P2WSH Bitcoin Core Witness Script Empty Error

Talkist

newbie

Activity: 3

Merit: 12

Thanks guys! Thanks to your direction I managed to sign it myself and now have my first transaction of the type indicated
that I signed myself. I am happy!

Without you I couldn't have done it!

achow101

staff

Activity: 3458

Merit: 6793

Just writing some code

Quote from: Talkist on December 06, 2023, 10:09:08 AM

Quote

Bitcoin Core doesn't know how to sign non-standard scripts. Script is not easy to analyze, so Bitcoin Core sticks to specific templates and patterns that it can analyze. Your script does not follow any of those patterns, so it is unable to produce any valid signatures. Furthermore, since it doesn't recognize the script, it will not place it in the witness. Thus the transaction you get after using signrawtransactionwithwallet is completely unsigned, and in fact, identical to what you passed in.

Thanks, noted. Does this mean every unlocking script in a P2WSH transaction is non-standard? If yes, does this mean P2WSH redeem scripts are not broadcasted by every client that only broadcasts standard transactions?

No, nodes do not inspect the contents of redeem or witness scripts for standardness checks.

Perhaps a better term would be "well known script template".

Talkist

newbie

Activity: 3

Merit: 12

Quote

Bitcoin Core doesn't know how to sign non-standard scripts. Script is not easy to analyze, so Bitcoin Core sticks to specific templates and patterns that it can analyze. Your script does not follow any of those patterns, so it is unable to produce any valid signatures. Furthermore, since it doesn't recognize the script, it will not place it in the witness. Thus the transaction you get after using signrawtransactionwithwallet is completely unsigned, and in fact, identical to what you passed in.

Thanks, noted. Does this mean every unlocking script in a P2WSH transaction is non-standard? If yes, does this mean P2WSH redeem scripts are not broadcasted by every client that only broadcasts standard transactions?

Quote

FWIW you don't need to push data smaller than 76 bytes using OP_PUSHDATA1 since it is wasteful. All you need to do is to use the size itself, which means using 0x02 and 0x14 instead of 0x4c02 and 0x4c14 respectively for the two data pushes which saves 2 bytes.

Thanks for the tip. Noted.

pooya87

legendary

Activity: 3472

Merit: 10611

Quote from: Talkist on December 05, 2023, 08:46:26 AM

Code:

OP_PUSHDATA1 EFEF OP_DROP OP_PUSHDATA1 f7983a6806d128c82842594183d119d2a5178f4c OP_CHECKSIG

FWIW you don't need to push data smaller than 76 bytes using OP_PUSHDATA1 since it is wasteful. All you need to do is to use the size itself, which means using 0x02 and 0x14 instead of 0x4c02 and 0x4c14 respectively for the two data pushes which saves 2 bytes.

achow101

staff

Activity: 3458

Merit: 6793

Just writing some code

Bitcoin Core doesn't know how to sign non-standard scripts. Script is not easy to analyze, so Bitcoin Core sticks to specific templates and patterns that it can analyze. Your script does not follow any of those patterns, so it is unable to produce any valid signatures. Furthermore, since it doesn't recognize the script, it will not place it in the witness. Thus the transaction you get after using signrawtransactionwithwallet is completely unsigned, and in fact, identical to what you passed in.

Talkist

newbie

Activity: 3

Merit: 12

I am trying to spend a P2WSH output. Here are the steps I have taken:

I have created a P2WSH output via bitcoin-cli. These are the details of the P2WSH output:

Code:

Type
V0_P2WSH
scriptPubKey (asm)
OP_0 OP_PUSHBYTES_32 a2b95877500eb4180401640c5649c55ce578584f865e4f1609f9971ca19d6f40
scriptPubKey (hex)
0020a2b95877500eb4180401640c5649c55ce578584f865e4f1609f9971ca19d6f40
Spending tx
Unspent

You can also view it here: https://blockstream.info/testnet/tx/3010534df31914f938014d34d0bd402ce1a741a46624b28abcfd2462126331a5?expand

In order to spend that output, I am first creating a transaction via bitcoin-cli as such:

Code:

bitcoin-cli createrawtransaction [{\"txid\":\"3010534df31914f938014d34d0bd402ce1a741a46624b28abcfd2462126331a5\",\"vout\":0}] [{\"tb1q77vr56qx6y5vs2zzt9qc85ge62j30r6vaccfxl\":0.0000007}]

This outputs the following serialization:

Code:

0200000001a53163126224fdbc8ab22466a441a7e12c40bdd0344d0138f91419f34d5310300000000000fdffffff014600000000000000160014f7983a6806d128c82842594183d119d2a5178f4c00000000

I now try to sign the message:

Code:

bitcoin-cli signrawtransactionwithwallet "0200000001a53163126224fdbc8ab22466a441a7e12c40bdd0344d0138f91419f34d5310300000000000fdffffff014600000000000000160014f7983a6806d128c82842594183d119d2a5178f4c00000000" [{\"txid\":\"3010534df31914f938014d34d0bd402ce1a741a46624b28abcfd2462126331a5\",\"vout\":0,\"scriptPubKey\":\"0020a2b95877500eb4180401640c5649c55ce578584f865e4f1609f9971ca19d6f40\",\"witnessScript\":\"4c02efef754c14f7983a6806d128c82842594183d119d2a5178f4cac\",\"amount\":0.0000007}]

This does not work however, as I always get the following error:

Code:

{
"hex": "0200000001a53163126224fdbc8ab22466a441a7e12c40bdd0344d0138f91419f34d5310300000000000fdffffff014600000000000000160014f7983a6806d128c82842594183d119d2a5178f4c00000000",
"complete": false,
"errors": [
{
"txid": "3010534df31914f938014d34d0bd402ce1a741a46624b28abcfd2462126331a5",
"vout": 0,
"witness": [
],
"scriptSig": "",
"sequence": 4294967293,
"error": "Witness program was passed an empty witness"
}
]
}

I do not understand why I receive a Witness program was passed an empty witness error, as I am explicitly passing a witness script in the command line. Is there a bug or what am I missing?

The witness script that was hashed is

Code:

OP_PUSHDATA1 EFEF OP_DROP OP_PUSHDATA1 f7983a6806d128c82842594183d119d2a5178f4c OP_CHECKSIG

which serializes to

Quote

4c02EFEF754c14f7983a6806d128c82842594183d119d2a5178f4cac

I have been told this transaction is non standart but I thought the (witness) redeem can be chosen freely?

Thanks for any help.

Topic: P2WSH Bitcoin Core Witness Script Empty Error (Read 122 times)