Newbies! Kindly Read This..! | Bitcointalksearch.org

Alone055

sr. member

Activity: 1260

Merit: 358

Quote from: Obiwankenodium on September 01, 2018, 03:42:24 PM

Maybe its because they want to get to 30 actuivity adap so they can get to jr member rank and be able to join the signature campaigns?

They can get activities by posting in latest topics as well. Why would they do it in those very much old threads?
And, signature campaigns should be limited to Member+ accounts. It has been said a lot of times before but isn't enforced yet. It would definitely reduce spam to a very large extent.

Saw one again today:

The last reply on that thread was about 8 months ago, in December 2017, and people, I don't know from where, have found it and started posting in it again just like it has been started yesterday. I don't really understand the mindset of such people who don't even bother to read the starting post before starting to reply, or maybe they read the starting post but just don't see the date it was posted on.

This is the thread I'm talking about here:
https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/hi-there-people-im-new-to-the-community-2610924

Obiwankenodium

copper member

Activity: 322

Merit: 15

Maybe its because they want to get to 30 actuivity adap so they can get to jr member rank and be able to join the signature campaigns?

Alone055

sr. member

Activity: 1260

Merit: 358

Quote from: Obiwankenodium on September 01, 2018, 10:03:10 AM

With all these signature campaigns it will be something we gave to work with as people feel the need to get their needed posts a week in as little effort as possible it seems.

This particular problem doesn't really have anything to do with signature campaigns because Newbies cannot join them anymore and I haven't noticed any of them wearing any paid signature when I saw them posting. It is just lack of care that draws them to do this I guess.

Quote from: LTU_btc on September 01, 2018, 10:38:21 AM

First of all, I'm not sure how Newbies find these old dead topics?

They basically surf more than one pages in a section in search of a topic where they can fit at least something that is somehow on-topic regardless of the date of that thread and the quality of their post.

Quote from: LTU_btc on September 01, 2018, 10:38:21 AM

But I think that they are just a part of problem. Ok, they bump old topic, but what we see further - then many high ranked users also replying to bumped topic without looking to date when it was created.

Exactly!
When a topic is bumped to the top, people start replying to the posts from the bottom without noticing the date when that discussion was started, and that process keeps killing the new topics in that section which move down in numbers when the dead start coming back to live.

LTU_btc

legendary

Activity: 3262

Merit: 1376

Slava Ukraini!

First of all, I'm not sure how Newbies find these old dead topics? But I think that they are just a part of problem. Ok, they bump old topic, but what we see further - then many high ranked users also replying to bumped topic without looking to date when it was created.

Quote from: bkrobottc1 on September 01, 2018, 05:16:24 AM

Thanks for the constructive post. But I think it difficult for newbie. Because they are "new" so they often don't read the rule clearly. But I hope they read this post at least one time.

Do they really need to know rules to know that it's not needed to post in old topics when question was already answered by many people.

Obiwankenodium

copper member

Activity: 322

Merit: 15

Better to post in new or active threads instead of digging up old topics indeed.
With all these signature campaigns it will be something we gave to work with as people feel the need to get their needed posts a week in as little effort as possible it seems. I struggle with this as well, but i always try to find active topics and try to add sonething to that topic when posting.

Alone055

sr. member

Activity: 1260

Merit: 358

Quote from: mansanas46 on September 01, 2018, 02:19:49 AM

Well, we need to post on such thread because we have something to share and we have the idea that need to be heard by all; thus, we post on such thread.

Why on earth would you need to share your thoughts on a topic that has been inactive for months now while there are other new and ongoing discussions that you can be a part of? It doesn't make any sense. And its not even like the posts that are made on those threads are somehow constructive, but they are utterly useless replies that even deserve to be deleted.

Quote from: mansanas46 on September 01, 2018, 02:19:49 AM

However, most of the people trying to open this post were not all newbies, let us consider that there are ranks who erroneously open a discussion just for the sake of their bounty campaign. So, definitely, this information is for all!

Quote from: Xiahouyuan on September 01, 2018, 03:37:36 AM

In fact, what you said is not just caused by Newbie. Many high-level accounts will do the same!

