My question is, why do exchanges have to be centralized? If money doesn't have to be, can't exchanges be networked too?
Also, there has to be some way where exchanges can accept more common forms of fiat funding while limiting fraud so they can eat the cost and better serve the customers. Mind you, I think if they would accept paypal (decentralizing things removes Paypal's ability to track the fact that the payments are for Bitcoin) and properly vet the account holders that the massive increase to Bitcoin trading would not only boost Bitcoin significantly overall, but also more than compensate for the level of fraud that would come with it.
After all: I'm someone who, by very principle, believe that human beings are literally, radically evil things. Yet even I have to recognize that most people aren't going to pull chargebacks. Most people are honest clients, and there are ways to weed out most of the ones that are trying to jack yo' crap up.
They don't have to be, The exchanges could be run by a algorithm running on an extra layer of Bitcoin, the bitcoin network is the most secure network ever built, only the data getting encrypted is vulnerable, so if The bitcoin client got turned into an exchange system with all other currencies, all users can participate at any given moment.
but the hard part would be tying the system into the real world, the centralized exchanges are our front end to interact with the national currencies, they are taking care of the legal aspect for us.
of course it would be interesting to create another Semantic Web machine that coupled with Bitcoin, the Banking component of bitcoin is currently being developed... and that is the exchanges.
now what ideology do we follow for the trade algorithms? after all we would have to convert our thoughts and ideas on it into pure math that can be programmed. anyone got any ideas?
Bitcoin was built to be absolutely secure... and in so doing seems to be following the Austrian School of economics ideology, that I am sure was not intentional, a consequence of making it ultra secure, do we follow the same ideology for the p2p exchange?