Author

Topic: Suggestion: remove spam 180,000x: hide Website links for users with 0/1 posts (Read 254 times)

legendary
Activity: 2156
Merit: 2100
Marketing Campaign Manager |Telegram ID- @LT_Mouse
Still not sure between Jr Member or Member but sounds like a decent proposal
I think anything other than from the beginning. I mean newbie can add website on their profile. So, allowing Jr member only would decrease the rate significantly as this spammer would never visit the site again after their account creation and adding the website link.
copper member
Activity: 783
Merit: 710
Defend Bitcoin and its PoW: bitcoincleanup.com
How about member or Jr. Member + Copper?

Member or anything (Jr Member, Newbie, Brand New) + Copper seems more fair. Newbies buy Copper to be able to display images for their business, project, ICO etc. So letting them add a website would be a logical thing to do.
legendary
Activity: 3500
Merit: 6320
Crypto Swap Exchange
A simpler proposal would be to remove the website link until you become a Member.
I tried not to raise the bar too high, but I'd be totally fine with this too Smiley

Still not sure between Jr Member or Member but sounds like a decent proposal

How about member or Jr. Member + Copper?
Copper is cheap enough that it's not a big deal for someone who is going to be even a casual member of the forum can pay for it.
There really is no reason for anyone to need to post website links, it's a convenient thing but not needed.
So either be useful & post and get merit or pay a bit.

-Dave
copper member
Activity: 783
Merit: 710
Defend Bitcoin and its PoW: bitcoincleanup.com
A simpler proposal would be to remove the website link until you become a Member.
I tried not to raise the bar too high, but I'd be totally fine with this too Smiley

Still not sure between Jr Member or Member but sounds like a decent proposal
copper member
Activity: 1652
Merit: 1901
Amazon Prime Member #7
If there is a requirement for a profile to have at least two posts in order to have their website displayed, there will be an incentive for people to create spam-bots that write exactly two posts and fill in a website they want to be advertised.
I considered that too, but there are spambots already. And all it would take it reporting one of their posts to remove the link again. Now Website links stay, I think even after the account gets Nuked.
Most spambots are advertising their website in their post. They are easy to identify. If someone had to make two posts in order to be able to display a website in their profile, the spammer could simply make two semi-useful posts in random threads to have this ability unlocked.

Also, as I mentioned previously, a user with no posts having a website in their profile is not doing anything for that website. I don't believe that google is indexing profile pages of users with no posts.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
I believe that those that are proxybanned cannot list anything in their profile.
I haven't tested this (and I don't want to go through Tor-captchas to try).

Why do we have to wait until a user has been nuked/banned and their content removed?  Why no dial it up in much the same way you can't post in your signature until you've advance through the ranks
I guess that's because the Website-link is "grandfathered" in the forum. Without spammers, it wasn't a problem at all.

A simpler proposal would be to remove the website link until you become a Member.
I tried not to raise the bar too high, but I'd be totally fine with this too Smiley
legendary
Activity: 2800
Merit: 2736
Farewell LEO: o_e_l_e_o
Good catch and value to discuss.

I suggest to hide the Website link in the profile of users with 1 or less posts.
We will see they will create account and make a random post then they are good.


Timelord2067 and NotATether have better suggestions I think. Specifically I will think closer to NotATether. But since he was advising to buy copper membership so I would emphasis on at least earning member rank before able to have a website link on the profile.
legendary
Activity: 1568
Merit: 6660
bitcoincleanup.com / bitmixlist.org
A simpler proposal would be to remove the website link until you become a Member. That way, people can just buy access to it with the Copper membership if they want to advertise their service. It also means custom PHP doesn't need to be added to the forum just to support the edge case of 0/1 post users.
legendary
Activity: 3696
Merit: 2219
💲🏎️💨🚓
Why do we have to wait until a user has been nuked/banned and their content removed?  Why no dial it up in much the same way you can't post in your signature until you've advance through the ranks - the higher the rank, the more bells and whistles (and colour and amount of characters etc you can include).
copper member
Activity: 1652
Merit: 1901
Amazon Prime Member #7
I believe that those that are proxybanned cannot list anything in their profile.

If there is a requirement for a profile to have at least two posts in order to have their website displayed, there will be an incentive for people to create spam-bots that write exactly two posts and fill in a website they want to be advertised.