I understand that some higher level accounts might do the same thing, but that is very rare to find. All I have seen so far have been newbies posting in those dead threads making them alive again. And, considering the fact that a higher ranked member would understand such a basic thing, I just pointed out newbies doing this because they are the majority behind this new kind of spam wave.

sheng01

newbie

Activity: 6

Merit: 0

hoping for all the newbies like me to encounter this post, because we are eager to post on that day, we are "newbies"!

bkrobottc1

newbie

Activity: 183

Merit: 0

Thanks for the constructive post. But I think it difficult for newbie. Because they are "new" so they often don't read the rule clearly. But I hope they read this post at least one time.

Xiahouyuan

jr. member

Activity: 151

Merit: 2

Most people only care about how to complete the task. In fact, what you said is not just caused by Newbie. Many high-level accounts will do the same! I occasionally make the same mistakes!

mansanas46

newbie

Activity: 8

Merit: 0

Quote from: Alone055 on August 30, 2018, 01:35:52 PM

Hello!

Recently, I have seen a lot of newbies posting in threads that are very old and aren't active anymore. The first page of a section is supposed to have active and ongoing discussions while such actions don't let them be.

If you are a newbie, please take some time and read the OP (opening post) from the first page of any thread before you post anything to make sure it is not old. Because when you reply to an old thread, it pops up to the top again and people start posting in it once again which is something shouldn't be done.
You don't need to share your opinion about a topic that was started in early 2017 or even before that. There are hundreds of new topics which you can use to express your feelings. I'm not saying that you should post in almost every single one of them, but if you think you have something to say about a topic then you should first see the starting date of that and then go on. Posting replies without reading the starting date of a thread only makes the dead alive.

I hope people take this seriously.

Well, we need to post on such thread because we have something to share and we have the idea that need to be heard by all; thus, we post on such thread. However, most of the people trying to open this post were not all newbies, let us consider that there are ranks who erroneously open a discussion just for the sake of their bounty campaign. So, definitely, this information is for all!

Zhen Zhibing

jr. member

Activity: 121

Merit: 1

Thanks for letting us know this. We should avoid posting in dead topics.

r1s2g3

sr. member

Activity: 742

Merit: 395

I am alive but in hibernation.

Some of the threads are bumped willingly specially in which some BTC transaction has taken place to just show the people are stupid to give their BTC for the services. you see the wave might be account farmer decided that today is the day to bump all old post from his farming accounts.

Crypto_loca

newbie

Activity: 83

Merit: 0

What you've pointed out is actually true. I have noticed it in some other forum as well! It's irritating sometimes how people don't take time to read the entire post including the date it has been posted.

Steamtyme

legendary

Activity: 1568

Merit: 2037

Depending on the topic, sometimes it's easy to miss that a conversation has died. I recall starting out mining with near obsolete hardware and obviously not finding current conversations on the topic when I searched. I can't recall if I ever necro-bumped a thread but probably did in those days with the specific purpose of getting knowledge from those that where there before me.

Though most of these users are not using search, and are bringing life back to dead spammy threads. The ones I've been seeing appear to be spam bots; usually a rehash of the last page of posts merged into a steamy pile. That may explain the waves that seem to pop up. Especially because when say a bot bumps it, then every post count whore out there jumps in like it hasn't been 17 months since the last reply.

It would be nice if a topic was auto locked after say 9 months of inactivity. If someone searches and needs answers or there is something to ad, they can request it be unlocked or start a current thread.

bill gator

legendary

Activity: 1386

Merit: 1123

Why do these things tend to happen in waves? There will be periods that stretch months without me ever seeing a newbie necro-bump a post, then when it happens it seems to be as if it's "monkey see, monkey do."

I was in this thread earlier : https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/ostrich-and-crocodile-leather-wallets-belts-bags-phone-pouches-and-more-351319

Then, when I noticed the dates and the lame comments posted by the same user I was pretty confused on many levels. I don't know why the newbie would waste time posting on such an old thread, I don't know where they found the thread and I don't understand what they are trying to say with what they write.

Quote from: kendraallen on August 31, 2018, 07:28:19 AM

wow nice sharing!!

