Is Margin Trading Killing Bitcoin? | Bitcointalksearch.org

BitMos

full member

Activity: 182

Merit: 123

"PLEASE SCULPT YOUR SHIT BEFORE THROWING. Thank U"

Quote from: TheRama on February 05, 2015, 10:45:16 PM

Uhhh.. I'm not a market genius, but I'm pretty sure currency traders create liquidity, not take it away.

If anything we need more traders to close the bid-ask spreads in all of the exchanges. The huge spreads between bitcoin exchanges is what is the problem. We also need more futures trading to create more predictability in the price of bitcoin and give those futures traders as much margin as the exchange can handle.

sublime! add easy volatility index products (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VIX) and rulezzzz...

traderman

legendary

Activity: 1260

Merit: 1001

YEP! No merchant will have confidence in bitcoin to hold it, it will just become another payment gateway for them. Which is ok, but that is not what Bitcoin was designed for.

Quote from: Q7 on February 07, 2015, 08:51:11 AM

What happens in exchangers is that even though there is a buying and selling activity going on involving bitcoins in actual fact, btc never changed hands. It is just numbers adding up and reducing. And that is what gives the power to trader to short sell and pushing the price down with money they don't actually own. And yes, it affects bitcoin negatively.

Q7

sr. member

Activity: 448

Merit: 250

What happens in exchangers is that even though there is a buying and selling activity going on involving bitcoins in actual fact, btc never changed hands. It is just numbers adding up and reducing. And that is what gives the power to trader to short sell and pushing the price down with money they don't actually own. And yes, it affects bitcoin negatively.

Elwar

legendary

Activity: 3598

Merit: 2386

Viva Ut Vivas

I have 5000 euro on a small European exchange. The current price is 195 euro. If I were to buy bitcoins with those 5000 euro I would drive the price up to 210 euro. This is what causes price swings.

If, however, people were going short and long on margin my measly 5000 euro wouldn't make a dent.

TheRama

newbie

Activity: 11

Merit: 0

Quote from: traderman on February 06, 2015, 02:26:45 PM

I never suggested any kind of central control on traders, just imagine what will start to happen when traders are able to borrow 10:1 or 50:1, you think that won't create ridiculous volatility?? You think any merchant will accept Bitcoin with massive daily swings? Because that is where things are headed!

Quote from: Elwar on February 06, 2015, 01:41:40 PM

Maybe we should have guys with guns in every city that oversee every Bitcoin trade controlled by a central entity to make the rules of how bitcoins can be traded.

That would be ideal. Maybe then we would have a useful currency.

And if someone tries to make a trade that doesn't follow the rules...shoot them in the face.

I'm saying that you are mistaken on the source of volatility. Illiquidity creates volatility not the other way around.

You are thinking too hard of using BTC as a store of value when that is not how merchants like tigerdirect are using it. Merchants today don't carry BTC on their books longer than they have to because of currency risk. They are using Bitcoin as a medium of exchange where volatility matters much less than illiquidity and bid-ask spreads. If the buyer has to buy on the bid and the merchant has to sell on the ask then BTC is not saving anybody money.

Bitcoin is itself volatile due to its newness, margin or no margin doesn't matter. But what traders do is vitally important to the usability of bitcoins. The best thing that can happen to bitcoin volatility is to create a trusted futures exchange with long term contracts that is also highly liquid. Only way to do that is through margin.

Elwar

legendary

Activity: 3598

Merit: 2386

Viva Ut Vivas

Quote from: traderman on February 06, 2015, 02:26:45 PM

I never suggested any kind of central control on traders, just imagine what will start to happen when traders are able to borrow 10:1 or 50:1, you think that won't create ridiculous volatility?? You think any merchant will accept Bitcoin with massive daily swings? Because that is where things are headed!

Quote from: Elwar on February 06, 2015, 01:41:40 PM

Maybe we should have guys with guns in every city that oversee every Bitcoin trade controlled by a central entity to make the rules of how bitcoins can be traded.

