Author

Topic: Is unconfirmed transaction revirsable ? (Read 391 times)

hero member
Activity: 2030
Merit: 578
No God or Kings, only BITCOIN.
December 27, 2020, 10:52:38 AM
#25
Still, I don't understand why you would pay a higher fee to cancel the transaction. You can just increase the fee of your original transaction. You do not need any extra coins in your wallet as long as you are fine with the smaller amount of coins sent to the other address.
I get that "Increase fee" now and that graph was a lot more helpful. Appreciate it.
legendary
Activity: 1876
Merit: 3139
December 27, 2020, 10:27:09 AM
#24
I try to click the double spend and it shows it will be sent to my other wallet address but will it still be stuck again considering the fee will be 3 sat/byte or that will be just instant?

By the time you read my reply, the fees might have have changed significantly. Go to this website and look at the third graph. Hover your mouse over it and you will see some detailed information on the fees. Every value under 1 MB should get your transaction confirmed in the next block if the blocks are mined regularly.

Still, I don't understand why you would pay a higher fee to cancel the transaction. You can just increase the fee of your original transaction. You do not need any extra coins in your wallet as long as you are fine with the smaller amount of coins being sent to the other address.
hero member
Activity: 2030
Merit: 578
No God or Kings, only BITCOIN.
December 27, 2020, 10:07:57 AM
#23
In such a case, Electrum should decrease the value of your transaction's output just as if you cancelled the transaction by double-spending it. If you had some coins your wallet, Electrum would add a new input to your transaction.
The thing is I have to withdraw from my Binance account to my wallet that currently has 0 balance but what a heck of a fee from Binance right now amounting to $13 for a single transaction, not a fan of that. My choice is to let it be mine on what blocks it should be mined.

I try to click the double spend and it shows it will be sent to my other wallet address but will it still be stuck again considering the fee will be 3 sat/byte or that will be just instant? Just bear with me with these lot of questions. Grin
legendary
Activity: 1876
Merit: 3139
December 27, 2020, 08:50:23 AM
#22
I don't have some sats to "Increase fee" as there is no balance left on my purse as I've put it to the max.

In such a case, Electrum should decrease the value of your transaction's output just as if you cancelled the transaction by double-spending it. If you had some coins your wallet, Electrum would add a new input to your transaction.
hero member
Activity: 2030
Merit: 578
No God or Kings, only BITCOIN.
December 27, 2020, 08:43:57 AM
#21
Your transaction will be double-spent to you with a higher fee than your original transaction automatically. Unless you have to pay a specific amount of BTC to someone, it might be a better idea to select "Increase fee" and set it to 20 sat/byte which should be enough to get your transaction confirmed in the block.
I see thanks for the quick response. I think I'll have to wait for it, it was almost hours from now maybe it will be confirmed later on. I don't have some sats to "Increase fee" as there is no balance left on my purse as I've put it to the max. I thought it was as simple as canceling it, I think it will be higher than 20 sat/byte if I double-spent it.
legendary
Activity: 1876
Merit: 3139
December 27, 2020, 08:16:53 AM
#20
My question is if I do click that "Cancel (double spend)" will it cancel the whole transaction? I was just a bit skeptical to click that and my bad as well as I thought I set it for 20 sat/byte but it was just 2 sat/byte.

Your transaction will be double-spent to you with a higher fee than your original transaction automatically. Unless you have to pay a specific amount of BTC to someone, it might be a better idea to select "Increase fee" and set it to 20 sat/byte which should be enough to get your transaction confirmed in the block.
hero member
Activity: 2030
Merit: 578
No God or Kings, only BITCOIN.
December 27, 2020, 07:53:36 AM
#19
I am using the latest version of Electrum 4.0.9 and my transaction was still stuck to 10 blocks and as I see on mempool.space it shows it has RBF feature. I search how to do that but somehow I saw this "Cancel (double spend)" on my wallet along with "Increase fee". My question is if I do click that "Cancel (double spend)" will it cancel the whole transaction? I was just a bit skeptical to click that and my bad as well as I thought I set it for 20 sat/byte but it was just 2 sat/byte.  Embarrassed
legendary
Activity: 1624
Merit: 2481
December 25, 2020, 11:18:33 AM
#18
I am still sure I have download this from electrum.org in 2019 [...]
I never check signature.

You should start to check the signature.

Just because you believe you were on electrum.org, it doesn't necessarily to be the case.
Verifying the signature is the only way to be sure that you have downloaded the original version.


The possibility that your pc got infected, definitely exists. Did you recently download or install any other software?
legendary
Activity: 1568
Merit: 6660
bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org
December 24, 2020, 07:54:40 PM
#17
Edit: Now as I was checking my all computer suddenly my Electrum wallet dissappear now after few restarts and antivirus scan its still not appearing is this any malware or what any comments about this.

