I think the reason it failed to gain any response at the time was, besides your lengthy paragraphs, it is too deep for most people here to bother formulating a response to. Nevertheless, you nailed some pretty important points about the NFT scene.
Yep, this is exactly what happened, and the maturation part is happening as we speak.
This is true... Maybe a couple of other shitcoins from the time are also still relevant, but that's it.
I also agree with this whole-heartedly. I tried to start a thread emphasizing the value of "Historical NFTs" as the rationale behind why they should possess more value than new NFTs makes a lot of sense.
Basically,
There will be an infinite amount of new NFTs manufactured in the future. We already saw a damn near infinite amount minted in the last couple years. So, the ones that are older and scarce - before NFTs really exploded in ~2020 - are going to be the most valuable as they were among the most unique at their time of creation.
Think of it as collecting baseball cards from the 1950s rather than the 1990s or onward.
Just wish I could get anybody on the forum to care about this but its hard to excite people beyond the prospect of writing up a viable post for their signature campaign.