Reason why Boise State Women's Volleyball team forfeit their match

ralle14

legendary

Activity: 3346

Merit: 1914

Shuffle.com

Quote from: AVE5 on October 03, 2024, 01:47:58 PM

Why Boise team forfeiting the match in the first place? Because I don't think the the team was the first to encounter Blaire Fleming and her team in a match.
I'd had suggested that Bois State team would had also accepted as a challenge instead of giving up without trial. They may have been lucky to beat Blaire's unbeatable records though.
I'm even thinking if there could be a kind of sports game that women could boldly accept to challenge men as a game of fun.

The link mentioned SJSU would go 10-0 after this so they're not the first team. Still they're the first ones to take the initiative about the issue by forfeiting and now, the other teams are starting to do the same.

Mixed competitions could be a thing for volleyball, but the competitive scene might not be as huge unlike the women's and men's leagues.

I wouldn't blame Boise State's decision because in their view it could become a bigger problem and sometimes it's better to drop the match that you can't win than to risk a potential injury.

alani123

legendary

Activity: 2422

Merit: 1451

Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform

Shame on any TEAM sport association that forfeits a match over a transgender athlete...
The trans athlete in question are spending their second or third year in university now. Why shouldn't they be able to play sports in a team sport is beyond me. It was very unsportsmanlike from a college level team to act like this over a single team member in their opponent team.

If the sports association organizing your league has taken a decision, act in a civil manner to try and change it if you wish, but follow the rules of your league. Otherwise in a team sport, you ruin things for everyone. Imagine if Everton or Manchester United stopped playing matches because they thought non-white people have an advantage for instance. They would be holding their league hostage over some very subjective beliefs that have already been decided upon.

Adbitco

hero member

Activity: 1428

Merit: 653

Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform

Quote from: Yucky on October 03, 2024, 02:43:14 AM

My question is: is it right to have a transgender player in a biological team? Would you play in such circumstance?

Can you comfortable play such game? I think this is really bad to say because transgender are like trying to impose a person fitting into where he or she doesn't belong and it's very bad. Like your suggestion where they would also create and belong to where they should belong instead of mixed up player between the opposite genders.

seoincorporation

legendary

Activity: 3346

Merit: 3125

Quote from: Apocollapse on October 03, 2024, 03:31:18 AM

This is what you get when you allow LGBTQ+, you don't even know the definition of woman.

A man that choose to take estrogen and dress like a woman is called woman instead of man.

I think the reason why they don't want to create a specify team for transgender because it would conflict against "non-binary" where they claim it's separate from man and woman. Transgender isn't always non-binary.

But the fact that a man is playing in the woman team is totally rigged and that shouldn't be allowed from my point of view because isn't fair for the woman who are on the otre team to play against a man.

I thing there should be a ligue of transgender to avoid this in the future and offer a fair game for all.

Dunamisx

hero member

Activity: 952

Merit: 555

Quote from: Yucky on October 03, 2024, 02:43:14 AM

I've been left wondering about the state of the world after hearing about a team forfeiting their match due to a controversy surrounding a transgender player.

A game that demands professionalism has been tainted by personal sentiments, leading to a decision of forfeit.

“Boise State women volleyball team forfeited their match against San Jose State University, on September 28th because of transgender team player Blaire Fleming. The Broncos will now compete today, Oct. 3 against Air Force.”

https://www.outkick.com/sports/boise-state-womens-volleyball-opts-no-contest-rather-than-playing-against-sjsu-trans-volleyball-player

My question is: is it right to have a transgender player in a biological team? Would you play in such circumstance?

I think its something that each team has to be very careful on the kind of players they are employing, this is not about performance alone, but there is need for more investigation of each player, they need to conduct on serious and intended investigations on them before signing a contract on them, this will help them to know much about their background and they wouldn't be making any funny discovery of such after some time of being together, i think I've read on related stories like this before on a basketball male player in disguise to be a female player, at the end, it turned an embarrassment.

AVE5

full member

Activity: 350

Merit: 128

Why Boise team forfeiting the match in the first place? Because I don't think the the team was the first to encounter Blaire Fleming and her team in a match.
I'd had suggested that Bois State team would had also accepted as a challenge instead of giving up without trial. They may have been lucky to beat Blaire's unbeatable records though.
I'm even thinking if there could be a kind of sports game that women could boldly accept to challenge men as a game of fun.

Slow death

legendary

Activity: 3164

Merit: 1127

Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform

Unfortunately, it is becoming very difficult for society to position itself against this practice of same-sex involvement. I am not talking about using violence because I am against violence, I am talking about having lectures and psychologists giving advice on how this practice is not good. If everyone only involves themselves with people of the same sex, then the number of people on earth will reduce a lot and one day we will become extinct. In sports we can see how it is not possible to have a man dressed as a woman competing with a woman, the difference is very clear. But even so, there are governments that have supported men dressing as women.

Oluwa-btc

hero member

Activity: 980

Merit: 585

Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform

Quote from: Yucky on October 03, 2024, 02:43:14 AM

My question is: is it right to have a transgender player in a biological team? Would you play in such circumstance?

In my opinion, creating a separate team for transgender individuals would promote inclusivity while respecting the biological differences between men and women.

I see nothing wrong forfeiting the team match because of a transgender issues, on a norms it's not about segregation and inequality but then things must be done the way it should so this is why I concur to the fact that the physically fit be assigned to play within themselves while the transgender be assigned to play within themselves too that way the inequality equation have been balance , tho some persons may see this as a biased decisions but then having the transgender compete within themselves is best for the whole sports.