It disappeared out of the blue while the computer was idle, or while you were running the antivirus scan? If it disappeared during the AV scan then it must have quarantined it, so check the AV's quarantined file list to see if it's there.
full member
Activity: 896
Merit: 236
December 24, 2020, 01:10:32 PM
#16
Edit: Now as I was checking my all computer suddenly my Electrum wallet dissappear now after few restarts and antivirus scan its still not appearing is this any malware or what any comments about this.

You said that you downloaded Electrum from electrum.org; however, you didn't confirm that you have checked the signature; if you didn't there's a chance you may have been tricked to download from a clone site with similar domain name and (like eIectrum.org or such)

This is the first thing that comes into my mind, but other things may have happened - from malware to false positive...
I am still sure I have download this from electrum.org in 2019 but I done one mistake few days back I was checking one site where I try to downlaod one thing but its not works then quickly I delete this but now feeling its done his work.

I never check signature.
legendary
Activity: 3668
Merit: 6382
Looking for campaign manager? Contact icopress!
December 24, 2020, 01:05:25 PM
#15
Edit: Now as I was checking my all computer suddenly my Electrum wallet dissappear now after few restarts and antivirus scan its still not appearing is this any malware or what any comments about this.

You said that you downloaded Electrum from electrum.org; however, you didn't confirm that you have checked the signature; if you didn't there's a chance you may have been tricked to download from a clone site with similar domain name and (like eIectrum.org or such)

This is the first thing that comes into my mind, but other things may have happened - from malware to false positive...
full member
Activity: 896
Merit: 236
December 24, 2020, 11:29:19 AM
#14
If the transaction has already been confirmed there is no going back and even the new version of Electrum can't help him. RBF to yourself is only effective while the transaction is unconfirmed.
Yes, I know that.

I think he mentioned above that the transaction has already went through
In the OP he said that the transaction is not yet confirmed. I read again the rest of his posts in this thread and he posted no updates that the transaction got confirmed in the meantime.
I realize something strange as my payment is going on wrong address but its still uncofirmed so is this reversable or can any one do this cancel.
He only confirmed that he enabled RBF in the original transaction.
Sorry for very late reply as today network was not available just because of this I was unable to give you any update sadly as I updated my Electrum transaction was confirmed and I have no chance to do any thing its really strange thing happened and now already lost my funds just because of some careless.

Edit: Now as I was checking my all computer suddenly my Electrum wallet dissappear now after few restarts and antivirus scan its still not appearing is this any malware or what any comments about this.
legendary
Activity: 2730
Merit: 7065
December 24, 2020, 04:29:22 AM
#13
If the transaction has already been confirmed there is no going back and even the new version of Electrum can't help him. RBF to yourself is only effective while the transaction is unconfirmed.
Yes, I know that.

I think he mentioned above that the transaction has already went through
In the OP he said that the transaction is not yet confirmed. I read again the rest of his posts in this thread and he posted no updates that the transaction got confirmed in the meantime.
I realize something strange as my payment is going on wrong address but its still uncofirmed so is this reversable or can any one do this cancel.
He only confirmed that he enabled RBF in the original transaction.
legendary
Activity: 1568
Merit: 6660
bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org
December 24, 2020, 04:00:28 AM
#12
Since Indymoney sent the original transaction with Electrum version 3.3.8, where the 'cancel transaction' (double spend) feature wasn't yet implemented, will he still be able to return the coins back to his wallet after installing the newest 4.0.9 version? The positive thing is that he enabled RBF, but has anyone tested if the 'cancel transaction' feature works in connection with older Electrum versions?

Even without that feature, he should in theory be able to double spend it back to his address if he is lucky and the initial transaction doesn't get confirmed in the meantime. 

If the transaction has already been confirmed there is no going back and even the new version of Electrum can't help him. RBF to yourself is only effective while the transaction is unconfirmed.

I think he mentioned above that the transaction has already went through, but there is a method for replacing unconfirmed transactions which works on older versions of Electrum that @bob123 posted in another thread. It helped me reverse an unconfirmed transaction of mine one time.

  • Disconnect Electrum from the Network
  • Open the console (View -> Show Console -> Then the "Console" tab)
  • Enter: wallet.remove_transaction("a219bb1983c1dea6a00360fa830e5961deaf5a1dccbafd0578c81087db3b50e5")
  • Close and restart Electrum
  • Create a new transaction sending your funds with a pretty high fee (definitely more than the 16 sat/vB from the first transaction) -> sign it and save/export it
  • Connect electrum to the network again
  • Import the just created transaction (Tools -> Load transaction -> from text/file (depending on what you have chosen in the last step))
  • Broadcast it

But replace the transaction ID with Indymoney's. Unfortunately this also only works for unconfirmed transactions.
legendary
Activity: 2730
Merit: 7065
December 24, 2020, 03:41:39 AM
#11
Since Indymoney sent the original transaction with Electrum version 3.3.8, where the 'cancel transaction' (double spend) feature wasn't yet implemented, will he still be able to return the coins back to his wallet after installing the newest 4.0.9 version? The positive thing is that he enabled RBF, but has anyone tested if the 'cancel transaction' feature works in connection with older Electrum versions?