I looked at a random person in your list, and I don't think his referral link is doing him any good by being displayed in his profile. I searched both his username and his referral link in google, and neither search came back with his bitcointalk profile.

I don't think google will index user profiles solely by virtue of someone having a forum account. If someone has written zero posts that google will ever see, there is no way for google to know to visit the profile. The member list is disabled, and google will visit webpages via following links are pages it visits, while being subjected to the limitations the administrator sets to google.
legendary
Activity: 3290
Merit: 16489
Thick-Skinned Gang Leader and Golden Feather 2021
I found spam again that advertises a Website in the user's profile. Out of 3460606 users, I've downloaded 1000 random profiles to check how often this happens:
Code:
1039992
2422300
1666856
3061865
658409
381375
802656
248733
3213211
2719500
225008
1762845
2250583
753199
1536038
205840
1282236
422785
3243646
2134169
3120460
2883000
3100270
1203644
1205398
2908950
992326
1566819
1788303
2100856
2251367
2329634
2562521
1891330
2487039
1793705
1324746
805555
2627435
1540013
153700
874245
2237356
990794
410776
2813480
924786
2440207
232539
602372
1320291
1440446
1666874
636887
1950493
410436
1174982
2768347
1748879
3432809
896669
3057595
3066764
2139259
1399102
2023447
2916818
671676
3021038
2056382
1134557
1788820
1097227
289115
3262381
1152261
2974027
1189361
499640
3415263
101509
3307332
1406769
2722892
867094
2800053
881425
406811
1049982
74740
2650262
932152
2010973
2201991
1381034
1678582
1370796
3105841
3357280
3029379
605240
1697860
1616165
521425
655098
1052162
18351
2626867
1521485
2958209
976146
16823
593627
995456
119577
395520
1583034
1535982
1724310
2420927
793012
2485652
1478173
2148108
1882052
602837
664350
2870687
3210373
1602495
579825
2137561
792557
1286632
802452
991399
1555999
990649
3410585
2268655
1928492
3450444
877519
55348
1596809
2708305
2387532
2969706
2457131
606517
277652
2428189
2741504
1465086
2413998
432174
2376497
2701223
1132370
2640294
435796
1930918
297956
2169502
460957
2605083
304704
946443
3107030
3198288
3244236
1376037
2315868
2139648
2806074
240029
2121380
1430843
1704125
1217814
3151034
800703
1445407
1431305
230405
789894
26519
377789
1103845
1001775
968136
2656319
3354487
1542193
323351
1496192
1618861
1925953
1474723
2175248
1005355
2309616
2001868
858
1880329
1527228
3351270
2888629
1695329
1197546
1019917
339205
2651396
1490727
1399225
102487
156871
2684410
1168306
1013510
2901221
2892963
3334614
546081
550000
2551077
378910
2505507
1387386
3315667
2338195
1759920
1870370
1277993
2194057
1583108
2647939
3333831
1090341
2589969
101204
1786702
1569253
351080
275780
2580025
3060743
624884
2245013
783796
378237
1415969
2319535
963372
3111122
1836145
824074
2265019
2036770
723516
803732
170322
2275216
995499
139548
551436
1095877
1725617
20356
1021509
3210399
28923
587445
1600811
2761652
287484
2439546
1527072
3440567
1997946
1276814
830583
2552232
427161
1985886
500476
3400453
2494346
2814654
1733120
2896040
1507146
1858593
3175091
1671797
1051893
3218733
2789462
3379068
863330
1658428
153576
2953930
629082
166765
1821764
1424144
3105416
3322168
1024206
3278061
2402348
2802798
2248008
1259367
2390631
2975349
2785883
662347
1732755
2156934
3138286
461299
2194886
1284810
1774919
1220832
1772918
149747
2867528
2727506
1147945
2165796
327689
3010933
3254358
2568833
773444
1403347
1478527
651931
2174722
1833665
2490977
1306799
11162
3452653
1697934
785153
2517242
2173899
597287
88723
3279812
459882
2952501
816135
790221
1851479
858844
2719634
3310072
2276167
2341908
2254054
1765601
428375
2446509
2655374
2196785
772595
2857789
630347
2230370
834376
3246162
1682755
2202995
1854270
1812606
3293901
2694198
1313922
3239481
3290958
1094318
2512126
2663229
1980566
2765066
2548865
1383783
978158
1193693
3164138
3324226
1278303
878859
2036616
934214
1984465
3211181
1786287
1377872
3100836
1595518
1203245
460332
1825883
2588956
2818559
2674674
2913567
1519199
3330377
313037
1282685
2053277
2364178
140249
1950406
2414894
1473985
1183327
2416935
2827506
1842907
225909
2394487
1444569
2814690
1409028
1741932
2794012
968049
1273331
1510680
1422247
127488
3200556