Dailyscript

full member

Activity: 350

Merit: 157

Fuck those transgenders who act to be women and deep down they most time respond like men when it comes to things like this. Acting like a female with male organs is wrong because the bones and responses were grown hard like that of a man.

For the game to be forfeited it is the right thing. And it should be raised as a concern in other sports to disallow anyone who is claiming to be a gender they are not.

I decide that no trans should partake in any sports that has to do with the two genders I know about. If they want to engage in sports then there should be an activity for transgender and not them interfering in male or female sports.

Text

hero member

Activity: 2464

Merit: 594

In my opinion, sports should be a space where fairness and competition are upheld, and inclusivity is essential. However, I do believe that the introduction of transgender athletes into teams categorized by biological sex does bring up important questions. There are undeniable physiological differences between men and women, which can affect performance in sports, especially at a high level of competition. Creating separate teams or leagues for transgender athletes could be a solution that promotes inclusivity while also maintaining the integrity of competition for all athletes involved.

lovesmayfamilis

legendary

Activity: 2072

Merit: 4265

✿♥‿♥✿

Quote from: Yucky on October 03, 2024, 02:43:14 AM

The world seems to be heading in a direction where sentiments override reason and fairness. I'm curious to hear your thoughts

I would say it a little differently. The world is moving towards madness. This is probably too harsh a word, but why change something that has been working for a long time because of those who woke up one day and decided that they are of the opposite gender? For me, such characters are scammers. Are there many cases of reverse gender reassignment, when a girl suddenly decides to play for a men's team, deciding that she is a man? Such actions are disadvantageous to the teams themselves, but it is clear to everyone that a man will be stronger than a woman. It is also not fair to organize competitions when the teams are not equal. It does not matter that this transgender felt like a woman, a cat, or someone else; it is necessary to test people for mental stability and only then allow them to compete.
Who will argue that transgender people have something wrong with their brains?

Cryptohygenic

jr. member

Activity: 87

Merit: 6

I don't support the transgender and the cisgenders in same sports events because they are surely gender inequality to physically counter each other in a particular gender competitive event.
The team forfeiting the match thereby was best option and if that is not taken to serious awareness, I bet it would encourage more transgender transition and since the world has corruptive, teams would intentionally require especially the male gender to be transmitted to the female genders just to hedge the club as advantage against female physiques.

Apocollapse

hero member

Activity: 1148

Merit: 796

This is what you get when you allow LGBTQ+, you don't even know the definition of woman.

A man that choose to take estrogen and dress like a woman is called woman instead of man.

I think the reason why they don't want to create a specify team for transgender because it would conflict against "non-binary" where they claim it's separate from man and woman. Transgender isn't always non-binary.

Yatsan

legendary

Activity: 2576

Merit: 1252

Leading Crypto Sports Betting & Casino Platform

Quote from: Yucky on October 03, 2024, 02:43:14 AM

I've been left wondering about the state of the world after hearing about a team forfeiting their match due to a controversy surrounding a transgender player.

A game that demands professionalism has been tainted by personal sentiments, leading to a decision of forfeit.

“Boise State women volleyball team forfeited their match against San Jose State University, on September 8th because of transgender team player Blaire Fleming. The Broncos will now compete today, Oct. 3 against Air Force.”

https://www.outkick.com/sports/boise-state-womens-volleyball-opts-no-contest-rather-than-playing-against-sjsu-trans-volleyball-player

My question is: is it right to have a transgender player in a biological team? Would you play in such circumstance?

In my opinion, creating a separate team for transgender individuals would promote inclusivity while respecting the biological differences between men and women.

Why include transgenders into women's teams, which can disturb the dynamics and fairness of the game?

If the goal is inclusivity, then I think having transgender teams compete against each other would foster equality and fairness in sports.

The world seems to be heading in a direction where sentiments override reason and fairness. I'm curious to hear your thoughts

The experience of the undefeated Boise State women's volleyball team is a serious problem facing sports today, with many thinking hard to try for fairness of competition. Especially in biodiversity.

Creating separate teams for transgender people can guarantee equality, besides the co-workers balance concerns. It helps to maintain fair competition while being respectful toward all the athletes involved.

As sports teams, they should have open discussion that considers the views of all concerned. It would be very hard to find ways on how to implement just and inclusive policies, but this is very essential in this regard because all athletes should be valued and respected.

Yucky

full member

Activity: 126

Merit: 94

I've been left wondering about the state of the world after hearing about a team forfeiting their match due to a controversy surrounding a transgender player.

A game that demands professionalism has been tainted by personal sentiments, leading to a decision of forfeit.

“Boise State women volleyball team forfeited their match against San Jose State University, on September 28th because of transgender team player Blaire Fleming. The Broncos will now compete today, Oct. 3 against Air Force.”

https://www.outkick.com/sports/boise-state-womens-volleyball-opts-no-contest-rather-than-playing-against-sjsu-trans-volleyball-player

My question is: is it right to have a transgender player in a biological team? Would you play in such circumstance?

In my opinion, creating a separate team for transgender individuals would promote inclusivity while respecting the biological differences between men and women.

Why include transgenders into women's teams, which can disturb the dynamics and fairness of the game?

If the goal is inclusivity, then I think having transgender teams compete against each other would foster equality and fairness in sports.

The world seems to be heading in a direction where sentiments override reason and fairness. I'm curious to hear your thoughts

Topic: Reason why Boise State Women's Volleyball team forfeit their match (Read 132 times)