Limited action of Newbie and Jr.Member

whale_shark

member

Activity: 79

Merit: 10

Quote from: funsponge on June 27, 2018, 12:51:08 PM

Just prevent newbies/jr members from bumping the topics and that should solve most of the problems with the bots. I do not think limiting newbies and lower ranked members from posting a certain amount of posts per day is the way to go. Its basically a newbie jail which was far from perfect.

says the guess who bought a stolen account from somewhere. 'Funsponge' was my friends account and you stolen it and encrypted it to your email address around december 2017.
he is on the bitbay team and was part of ultracoins team. your a fraud pal

jackg

copper member

Activity: 2856

Merit: 3071

https://bit.ly/387FXHi lightning theory

Quote from: azvn on June 26, 2018, 10:32:28 PM

- Just from this topic: "Prevent spamming and pump topic from new account ?" https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/prevent-spamming-and-pump-topic-from-new-account-4546636 , I would like to share my thoughts to prevent spamming and pump topic in Alternate cryptocurrencies section. A lot of mega thread in Altcoin Discussion & Speculation (Altcoins) that is only for spamming of signature campaign. Almost spamming and pump topic come from Alternate cryptocurrencies section, so I just share my idea here:

Quote from: azvn on June 26, 2018, 03:45:13 AM

Agree, If you want to prevent newbie and Jr. Member from spamming and shit-posting, just make restricted on Alternate cryptocurrencies section because all spam and pump is from Alternate cryptocurrencies section. Ex:
- Newbie: Only view/ Can't comment, reply/ Can't create new topic.
- Jr. Member without Merit: View & Can comment or reply 1 time/day
- Jr Member with Merit: View & Comment 5 times/day
- Higher rank: No restrict

It will encourage New and Jr. Member to contribute quality post for getting Merit.

We can adjust it to suitable for all Newbie and Jr. Member

It's slightly better than what's suggested on the other board, that other one is just stupid and we'd end up with a newbie posting "great project" enough time to fill space.

Code:

great project
great project
great project
great project
great project
great project
great project
great project

Or they'd go one step further and just add loads of emojis to the end of their posts.

I'd say:
- Newbie/Jr. Member without merit: Only view/ Can't comment, reply/ Can't create new topic.
- Jr Member with Merit: View & Comment 5 times/day
- Higher rank: No restrict

(disclaimer, as a newbie here, bounties were deleted "apparently" so we didn't use to have this issue as you always got redirected to other forums).

Manhenro

newbie

Activity: 229

Merit: 0

I must agree with you that most of the bumps and shit posts are usually associated with newbies and Jr members accounts. However from the look of things at the moment, the restrictions placed on newbies and Jr members have not being very effective because we are still seeing a lot spam messages. The administrations and the moderators should come up with a better way of checkmating all those accounts used for bump and all the bots, that way we all enjoy quality posts from the forum.

NiceDev

member

Activity: 63

Merit: 10

Quote from: DaftAjax on July 03, 2018, 09:12:09 AM

Quote from: azvn on June 26, 2018, 10:32:28 PM

- Newbie: Only view/ Can't comment, reply/ Can't create new topic.

Are you serious? How can the Newbies progress if they can't reply or comment to any topics or threads? I think this is incorrect since Newbies suppose to do this, well all ranks do. In my analysis, you are literally just want to say that, this forum will not accept any new members.

Hmmm, now it got me thinking, if the current problem is because of having new members end up flooding the forum, by making such toxicity then will it be good to not let new members for a while, like 2 months or something?

I don't think it will help much if we just disable new account registration for say 2 months.

In fact, there are already many registered accounts with zero post history. People can still make use of these accounts to flood the forum if they want to.

And more importantly, this is a bitcoin talk forum aiming at promoting BTC. Disabling new account registration here won't help promote BTC.

For the flooding issue, I think it is more a moderation problem. We should think more about how to improve our moderation system, rather than just imposing restrictions on Newbies or Jr. Members.

DaftAjax

sr. member

Activity: 532

Merit: 284

Quote from: azvn on June 26, 2018, 10:32:28 PM

- Newbie: Only view/ Can't comment, reply/ Can't create new topic.

Are you serious? How can the Newbies progress if they can't reply or comment to any topics or threads? I think this is incorrect since Newbies suppose to do this, well all ranks do. In my analysis, you are literally just want to say that, this forum will not accept any new members.

