12.5 bitcoins), this transaction ALSO includes the sum of all the transaction fees of all the transactions in the block.

The description "coinbase transaction" existed prior to the Coinbase business.  Since the business was built as a way to buy and sell bitcoins, they used an existing bitcoin word as the name of their business.

This is also true of blockchain.info.  Bitcoin, and the bitcoin blockchain, existed before the blockchain.info website.  Since the website was created as a way to see information about the bitcoin blockchain, they used the existing bitcoin word as the name of their website.


Correct.

I'll give it a try:

You can think of hashing as a 'mathematical equation' where you produce a (random) output depending on the input.
Now, when you mine, you are basically calculating hashes (with the TX's as input) until you have found a hash with X leading 0's.
How much 0's are needed is defined by the difficulty of the network. This difficulty adjusts every 2 weeks to get a 6 blocks per hour 'speed'.
Each time you mine a block the first transaction in this block is the coinbase transaction (has nothing to do with coinbase.com).
This coinbase transaction contains the freshly mined BTC's to the miners address.

Basically its a probability game. The miner with the highest hashrate (most calculations per second) has the highest chance of mining a block (calculating a valid hash) proportionally.


Thats just a very basic description of the mining process. Feel free to ask more detailed questions.

Personally, I wouldn't recommend either of those links. BOTH of them are rather misleading and get some details entirely incorrect.  There are definitely better sources of information.

To get a grasp on the general concepts, I suggest watching this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bBC-nXj3Ng4

Some of the specific details are generalized or simplified in that video, so it won't give you an exact understanding of every technical detail, but it is a good introduction to the more basic concepts.

Then once you've watched it, let me know if you still have some questions.

The information was written a good number of times, so I will not do the same again. If you want non technical info you should add ELI5 in the list of keywords you are searching for.
I searched for Bitcoin mining eli5
Of course, some results are still technical, but I will give two links from the same reddit thread which seem to cover the story pretty good, so you can start with them: main explanation and fix and completion

Hey there!
I''ve recently become interested about cryptocurrencies (and this forum, as well) so I'd like to learn more about it and I'll probably think about investing in them in future. But before I do, I'd like to learn about the technical side of it.

Could you please explain to me, as easily as possible, how does mining work? How does it happen that we "mine" bitcoins and that we get them?

I try to understand but I can't find anything but technical descriptions, and since I'm not so familiar with this, I need a simple explanation

Thanks a lot