That would be ideal. Maybe then we would have a useful currency.

And if someone tries to make a trade that doesn't follow the rules...shoot them in the face.

You can borrow 50:1 already.

traderman

legendary

Activity: 1260

Merit: 1001

I never suggested any kind of central control on traders, just imagine what will start to happen when traders are able to borrow 10:1 or 50:1, you think that won't create ridiculous volatility?? You think any merchant will accept Bitcoin with massive daily swings? Because that is where things are headed!

Quote from: Elwar on February 06, 2015, 01:41:40 PM

Maybe we should have guys with guns in every city that oversee every Bitcoin trade controlled by a central entity to make the rules of how bitcoins can be traded.

That would be ideal. Maybe then we would have a useful currency.

And if someone tries to make a trade that doesn't follow the rules...shoot them in the face.

Elwar

legendary

Activity: 3598

Merit: 2386

Viva Ut Vivas

Maybe we should have guys with guns in every city that oversee every Bitcoin trade controlled by a central entity to make the rules of how bitcoins can be traded.

That would be ideal. Maybe then we would have a useful currency.

And if someone tries to make a trade that doesn't follow the rules...shoot them in the face.

bigkahuna

newbie

Activity: 46

Merit: 0

From reading this article I understand that as time passes, there will be less and less or an impact from margin traders.

TheRama

newbie

Activity: 11

Merit: 0

Quote from: traderman on February 06, 2015, 10:46:18 AM

The problem isn't the price going up, it is the wild back and forth swings as leveraged traders enter and exit trades that is hampering Bitcoin being used as an actual currency. When the Russian rubble started to drop in the last few weeks people were scrambling to buy any hard asset they could get their hands on to preserve purchasing power. So the same concept applies to Bitcoin. Stability is necessary for bitcoin to flourish as a means of exchange, otherwise all we have is a fancy new casino.

Quote from: slacknation on February 06, 2015, 01:14:29 AM

if everyone wants the price of bitcoin to go up, y don't we create a system such that no one can sell lower than the last price?

Margin trading doesn't create volatility. The underlying creates volatility. No one knows what bitcoins should be worth. That's the primary issue. It really doesn't matter if it's one dude buying and selling Bitcoin with 10x leverage or 10 people buying and selling Bitcoin with just cash. It's the same.

We need MORE traders, leveraged or not. The spreads are what makes BTC unusable for daily transactions, not volatility. Imagine you go to a store that lets you pay with BTC with a spot price exchange....

For the buyer, he doesn't want to pay in an equivalent amount of BTC because he's going to end up paying the Bid which might be .5 to 1% greater than the Ask price.

In that situation why would I pay in bitcoins when I can pull out my credit card and get 2% cash rewards?

fenghush

sr. member

Activity: 658

Merit: 250

I've read the article and I missed the point how margin trading is killing bitcoin.

traderman

legendary

Activity: 1260

Merit: 1001

The problem isn't the price going up, it is the wild back and forth swings as leveraged traders enter and exit trades that is hampering Bitcoin being used as an actual currency. When the Russian rubble started to drop in the last few weeks people were scrambling to buy any hard asset they could get their hands on to preserve purchasing power. So the same concept applies to Bitcoin. Stability is necessary for bitcoin to flourish as a means of exchange, otherwise all we have is a fancy new casino.

Quote from: slacknation on February 06, 2015, 01:14:29 AM

if everyone wants the price of bitcoin to go up, y don't we create a system such that no one can sell lower than the last price?

slacknation

member

Activity: 93

Merit: 10

if everyone wants the price of bitcoin to go up, y don't we create a system such that no one can sell lower than the last price?

PaulPierce

member

Activity: 112

Merit: 10

Quote from: Crypto9er on February 05, 2015, 11:46:55 PM

Quote from: traderman on February 05, 2015, 11:39:47 PM

The implication is that Bitfinex being the largest exchange and offering traders the option to lever up in an illiquid market causes excessive volatility.

