I am surprised that no one has pointed out the fundamental economic flaw with this concept.
If the USD is backed by nothing but faith, confidence, and (arguably) oil....and PayPal is backed by USD... Then what isn't this technically just shit backed by shit?
And if we measure Bitcoin's price in USD, then technically Bitcoin is backed by nothing, it has zero value. But at the moment, everything is measured in American dollars. When you go the doctor for surgery, they'll calculate your bills in dollars. Even if they accept bitcoin payment, still, they will calculate it in USD value and then convert into bitcoins according to current exchange rate.
Not really. Bitcoin's value is derived from its economic rules, the ecosystem's speculation, the blockchain ledger, and so much more. While Bitcoin's rules are fixed and do not change, USD and fiat money's rules change around what's needed for it to survive.
If USD = 0 then Bitcoin would be measured against another commodity primarily, like ETH (also a commodity) or Gold. Also, if US = 0, it doesn't mean everything else goes to 0... It means everything else = infinite USD. Just like what's happened in Venezuela with their currency.
The main reason PayPal is doing this is for database integrity via the blockchain ledger, making all payments traceable while reducing the liability and costs involved with the amount of data they process daily. There will probably be a massive scalability boost if the blockchain they use has a reasonable TPS....
Yes but a lot of people simply don't care about that, is it hard to understand? A lot of people don't care about the fact that their transactions will be recorded by PayPal, all they care about is easy access to crypto and stablecoins to gain profit.
For now they don't, as for now, it does not matter. When it effects them, it will matter to them. The way you are looking at it might seem correct to yourself for now, but there will come a day that this is no longer the case and your view will be clearly short sided in hindsight.
People also don't care about their social media data being sold to advertisers or insecurely/carelessly handled, I am sure they will care when their face is painted on a commercial thanks to AI, and it is allowed as they permitted it when they agreed to the terms of service on a platform like Facebook, which had a clause permitting such.
I am surprised that no one has pointed out the fundamental economic flaw with this concept.
If the USD is backed by nothing but faith, confidence, and (arguably) oil....and PayPal is backed by USD... Then what isn't this technically just shit backed by shit?
It's good for cryoto, if it enables people to move from PayPalUSD to cryptocurrency with no limitation. However, limitation is the biggest problem with PayPal. I doubt movement between crypto and PayPal's stablecoin will be seamless or limitless.
The main reason PayPal is doing this is for database integrity via the blockchain ledger, making all payments traceable while reducing the liability and costs involved with the amount of data they process daily. There will probably be a massive scalability boost if the blockchain they use has a reasonable TPS....
Though that's another question. If PayPal is going to make all balances backed by its stablecoin eventually, what chain will it be deployed on and can it keep up with PayPal's TPS?
[1] The USD is backed by the credit of the American government and America's military as what was shown when Saddam Hussien declared that Iraq will begin using the Euro for oil trades. They were invaded only 1 month after this declaration.
[2] Also, many people in the bitcoin community say that the dollar is
shit, however, in what currency do we price bitcoin? What are the proposals and how to price bitcoin away from
shit?[3] You also mention that Paypal's stablecoin will be good for the cryptospace if it can be moved in the cryptospace without limtation? According to your words, it is
shit. Why would you want more
shit in the cryptospace?
Credit is shit. Military is where all the money went, and why the gold standard was eventually abolished. The invasion of Saddam Hussein is only one of many war crimes that the US have committed with the power they have amassed via the fiat money scam.
What better opponent to give Bitcoin than the once unopposed, all powerful reserve currency of the world? As Bitcoin has grown, USD has lost its power. As BTC continues to grow, USD will continue to lose its power. That is what the price truly reflects.
When you convert or redeem PaypalUSD you are able to convert shit to Bitcoin. Just like you can convert USD to BTC. If it's possible, it's another funnel of demand for Bitcoin.
You said that stablecoins are shit backed by American dollars which is also shit. Bitcoin's price is based on dollars and also backed by dollars. The market cannot exist without dollars. Does this imply that bitcoin is also backed by shit also?
You also said that you wish to witness Paypal's stablecoin would make it easier for inflows into bitcoin. This clearly implies a possbility of a pump that might become a bubble if this occurs. However, what would happen if people want to dump their bitcoin because they want dollars?
I will not be a hypocrite and tell everyone that I do not want to witness a big pump on bitcoin, however, mixing idealism with our speculative investments and having a position that say
we are better, the other coins have no right to continue might not be a very good position to have.
However, I agree on the argument on stablecoins. I have always speculated that they might have fractionalized already. If the speculation is correct then stablecoins are fractionalized currencies backed by fractionalized currencies hehehehe.
I think you both are forgetting a very important fact.
The US Dollar is a scam, which is why Bitcoin was created and is superior to it.
Even though the USD scheme will be around for some time, it does not mean that its value will be. Bitcoin started at fractions of cents and is now worth 5 figures per coin. As more stablecoins, derivatives of USD, or in other words, more USD monetary supply is created, the higher BTC will be valued in USD. The more Bitcoin's price rises, the less USD is worth.
If you want a non BTC example, just look at purchasing power decline of USD and all other fiat currency to date. This won't reverse...and eventually it will be so bad that
shit will be a nice way to describe fiat money, when you take into account how angry the normies that Syncronice somewhat described in the second part of his post will be when shit hits the fan