Topic: It seems to me, all POS coins are ultimately doomed to fail. Am I wrong? (Read 1053 times)

low PoS like EXCL that have PoW are more scure than pure POW

Yes you are wong.

You could always hold Maieuticoin and buy the Snowball

Sure When/if supply overwhelms demand.

and why spend them when they are better used to leverage BTC,. just convert into btc to buy what you want when you want and let em stake in the meantime. (Assuming BTC and the PoS stays somewhat stable over X time)

XCR encourages spending for commerce and the amount of coins you have in your wallet is not tied to how much you forge.

That being said I don't agree with the conclusion you make but I understand your sentiment.
Most coins aim to have incentive for larger holders to get more interest by buying more and hoard to increase it's market capitalization and keep spending to a minimum. Come to think of it in hindsight Bitcoin was very similar in that sense that there was nothing to buy with it in the earlier days so the only thing one could do was to hold it and hope for more people or buy a Pizza.


It makes for good investments at the time I suppose, many things in life have value because the general consensus is that it does.
I guess one could make the argument they aim to be more of a store of value than currency

Fair enough, but why would I not just hold my own bitcoin assets, instead of as you say, let the "bank of NXT" hold them?

That's correct you're wrong.

POS stake coins like Qora and NXT are more about decentralised trading and asset holding than anything else. Bitcoin will work wht in these systems. Think of them as banks that can hold various currencies and assets rather than coins.

Im gonna give u a good example, take a look at NXT, and then take a look at Nxt AE, then take a look at those assets, now do u still think u want to hoard the Nxt while investing in assets could be more profitable than hoarding?

In every POS coin the incentive is to hoard, not to spend.

I buy, I get dividends...
I buy more, I get more dividends...
I buy even more, I get even more dividends....

I keep doing this for what? months, years?

In the mean time there is no where of significance to spend my coins.
Plus the mantra tells me, don't spend, hold, get more dividends

Eventually this ponzi game has to stop, for we hold bunches of coins with no where to spend them.

If I am wrong, show me a POS coin that has many places for me to spend my coins,
and I don't mean a handful of tiny websites, but hundreds, thousands of places to really spend, like with bitcoin.

And do you really think that on one magic day, all us coinholders can convince merchants to accept a coin simply because we hold a bunch of them?
The merchants will rightly ask, "but who will I sell them to?"

[Edit] I was told later in this thread that when you want to spend coins, you just convert to BTC. But that is making a huge assumption. That is, while I am holding my assets in POS coins, their value (including dividends) relative to BTC remains the same or improves. If their price relative to BTC drops (for example, NXT certainly has this year) than I am screwed. My money would have been better left in BTC.

I am not trying to spread fud on any one coin, or calling any of them scams. It is just the concept that seems flawed to me. Particularly when as an investor, I am now faced with 20-30 of these coins, which are proclaimed as the "best way to hold my assets".