2505951
365587
2247703
1218634
1302687
1792004
527067
430778
3315810
1002934
917823
1034292
919547
743212
418328
711084
1050919
3108743
966488
789918
959525
3264923
1500176
3182512
2051328
3148651
845572
2814157
1332959
3341613
1124709
2351549
450853
1226304
1919512
1146692
2618204
3103938
1716838
3253968
2831851
3084634
3052121
1366649
3089489
565261
244190
1229296
2531550
2268027
1996775
778241
2272411
588883
2338690
521200
935033
1924876
2369774
1708549
1337134
1744207
2811122
539930
1151202
2505804
2818318
793517
2358760
3291570
2432381
2956067
1861022
3389152
605954
925754
906963
2602635
1161112
17190
723777
1197600
1106698
2373820
919109
3233316
1805669
525313
2333513
1821823
73195
2132985
2604716
2588952
1314234
2643523
2749345
2214194
1502384
1231385
2658248
548353
2318096
43887
75352
768667
3098760
2492952
2609830
485108
1011153
2801124
1012334
3052452
615091
547293
751003
3088251
169766
861505
3233965
601283
173330
877082
2770632
130936
3412429
2934944
202915
1778942
2466472
889147
398881
2530750
1505228
2787131
2103922
1320770
830137
546958
906798
2434396
1782533
3188387
2989380
114979
793771
2954413
2081257
128666
3387921
1968532
3229719
381428
1056774
3329451
1621886
1044341
777293
3233150
1211752
2471254
827030
1376328
2139485
2123808
2340147
2338462
1236252
1026460
1685630
116750
1691439
1263638
1523014
810724
2704433
1031308
649257
1239605
1983985
536754
3416756
818799
1209957
465415
1912208
498526
2124781
1090547
2656467
541358
1647273
1069154
100985
546488
3360013
1565377
1643311
2171795
1906561
1560861
132294
777207
2034520
3331901
1874789
370315
3443572
1164703
2171693
2681917
2537794
2016506
1726812
2550750
2751604
2088046
2119695
318283
3144835
2881607
18298
2192964
2505574
1201673
1111297
3381805
3146539
1019660
2230184
2417309
862908
371666
649534
3432804
1530668
1415618
196608
3244
997538
3172428
2007284
946270
3403052
1353831
928668
313747
2065406
3328636
2405951
2619877
2002752
2298350
1778412
2171774
2749874
1101942
2968834
3401311
3310558
2718600
39751
2369034
1695600
1319968
1408703
1090148
2669979
1873993
1466984
2053748
536108
2446834
1450427
454874
505281
3132854
699323
2575795
3186375
998318
252136
817976
2346264
999297
2040962
2266619
2877606
799528
430897
604663
1475259
1861236
357391
2974964
2005760
1992508
643919
1842388
558367
1070940
1181274
2487802
816999
1647172
2308184
2860998
940267
2866381
551232
1261832
743329
3130556
49809
1588899
1286983
374633
495508
3354847
1608695
930589
1690052
283588
327420
160813
2957775
917749
1438927
55673
3232935
3340885
1078293
878776
993705
2790779
1216287
2460149
1166030
868068
826631
582401
1781537
2021162
1215297
2292339
1388669
2677342
393439
1617030
1340542
1639437
1866132
3199341
959663
1724354
50549
1845062
2364666
331889
217935
3243884
1375507
3205308
3097159
1898388
747891
1283551
3431464
1315305
1832488
1337037
2211086
3393169
331325
913924
1492471
1775975
1973176
2408408
1802373
108068
3362586
3400510
2531587
2805877
1061876
546318
216891
2516529
610019
2567550
1295810
108979
2551276
961481
1897755
16842
103088
2586466
309480
1537553
2399466
349068
2282879
639965
1922435
2680091
2204740
213706
2920696
2679034
3164250
1726400
1213374
1184414
2773752
2017478
3240485
1788487
534149
1103765
3405586
766435
395935
1394774
1136134
1384624
1133732
1845222
1069590
2774124
391530
893217
2498464
2282415
1001284
469501
523430
2249025
2475439
542097
99569
2630449
3182233
3069934
2588104
1765797
1312800
1462793
887446
1032588
2682320
3286992
1248216
1400590
2970682
2543383
3278385
2786050
2036867
2790635
1478467
1578614
845735
3194124
2397145
2313021
344394
1074820
276916
995505
543083
1612877
2238626
3220129
1808853
3212625
594428
2512695
3138619
874822
687323
2475976
2776598
1220488
187908
3337732
1518538
1070228
1428893
1672287
3078614
1052790
256391
1576177
2433703
1430907
352775
2049957
4596
2528783
3278407
620417
1529066
2280752
1717577
41574
2826070
2422236
380519
1629214
817329
1614128
722134
3280947
1577927
422469
2095579
306886
2987383
2898482
1725472
2752449
2585702
1786703
359650
1963715
161352
873271
2099532
905493
2651836
3013376
2362739
1788833
1138992
526124
2421082
2625416
3247547
2743072
226633
1641941
65441
2838247
251343
77619
1786717
2269507
1685289
228986
3095120
48973
1393342
2276950
2201854
2999866
2091709
3362396

