[Suggestion] Issue Refund | Bitcointalksearch.org

OmegaStarScream

staff

Activity: 3472

Merit: 6129

Quote from: Coding Enthusiast on October 03, 2016, 12:57:26 PM

it is suggested not to do Address reuse and many users are following this suggestion. this means your suggested feature is either encouraging address reuse! or is not going to work because the sender no longer wants to use that address or may not even have access to it because of using an Exchanger, an online wallet like Coinbase,...

Electrum is already showing addresses in a way that some believe is encouraging address reuse. so i don't think it would be a good idea to add to that.

also bitcoin is a no charge-back-currency so i find the idea of "refund" a bit redundant.

I wouldn't really consider this as an address reuse because It's simply sending funds back to an address you just used to send from, and not using it to receive multiple times.
If we are speaking about what is "not recommended" then It's also not suggested to use online wallets & exchange.
Chargebacks are and will remain something impossible to do with Bitcoin , those "refunds" will be made with the will of the receiver and not the sender.
As for NorrisK question , then I know It's possible to do this but having things automatic could make life of users much easier.

FrilledShark

hero member

Activity: 617

Merit: 500

I am the signed message, without I am not

I don't think it is necessary, as many things could go wrong in the refund process, like people not controlling their sending address (aka Coinbase or your example of an exchange). I have seen a lot of people who is using Coinbase as their go-to wallet.
On top of my head, I can't think of a situation where creating the refunds the traditional way is worse then having an automated solution.

There is also better places to improve then a return button. Like: Deleting transactions from wallet memory or an easier way to deal with 0 confirmations.

NorrisK

legendary

Activity: 1946

Merit: 1007

Isn't it already quite simple to return the funds if you want? You can simply copy the sending address from the transaction details and issue a refund.

Ok, it would take 2 more steps and manually typing in the amount, but I doubt a lot of people are in need for issuing refunds. What makes you want a function like this?

Coding Enthusiast

legendary

Activity: 1039

Merit: 2783

Bitcoin and C♯ Enthusiast

it is suggested not to do Address reuse and many users are following this suggestion. this means your suggested feature is either encouraging address reuse! or is not going to work because the sender no longer wants to use that address or may not even have access to it because of using an Exchanger, an online wallet like Coinbase,...

Electrum is already showing addresses in a way that some believe is encouraging address reuse. so i don't think it would be a good idea to add to that.

also bitcoin is a no charge-back-currency so i find the idea of "refund" a bit redundant.

OmegaStarScream

staff

Activity: 3472

Merit: 6129

I didn't see this feature in any wallet before but I think It could be very helpful (Let me know what you guys think).

Idea is pretty simple , you basically send the received funds back to the sender address. If a big amount was sent (which probably means multiple addresses will be shown) then choose one of the addresses.

So , when you first run Electrum you have the transactions in the first tab. You should be able to access this "Issue refund" just by right clicking the transaction you want . Typing the password should be necessary .

It could be a problem for what comes to exchanges where people don't really control their addresses so a warning should be available when on the "Type password" window. (Most people don't use exchanges to send funds to other people's wallets anyway)

Topic: [Suggestion] Issue Refund (Read 360 times)