Quote from: kendraallen on August 31, 2018, 07:42:25 AM

recently i gifted a wallet to my friend i have purchased it for 30 dollars best wallets for men

It just defies all logic, but I suppose if you don't know any better then things like this are bound to happen. Please use your common sense, read the rules, guidelines and stickies around the forum and specifically within whatever section you plan to post within. It is not hard to know what is expected, what is frowned upon and what is going to lead to unproductive conversation. I can't help but feel like most of the problem is somebody refining a bot to spam around the forum more properly. Until it is calibrated, maybe it just posts the nonsense on more "suspect" threads, like we see here.

Alone055

sr. member

Activity: 1260

Merit: 358

Quote from: nakamura12 on August 30, 2018, 10:47:19 PM

If all newbies would do this then spam in this forum will be lessen.

And even if it doesn't lessen the spam, it would definitely not bring down the threads/topics created recently and might are important to be seen for some people. When old threads start getting spaces on the top, all the new threads start getting down on the list which is what should not be happening.

Quote from: Vaccaria on August 30, 2018, 11:06:29 PM

I'll be more careful in the future.

Good!
At least someone accepted this. I hope everyone else do too.

Quote from: audaciousbeing on August 31, 2018, 04:53:06 AM

<.....>

Exactly. You see that in every other section these days. They simply just open the last page of the thread and I even doubt if they even read a few replies and then they just post something regardless of the date when that discussion was started.
I just wanted to post this so that if even a few of them read this and don't do this again, I will think I, at least, did a very small thing for the betterment of the forum.

audaciousbeing

hero member

Activity: 1330

Merit: 569

Quote from: Alone055 on August 30, 2018, 01:35:52 PM

Hello!

Recently, I have seen a lot of newbies posting in threads that are very old and aren't active anymore. The first page of a section is supposed to have active and ongoing discussions while such actions don't let them be.

If you are a newbie, please take some time and read the OP (opening post) from the first page of any thread before you post anything to make sure it is not old. Because when you reply to an old thread, it pops up to the top again and people start posting in it once again which is something shouldn't be done.
You don't need to share your opinion about a topic that was started in early 2017 or even before that. There are hundreds of new topics which you can use to express your feelings. I'm not saying that you should post in almost every single one of them, but if you think you have something to say about a topic then you should first see the starting date of that and then go on. Posting replies without reading the starting date of a thread only makes the dead alive.

I hope people take this seriously.

You have pointed out something so germane and its what we see around here. Its not enough for a thread to have just too pages and you see that as an opportunity to post (since its not a mega thread) "I should not be accused of spamming the forum".

The annoying place you tend to see it on the Service section where a campaign that has ended, a newbie will post to ask for whether there is a room for him to be recruited.

The bold part is where the challenge is because lots of newbies won't get to see this thread either by error or omission and after a few days where several threads have been created, this gets push backwards never to be see again.

Vaccaria

jr. member

Activity: 39

Merit: 10

Newb trying to act cool

Thanks for pointing this out! I was probably one of these noobs. Being new to forum, I was not aware enough to notice the timestamp. On hindsight, that was stupid and careless of me... I'll be more careful in the future.

nakamura12

hero member

Activity: 2268

Merit: 669

Bitcoin Casino Est. 2013

It's very true, I did encounter this one where old post are brought back from dead and when I saw the date it's not what I expected it would be. If all newbies would do this then spam in this forum will be lessen.

Alone055

sr. member

Activity: 1260

Merit: 358

Hello!

Recently, I have seen a lot of newbies posting in threads that are very old and aren't active anymore. The first page of a section is supposed to have active and ongoing discussions while such actions don't let them be.

If you are a newbie, please take some time and read the OP (opening post) from the first page of any thread before you post anything to make sure it is not old. Because when you reply to an old thread, it pops up to the top again and people start posting in it once again which is something shouldn't be done.
You don't need to share your opinion about a topic that was started in early 2017 or even before that. There are hundreds of new topics which you can use to express your feelings. I'm not saying that you should post in almost every single one of them, but if you think you have something to say about a topic then you should first see the starting date of that and then go on. Posting replies without reading the starting date of a thread only makes the dead alive.

I hope people take this seriously.

Topic: Newbies! Kindly Read This..! (Read 344 times)