64 of those profiles contain a Website link:
Code:
0 posts - userID: 1019660 - username: [email protected] - URL: https://www.coinbase.com/join/591ef8a6bb71781aa7da82d5
0 posts - userID: 1166030 - username: atexfun07 - URL: http://spasandhottubs2.simplesite.com/
0 posts - userID: 1583108 - username: ragilsurya12 - URL: https://twitter.com/Ragilsurya2
0 posts - userID: 2010973 - username: Lias - URL: https://bountyhive.io/r/Lias
0 posts - userID: 2338462 - username: ananyashetye - URL: https://www.dhflinsurance.com/
0 posts - userID: 2531550 - username: incap22 - URL: https://bestgoodcaptions.com/sassy-instagram-captions/
0 posts - userID: 2627435 - username: architex6 - URL: https://i13.co.in/services/kitchen-design
0 posts - userID: 2680091 - username: ydevyv - URL: http://flexa-plus-optima.eu/gr/
0 posts - userID: 2701223 - username: mentemillonaria - URL: https://mentemillonaria.com.mx/
0 posts - userID: 2741504 - username: inheritance1Ukraine - URL: https://nasledniki.com.ua
0 posts - userID: 2768347 - username: larry7036 - URL: http://kvinnoshop.eu/
0 posts - userID: 2790779 - username: Salty_Endeavors - URL: https://cozumelscuba.com
0 posts - userID: 3198288 - username: iris_brown_62 - URL: https://hampton-hill-pest-control.co.uk
0 posts - userID: 3330377 - username: WEN LAMBO - URL: http://www.wen-lambo.com
0 posts - userID: 3331901 - username: Executeriodejanerio - URL: https://www.execsecure.com/locations/rio-de-janeiro-secure-transportation-services/
0 posts - userID: 378237 - username: Rodez72 - URL: http://www.probioticsforweightloss.net/
0 posts - userID: 418328 - username: HollieWYDB - URL: http://fb.bia2fars.ir/index.php?a=profile&u=dawnzmdqhmp
0 posts - userID: 422469 - username: RosauraLem - URL: http://fly.ryousoft.com/913737
0 posts - userID: 422785 - username: MichellMas - URL: http://Tupalo.com/en/irvine-california/gold-ira-rollover-pros
0 posts - userID: 427161 - username: IndiraShaf - URL: http://kayleeyacdbcif.pen.io/
0 posts - userID: 430778 - username: JaniWithne - URL: http://bluepacificmobilehomes.com/gta5/car-cheats-for-gta-on-xbox-360/
0 posts - userID: 430897 - username: AutumnQQML - URL: https://Helpdesk.Salvationarmy.ch/entries/88103848-How-Does-Acid-Reflux-Diet-Work-
0 posts - userID: 432174 - username: HildreWinf - URL: http://akuhanyagadiskampung.blogspot.fr/2013/12/segmen-kenapa-aku-jadi-blogger-by.html
0 posts - userID: 435796 - username: Ben66Ylniz - URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A4NiEiCwUA0
0 posts - userID: 450853 - username: JodyNerlik - URL: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vUBMPKVko1E
0 posts - userID: 454874 - username: LeoAiello - URL: https://www.facebook.com/kimkardashianhollywoodcheatshackupdated
0 posts - userID: 460957 - username: DarinHoule - URL: http://filedb.goodsoft411.com/resites.php?url=http://www.grossirdesfesses.com/
0 posts - userID: 461299 - username: JillDaniel - URL: http://functionalbigot74.sosblogs.com/The-first-blog-b1/3D-Textured-Diamond-Claws-b1-p7.htm
0 posts - userID: 465415 - username: LuigiCalli - URL: http://Www.Dressesclub.biz/
0 posts - userID: 469501 - username: MauriceG70 - URL: http://minecraftpremiumacc4free.blogspot.com/
0 posts - userID: 49809 - username: gillingham - URL: http://www.hefitshefit-personaltraining.com
