Ok so I figured I would mess around in Photoshop and make a quick coin from scratch. I Picked the name at random and spent about 15 min doing the design and animation let me know what you think and rate it from 1/10 thanks.
I give you 8/10.
Topic: Rate My First Coin Design (Read 567 times)
Looks cool.
I give you 8/10.
Thanks for all the feed back guys all of it helps and I appreciate reading and learning what people like to see.
Interesting design.. A bit crowded the design and also looks like a button on a jacket rather than a coin.
I would rate it 7/10. The image looks more like a token than a coin. I suggest changing the colors a bit
More contrasting colours would be good. I'm not sure what the point of the rotation is, but I guess you're just practicing animating it. I think for a coin a more centered design might be a bit more appropriate. But that's a matter of taste. Either way, keep it up! 
Thanks for all the feed back guys I appreciate it it. I will take it all in to account when I am doing the next design.
Good luck
Thanks for all the feed back guys I appreciate it it. I will take it all in to account when I am doing the next design.
kinda cool, but as others have said, hard to read with it rotating. also colors make it hard to read.
looks like you have some good skills though
looks like you have some good skills though
How are people supposed to read it if it's constantly rotating? Why do you need the words to be repeated twice?
I don't really like the color at all, other than that it looks okay.
I find it too dark and very hard to read.
Try to change the reflexes of the coin according to its rotation, the final effect will be much more good looking.
It's making my eyes bleed 
I think you need to spend more time on it and make it more legible, check out coin designs that other people have done including physical ones and note the differences between them and yours.
I think you need to spend more time on it and make it more legible, check out coin designs that other people have done including physical ones and note the differences between them and yours.
Thanks for the feed back, All though it was a rush job I will take your tips and use them wisely by doing some research and submit another coin for rating on a later date.
It's making my eyes bleed
I think you need to spend more time on it and make it more legible, check out coin designs that other people have done including physical ones and note the differences between them and yours.
I think you need to spend more time on it and make it more legible, check out coin designs that other people have done including physical ones and note the differences between them and yours.
Ok so I figured I would mess around in Photoshop and make a quick coin from scratch. I Picked the name at random and spent about 15 min doing the design and animation let me know what you think and rate it from 1/10 thanks.
Jump to: