Rebroadcast with higher fee? Nope, 258: txn-mempool-conflict.

DannyHamilton

legendary

Activity: 3472

Merit: 4801

Quote from: theartlav on May 12, 2017, 04:55:41 PM

- snip -
The question is what should i have set differently in a transaction for it to have been marked as RBF?

https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0125.mediawiki

theartlav

newbie

Activity: 13

Merit: 1

Quote from: achow101 on May 12, 2017, 04:51:57 PM

You cannot change it after the fact.

I understood that. The question is what should i have set differently in a transaction for it to have been marked as RBF?

DannyHamilton

legendary

Activity: 3472

Merit: 4801

Quote from: theartlav on May 12, 2017, 04:49:39 PM

- snip -
So, what should i change/set in a tx for it to be marked as RBF enabled?
- snip -

https://github.com/bitcoin/bips/blob/master/bip-0125.mediawiki

achow101

staff

Activity: 3458

Merit: 6793

Just writing some code

Quote from: theartlav on May 12, 2017, 04:49:39 PM

Quote from: DannyHamilton on May 12, 2017, 04:28:42 PM

If the first transaction was sent with RBF enabled, then you can replace it with a higher fee transaction.

So, what should i change/set in a tx for it to be marked as RBF enabled?
There is surprisingly little i can google about this.

You cannot change it after the fact. Since the transaction has already been broadcast, you cannot change it to be RBF enabled. That can only be done when creating the transaction, before it is signed and broadcast. Your transaction is not RBF enabled.

theartlav

newbie

Activity: 13

Merit: 1

Quote from: DannyHamilton on May 12, 2017, 04:28:42 PM

If the first transaction was sent with RBF enabled, then you can replace it with a higher fee transaction.

So, what should i change/set in a tx for it to be marked as RBF enabled?
There is surprisingly little i can google about this.

DannyHamilton

legendary

Activity: 3472

Merit: 4801

Quote from: theartlav on May 12, 2017, 03:01:51 PM

- snip -
I read many times that an identical transaction with higher fee should supersede an existing one with a lower fee.
- snip -

Then you've been reading some misleading sources.

Quote from: theartlav on May 12, 2017, 03:01:51 PM

- snip -
However, when i send it to the network it won't propagate.
- snip -

Correct. Most nodes that have heard about your first transaction will refuse to accept or relay the new one so long as the original transaction is still in their mempool. You have no control over when other nodes choose to remove a transaction from their mempool.

Quote from: theartlav on May 12, 2017, 03:01:51 PM

- snip -
So, the question is - is it possible to re-send a transaction with a higher fee, and if yes how to do it?
- snip -

If the first transaction was sent with RBF enabled, then you can replace it with a higher fee transaction. If it was not, then you'll need to wait for a few days for most nodes to forget your original transaction, then (as long as neither you nor anyone else has re-broadcast your original transaction) you'll be able to broadcast the new transaction.

theartlav

newbie

Activity: 13

Merit: 1

Greetings.

Lately i've been playing with Bitcoin at protocol level, trying to implement all the basics from scratch as a learning exercise.

Yesterday i made and signed a transaction to move some satoshis from one address completely to another, on mainnet.
At 44.643 sat/B fee it predictably didn't go anywhere, and after a day of poking ViaBTC's "accelerator" and getting "Submissions are beyond limit" i decided to try to send it again with a proper fee.
I read many times that an identical transaction with higher fee should supersede an existing one with a lower fee.

However, when i send it to the network it won't propagate.
After exhausting all possible bugs on my end i tried submitting it via https://coinb.in/#broadcast, and got a "258: txn-mempool-conflict" error.
Apparently it is being considered a double spend or some other sort of a collision.

So, the question is - is it possible to re-send a transaction with a higher fee, and if yes how to do it?

Here is the old transaction:

Code:

txid: 10c4272ff25ccbc4e98fe6576ce8c13bfda5d99857407c5d596eb3e21bc07f8b
raw: 01000000019dcb891734e73cf8ffa054a0dd0f01807444c1b142ef8c938fc346bb09e29bdb000000008b483045022100dfd8837b299eb521d1669fc33876bb0f984b94cd20905bc1683cd055f7fc9cd702202110c54022b9eb7c7441841b8bac51c0bb971f929bc56ac98f4b2599f0cedd8a014104d1c6161c384ebbf6267a1597b5a19ef7e401f6e795de70a6db5f4c9ab5c0d5d9c4dba46c4a1a962d3ea53509700a6ed02f6b21a83b0f937cd3f593663a2d2617ffffffff0119dd0000000000001976a91450594e8b1197f00aa58ce3efa57ed756647959f588ac00000000

And the new one:

Code:

txid: da8e467ed90efb2168c6cf6ec3e436465eff3faf25a2162ce34e279adee20d89
raw: 01000000019dcb891734e73cf8ffa054a0dd0f01807444c1b142ef8c938fc346bb09e29bdb000000008b483045022100c0744cd8c917c1c8fd283f28ae2b6b45f544ea02c45a375f750c5db4ba8f676a0220d4ce2924b48ccb11632481abbb10bef2a30355d07cfadd68cc8c2380cb8737d6014104d1c6161c384ebbf6267a1597b5a19ef7e401f6e795de70a6db5f4c9ab5c0d5d9c4dba46c4a1a962d3ea53509700a6ed02f6b21a83b0f937cd3f593663a2d2617ffffffff01597f0000000000001976a91450594e8b1197f00aa58ce3efa57ed756647959f588ac00000000

Topic: Rebroadcast with higher fee? Nope, 258: txn-mempool-conflict. (Read 904 times)