0 posts - userID: 551232 - username: RaynaHenrry - URL: https://cityraven.com
0 posts - userID: 55348 - username: ame l30 - URL: http://games151144.info
0 posts - userID: 565261 - username: jamybtcbank - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 624884 - username: aruva - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 630347 - username: zhongxia - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 636887 - username: mewah - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/?i=autobit
0 posts - userID: 65441 - username: rosaclinic - URL: http://www.bellarosaclinic.com/
0 posts - userID: 664350 - username: corablack9 - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 766435 - username: Kitsana2535 - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/?i=lalitaray7071
0 posts - userID: 768667 - username: Mouwin - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/?i=mouwin07
0 posts - userID: 773444 - username: yohanes kurniawan - URL: http://http:mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 777207 - username: anitabudmmmg - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/?i=lex
0 posts - userID: 777293 - username: mee lay - URL: http://http//mmmglobal.org/?|=lex
0 posts - userID: 783796 - username: Lanni - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 785153 - username: alice494949 - URL: http://mmmmgloball.org/?I=alice494949
0 posts - userID: 793012 - username: Ashn - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 793771 - username: amritpal - URL: http://mmmglobal.org/[email protected]
0 posts - userID: 830137 - username: starvps7854 - URL: http://starvps.ru/
0 posts - userID: 845572 - username: robustreproduct - URL: https://disqus.com/by/ProfitSEOBrisbane/
0 posts - userID: 995499 - username: lillianacroxen - URL: https://www.onlinetrafficeducation.com/Michigan-Driver-Improvement-Course-Online.php
1 posts - userID: 2091709 - username: hsrppankaj - URL: https://www.fifaworldcup2018schedule.org/
1 posts - userID: 3310558 - username: Generate Free Btc - URL: http://www.generatefreebtc.com/
3 posts - userID: 2036616 - username: GAIA-Projects - URL: http://gaia-projects.org/
3 posts - userID: 378910 - username: salojc2006 - URL: http://www.wideexchange.com
4 posts - userID: 968136 - username: alexisasia6 - URL: http://bountyhive.io/r/alexisasia
7 posts - userID: 2272411 - username: Ohab09 - URL: https://smmaim.com/
24 posts - userID: 1211752 - username: Veenom - URL: https://bountyplatform.io?code=29628
28 posts - userID: 406811 - username: BigTiger - URL: https://www.btcdlc.com/shop/reisen-hotels
74 posts - userID: 1324746 - username: NlaakStudios - URL: https://www.nlaak.com
85 posts - userID: 11162 - username: btcLottery - URL: http://www.btclottery.com
139 posts - userID: 1873993 - username: BitcoinRM - URL: https://www.bitcoinrm.org/
254 posts - userID: 2298350 - username: HealthNet - URL: https://up.hc-net.online/
318 posts - userID: 1842388 - username: prettymargaux - URL: https://bountyplatform.io?code=13807

Suggestion:
To take away one of the incentives to create spam accounts, I suggest to hide the Website link in the profile of users with 1 or less posts.
This would hide 53 of the 64 websites above, and none of them will be missed. If I extrapolate to 3460606 posts, this will remove approximately 180,000 spam backlinks from Bitcointalk.
Jump to: