It shows up in Receive with the public address but doesnt update my wallet total.
Also, the coins are still on my paper wallet when I go to check the balance.
I used the steps outlined in the links below.
https://litecointalk.org/index.php?topic=7072.0
http://www.coinqa.org/import-paper-wallet-to-litecoin-qt/
Edit: I get this when i enter the "importprivkey 1234sfY5...."
"Error adding key to wallet (code -4)"
Is your wallet encrypted? You need to unlock it first if it is:
walletpassphrase YourPasswordHere 60
Will unlock your wallet for 60 seconds which should be enough to run the importprivkey line straight after.