Quote from: odolvlobo on February 05, 2015, 11:26:03 PM

Don't bother reading the article. Only one sentence in the entire article was about margin trading and Bitcoin and here it is:

Quote

Bitfinex’s current leverage is about 3.3 to 1 for buying Bitcoin/Litecoin on margin, which is very miniscule compared to the leverage in more established markets.

I m more worried about Higher leverage (Like futures trading - 10/20x leverage), where sometimes with just few coins, traders can move the price up/down by few $. It make it much easier for "Big players" to manipulate the price and drive it in any direction they want.

True mate..even I am a bit worried about the "big Players" but I guess there is mostly someone to counter it..so it doesnt move much..unless few big guns sync it together.

Crypto9er

member

Activity: 60

Merit: 10

Quote from: traderman on February 05, 2015, 11:39:47 PM

The implication is that Bitfinex being the largest exchange and offering traders the option to lever up in an illiquid market causes excessive volatility.

Quote from: odolvlobo on February 05, 2015, 11:26:03 PM

Don't bother reading the article. Only one sentence in the entire article was about margin trading and Bitcoin and here it is:

Quote

Bitfinex’s current leverage is about 3.3 to 1 for buying Bitcoin/Litecoin on margin, which is very miniscule compared to the leverage in more established markets.

I m more worried about Higher leverage (Like futures trading - 10/20x leverage), where sometimes with just few coins, traders can move the price up/down by few $. It make it much easier for "Big players" to manipulate the price and drive it in any direction they want.

traderman

legendary

Activity: 1260

Merit: 1001

The implication is that Bitfinex being the largest exchange and offering traders the option to lever up in an illiquid market causes excessive volatility.

Quote from: odolvlobo on February 05, 2015, 11:26:03 PM

Don't bother reading the article. Only one sentence in the entire article was about margin trading and Bitcoin and here it is:

Quote

Bitfinex’s current leverage is about 3.3 to 1 for buying Bitcoin/Litecoin on margin, which is very miniscule compared to the leverage in more established markets.

GRWer

newbie

Activity: 16

Merit: 0

i am not sure about margin . but the chinese exchanges okcoin & huobi are creating tons of faking bitcoins on their platform to make profit , that's why bitcoin price falls

odolvlobo

legendary

Activity: 4466

Merit: 3391

Don't bother reading the article. Only one sentence in the entire article was about margin trading and Bitcoin and here it is:

Quote

Bitfinex’s current leverage is about 3.3 to 1 for buying Bitcoin/Litecoin on margin, which is very miniscule compared to the leverage in more established markets.

traderman

legendary

Activity: 1260

Merit: 1001

Having more traders is better as the spread will be tighter, but margin creates too much swinging. Especially in a price fall where you get mass liquidation due to panic.

Quote from: TheRama on February 05, 2015, 10:45:16 PM

Uhhh.. I'm not a market genius, but I'm pretty sure currency traders create liquidity, not take it away.

If anything we need more traders to close the bid-ask spreads in all of the exchanges. The huge spreads between bitcoin exchanges is what is the problem. We also need more futures trading to create more predictability in the price of bitcoin and give those futures traders as much margin as the exchange can handle.

TheRama

newbie

Activity: 11

Merit: 0

Uhhh.. I'm not a market genius, but I'm pretty sure currency traders create liquidity, not take it away.

If anything we need more traders to close the bid-ask spreads in all of the exchanges. The huge spreads between bitcoin exchanges is what is the problem. We also need more futures trading to create more predictability in the price of bitcoin and give those futures traders as much margin as the exchange can handle.

traderman

legendary

Activity: 1260

Merit: 1001

I think it's about time we have this discussion!

http://www.btcfeed.net/news/margin-trading-killing-bitcoin/

Topic: Is Margin Trading Killing Bitcoin? (Read 1546 times)