Even without that feature, he should in theory be able to double spend it back to his address if he is lucky and the initial transaction doesn't get confirmed in the meantime. 
legendary
Activity: 1568
Merit: 6660
bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org
December 24, 2020, 03:37:40 AM
#10
If the transaction has already went through and you were sending it to a business' address and you simply sent it  to an address they're no longer listening to, you need to contact them for support and tell them you sent money to the wrong address which they control.

It could also be clipboard malware which changed the address. What is the address that you send funds to by mistake? Maybe it's in the database of scam addresses. There is a certain site tracking them which I forgot its name.
legendary
Activity: 3472
Merit: 10611
December 23, 2020, 10:19:55 PM
#9
Just to be clear you can not cancel or reverse a bitcoin transaction, even if it is unconfirmed. However, you can double spend it. Which is basically you making that previous transaction invalid by spending the inputs of the first transaction in a way that it confirms faster.
So even though the button is called "Cancel" but in reality you are paying some additional fee for a new transaction that double spends the same outputs but this time it sends the coins to your own wallet.
legendary
Activity: 3472
Merit: 3217
Playbet.io - Crypto Casino and Sportsbook
December 23, 2020, 05:50:29 PM
#8
I realize something strange as my payment is going on wrong address

Did you double-check the transaction before you send it?
If you remember that you sent it to the right address and it was changed to a different address you might be infected.

I suggest you before you use the latest version of Electrum as suggested above, install the latest version of Electrum to a known safe and clean PC/laptop(If you have extra) and import your wallet file or seed phrase.
After that do what they said(Cancel the transaction).
legendary
Activity: 1876
Merit: 3139
December 23, 2020, 04:57:55 PM
#7
Edit: asking just for information I will able to have all my addresses on new version ?

Yes, your wallet will remain untouched. You should also verify the installer before doing every update. Since you need to cancel your transaction urgently, you can skip this step exceptionally.
full member
Activity: 896
Merit: 236
December 23, 2020, 04:48:25 PM
#6
~
Did you download it from Electrum.org? Download the latest version (4.0.9) and you should have the "Cancel transaction" option when right clicking the unconfirmed transaction.
Yes I download this from Electrum.org and never update now trying to download new version in next few minutes because its very important for me to stop this transaction.

Edit: asking just for information I will able to have all my addresses on new version ?
legendary
Activity: 2758
Merit: 6830
December 23, 2020, 04:46:00 PM
#5
~
Did you download it from Electrum.org? Download the latest version (4.0.9) and you should have the "Cancel transaction" option when right clicking the unconfirmed transaction.
full member
Activity: 896
Merit: 236
December 23, 2020, 04:44:54 PM
#4
Today I was sending a payment to another user from my Electrum all was ok because I am using this for last few years but after few hours I realize something strange as my payment is going on wrong address but its still uncofirmed so is this reversable or can any one do this cancel.

If you are running Electrum 4.0.4 or newer and if the transaction is marked as replaceable then you should see "Cancel tx" under the context menu once you right-click on that transaction. Do you recognise the address to which the coins were sent? From where did you download your version of Electrum? The address should not have changed on its own.
I just check and its showing I am using electrum 3.3.8
If your transaction has the RBF flag, you can right click it and select "Cancel transaction" to double-spend it back to your wallet with a higher fee.
RBF: True
sadly now I have nothing in my wallet its showing zero because I send all amount in this transaction.
legendary
Activity: 1876
Merit: 3139
December 23, 2020, 04:36:27 PM
#3
Today I was sending a payment to another user from my Electrum all was ok because I am using this for last few years but after few hours I realize something strange as my payment is going on wrong address but its still uncofirmed so is this reversable or can any one do this cancel.

If you are running Electrum 4.0.4 or newer and if the transaction is marked as replaceable then you should see "Cancel tx" under the context menu once you right-click on that transaction. Do you recognise the address to which the coins were sent? From where did you download your version of Electrum? The address should not have changed on its own.
legendary
Activity: 2758
Merit: 6830
December 23, 2020, 04:35:43 PM
#2
If your transaction has the RBF flag, you can right click it and select "Cancel transaction" to double-spend it back to your wallet with a higher fee.
full member
Activity: 896
Merit: 236
December 23, 2020, 04:32:09 PM
#1
Today I was sending a payment to another user from my Electrum all was ok because I am using this for last few years but after few hours I realize something strange as my payment is going on wrong address but its still uncofirmed so is this reversable or can any one do this cancel.
Jump to: