Topic: To comment/post removers (Read 282 times)

A thread that isn't self-moderated can't get deleted after another user has posted in it. If the thread hasn't had any other posts, it can be deleted depending on the location of it. In a self-moderated thread, the OP is the mod, and they can delete each and every post they see fit. If you don't trust or like the person that is moderating the thread, don't post there if you think your posts will get deleted.

I remember your username from some older posts. There is nothing in your history that can be considered valuable or worth reading.   

We already have third-party services for that. Ninjastic.space and loyce.club were already mentioned to you.

Your posts don't save lives and have no historic value, sorry.

There is no need to compare your spam and the spam of others with valuable pieces of art and literature that were unnecessarily destroyed. One is a shameful act while the other is a welcome one.

No one cares about your beliefs. Keep your beliefs to yourself or share them only in the sections where that is appropriate, like the Off-topic board, Politics & Society, etc. Most parts of this forum exist so we can discuss various topics related to bitcoin and crypto, not who created the universe. Stay on topic, leave God out of the picture, respect the rules, and you won't have your posts deleted. Or don't and see how it goes.

Preservation of posts you say @OP, I think the first respondent did just to that. It's not entirely wrong to be concerned with what and how your literal piece is been handled but let's not forget, deleted threads are done by moderators and this can account for some set of just reasons, the topic has been discussed exhaustively on other threads and there was no use for another thread making it a spammees heaven, the thread probably comes without an sense or proper narration, it's used for some off forum promotions and generation of traffics, etc. These and other reasons goes for threads, while comments follows a different part of which are mostly spam and off topic replies. They always find there way off the forum.

Replies definitely gets deleted and where it becomes questionable is in self moderation as, I practically don't need no reason to delete a comment. All it could take is, I don't want you posting in my thread and at that point, it doesnt matter how vital your comment might be or the amount of work you put in to its composure.

Threads on the other hand are moderators job and a few might just be moved to there supposed board, others find themselves in off topic while, the others might just find there way out. It's fair.

Uh no, there are many good reasons to remove other peoples comments / posts.
Trolls, spammers, people who post wrong / dangerous information.
Add in, sometimes the post is about subject A and then it drifts to subject B.
But subject B is discussed elsewhere.
Discussing B is limiting the discussion of A

And so on. Some posts I do as self mod, others I don't. Depends on if you want a free for all discussion or to keep it on topic. OR, and this is valid too, on YOUR VIEW OF THE TOPIC. If others want to have a conversation about their view, they can start their own thread.

-Dave

Also, I think a lot of users might be underestimating how much space over time that useless data actually uses. Normally, system admins tend to prune even old databases, because of the storage it uses up. I think you've come across certain issues with archiving certain data from the forum.

While an individual post doesn't take up all that much, chuck a few hundred thousand on it, and you're soon looking at issues. Anyone that's worked with data will know the limitations of software when opening up traditional text files that are over a certain size, and likely having to resort to using Vim etc.

I guess I get to see the amount of work that goes on behind the scenes, but it only takes monitoring the modlog, and that isn't displaying all the actions being taken on a daily basis by a pretty decently sized moderation team.

Most posts that get deleted deserve to get deleted. Take a look at Modlog, the latest user who got Nuked was Dr.Exchanger. He posted malware. There's no need to preserve that.

No it's not. Deleting useless data makes the remaining data easier to find.

I think it's because not much changes that much and it might be due to how big the forum is and how often the archive site feels it needs to be snapshotted.

It's very likely there's a queue somewhere that lists how significant sites are (especially time wise) and perhaps a lot of news sites have started taking over as the main thing they consider worth archiving (would be my guess - especially considering the last two days saw about 300 snapshots a day of a Russian news organisation - maybe the number of snapshots relate to how popular they are too on the archive site).

The trash should simply be deleted, but luckily for you, most of the posts you wrote were saved anyway, so this whole thread is completely pointless.


Please stop constantly mentioning the creator and your religious beliefs, because it has nothing to do with the forum or Bitcoin. I don't know what religion you are, but in Christianity, mentioning God's name in vain is a sin and one of God's commandments. If you want to discuss the creator of the universe and similar things, limit yourself to Serious discussion, Off-topic or Politics and Society.

Do you know the reason behind this ? Is it because there are so many pages now ?

Yeah UCY... I'm rightly your support.
I don't see any essence in post deletion - most especially if it's a mega thread that conveyed an instruction/guide or rules pe-say. Alright...now I've learnt alot behind closed doors, without asking too much questions and that had been made possible with the help of Old threads; those autographs on black, fine prints from peeps i didn't even meet, that was left in here to keep telling their stories and rekindling the legacies after them; some of which had been plunge below the bowls of some bottomless abyss, beneath us all., Shouldn't be reprehended... THEY CAN'T TALK ANYMORE but those words would stand to attest for them and also, teach new toddlers what the forum ONCE was like.
I'm not saying that mods shouldn't do away with some unwarranted/ absurd post( that's their jurisdiction and I see 'em as being imperative) but even the slightest, constructive fact (gimmick or not) should be Allowed to stand the test of time. ONE DAY, NEWBIES WILL LIVE TO GAIN PROFOUND KNOWLEDGE FROM MY HISTORY.

Sandra 💇

No. Most archive sites do as you say but archive.org seems to function differently. Iirc it's attached to a US state library and tries to collect as much online information and as much literature/facts as they can.

I had a quick look at 2015 and if you search for the snapshots they take of the forum you should be taken to the landing (/main) page where you can then browse the site as it loaded for them on that day.

In case it needs to be said, don't try logging in as that feature won't work and it's an unnecessary risk.

Doesn't archive.org (and other archiving websites) archive a webpage only if someone requests that? As far as I know, they don't take snapshot regularly.
It's possible that a webpage has been archived more than 100 times while another webpage has been never archived.

archive.org used to take daily and then weekly snapshots of the forum's pages. Now I think it only does it every few months.

You can't delete your own thread if it's already had one view (unless you're a Moderator) I'm fairly certain this is the same for self moderated threads (the op can be edited to del or ~ as it sometimes is and the thread can also be moved to archival).

There are other sites mentioned above that archive posts too.

There have been instances in the past where a Moderator has deleted a large and significant thread before (I can only think of one example and it's because the op moved the thread to an irrelevant board and used a bunch of alts to report it). It wasn't possible to bring it back though as posts had been wiped from the database and were inaccessible.

Thank you! I really value his/her contributions alot. One of my favorites.

Just use the third party sites like https://loyce.club/. It has a area for you to look at unedited and deleted posts https://loyce.club/archive/posts/. You can search it might member id or post id. If posts were not deleted this forum would be over run with spam more then it is now.

I do not think topics are moved any where when they are deleted but some mods might send it to the archival board instead of deleting it if it has some historic value but is getting spammed. I think they lock topics to.

This includes those who self-mod their threads to be able to delete comments made by others.... And possibly those who delete their own threads together with people's posts... I wonder if the latter is even possible, as I have noticed couple of times that threads can't be deleted after awhile.

Why exactly I'm writing this you may ask, well because I prefer to have my posts immutable and the record preserved for the sake of posterity or just so that very valuable information is not deleted or even altered.  If it becomes necessary to delete/change a post, we should atleast have a dublicate that is undeleted/unchanged. It could be archived, unpublished, push it somewhere anyone who is interested could access, push the deleted dublicate to the owner's inbox after one has been deleted, etc.  From what I can tell, this forum handles much of deleted posts in similar manner. But how about threads? Are there sections they are sent to after they're deleted? I think there should be, assuming there aren't yet, so that those who have post they considered valuable can have them saved for the future use.

I honestly don't believe in deleting posts without leaving their duplicate/copies behind. I think the only time I strongly considered deleting people's posts/comments was when I self-modereted couple of my threads, and I would have even archived deleted comments on sites I use for archiving posts/records, then post the links to the archived posts to my self-moderated threads for the future just incase they are needed by anyone for good purposes, like to investigate if the posts were justly deleted, if they of any use etc.

Here are couple of things to know about posts that do not deserve to be wiped off record...they could be used to save lives, they could actually be great contents of historic values etc. Wiping them off records is akin to primitive tribes/people burning great books in the old days because they are afraid of the truth  or don't want to be enlightened for good. Books that make societies better/good must never be destroyed. I'm sure everyone will agree with me that the destroyers of rare, good and very useful things like that deserve punishment. Well, I can guarantee you they are punished for the destruction whether by man or not. So, we should avoid wiping things that could be of great benefit to us/society off record so we don't get punished.
I have had few of my posts deleted in the past...in one of the posts I spoke about "post deletion" ... It was probably deleted and later restored by a forum administrator then moved to Meta from off topic section, or maybe it was just straightly moved to meta (from off topic section) then I assumed it was deleted when I couldn't find it in the off-topic section...i later noticed it was in Meta section. If that post was deleted and later restored, I  commend the one who restored it. I thought an admin with high privilege could have made that decision. I have noticed a superior admin made decision like that or atleast promised to restore post of a forum member who probably don't deserve having the post deleted. If you are reading, consider going through a post of mine that was deleted in off-topic. In it, I gave conditions to work with anyone... part of which include respect of my beliefs, like belief in a CREATOR of the whole  Universe/existence and Mankind. my future coworkers was meant to know that with the CREATOR nothing is impossible... Atleast this will help him/her stay strong when hard-to-believe things begin to happen when we work together as team. To cut this short, the post may have eventually been deleted, probably last year or early this year. I looked for it to share it with someone I was discussing a project with when he started saying things that shouldn't be uttered about my CREATOR and my faith. It will be nice if the post is restored because I intended to use it as part of my Terms and conditions for working with anyone. It was probably deleted as I could not find it when I needed it.


I will very much appreciate it if you consider preserving all deleted posts, assuming this is not done already. Maybe email them to their owners if you are worried about preserving garbage atall in your storage space.

---

Post Edit History:
Last edited: 20:30 GMT, Nov 15 2022
Post before the edit can be found here: https://archive.ph/3217N