Hmmm, now it got me thinking, if the current problem is because of having new members end up flooding the forum, by making such toxicity then will it be good to not let new members for a while, like 2 months or something?

trupero_uno

jr. member

Activity: 210

Merit: 1

There will be a pro-contrary to your idea, I think it should be lying on big interest of this forum. One of the interest is knowledge and idea sharing among the members, if this is restricted to some members then it will reduce the sharing content even perhaps most of low rank still lack of knowledge but idea is not. Perhaps some good idea will come from fresh knowledge even some of them are ridiculous. But the idea is a good asset of this forum, so the limitation as OP say is not suitable idea.

shilpyh

copper member

Activity: 210

Merit: 7

Better to stop creating new account and close all brand new, newbie, jr member account. Already there are different benefits for each type of membership? So, why you are thinking the alternate of admins post. If you think admin is not enough fair then it would better if you create a new post.

Note: Several social media stopped approving sponsor promotion for cryptocurrency. Now this forum is a great source of marketing. Almost maximum participant except signature campaign are newbie and jr. member. If newbie and jr. member restricted as on your view then they will loss a huge traffic and if so crypto market will go more lower.

suchi2591

newbie

Activity: 126

Merit: 0

Quote from: azvn on June 26, 2018, 10:32:28 PM

- Just from this topic: "Prevent spamming and pump topic from new account ?" https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/prevent-spamming-and-pump-topic-from-new-account-4546636 , I would like to share my thoughts to prevent spamming and pump topic in Alternate cryptocurrencies section. A lot of mega thread in Altcoin Discussion & Speculation (Altcoins) that is only for spamming of signature campaign. Almost spamming and pump topic come from Alternate cryptocurrencies section, so I just share my idea here:

Quote from: azvn on June 26, 2018, 03:45:13 AM

Agree, If you want to prevent newbie and Jr. Member from spamming and shit-posting, just make restricted on Alternate cryptocurrencies section because all spam and pump is from Alternate cryptocurrencies section. Ex:
- Newbie: Only view/ Can't comment, reply/ Can't create new topic.
- Jr. Member without Merit: View & Can comment or reply 1 time/day
- Jr Member with Merit: View & Comment 5 times/day
- Higher rank: No restrict

It will encourage New and Jr. Member to contribute quality post for getting Merit.

We can adjust it to suitable for all Newbie and Jr. Member

First of all you are already a member of Signature campaign.
You are making redundant post may be to complete your signature count.
What is the purpose of becoming a hero Cheesy

funsponge

hero member

Activity: 776

Merit: 557

Just prevent newbies/jr members from bumping the topics and that should solve most of the problems with the bots. I do not think limiting newbies and lower ranked members from posting a certain amount of posts per day is the way to go. Its basically a newbie jail which was far from perfect.

Jet Cash

legendary

Activity: 2814

Merit: 2472

https://JetCash.com

Put those restrictions on the 'proper' boards, and leave them to wallow in the alt cesspit they create.

LeGaulois

copper member

Activity: 2940

Merit: 4101

Top Crypto Casino

Since you posted it once already why open a thread to post it twice....

azvn

member

Activity: 294

Merit: 10

- Just from this topic: "Prevent spamming and pump topic from new account ?" https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/prevent-spamming-and-pump-topic-from-new-account-4546636 , I would like to share my thoughts to prevent spamming and pump topic in Alternate cryptocurrencies section. A lot of mega thread in Altcoin Discussion & Speculation (Altcoins) that is only for spamming of signature campaign. Almost spamming and pump topic come from Alternate cryptocurrencies section, so I just share my idea here:

Quote from: azvn on June 26, 2018, 03:45:13 AM

Agree, If you want to prevent newbie and Jr. Member from spamming and shit-posting, just make restricted on Alternate cryptocurrencies section because all spam and pump is from Alternate cryptocurrencies section. Ex:
- Newbie: Only view/ Can't comment, reply/ Can't create new topic.
- Jr. Member without Merit: View & Can comment or reply 1 time/day
- Jr Member with Merit: View & Comment 5 times/day
- Higher rank: No restrict

It will encourage New and Jr. Member to contribute quality post for getting Merit.

We can adjust it to suitable for all Newbie and Jr. Member

Topic: Limited action of Newbie and Jr.Member (Read 273 times)