transaction stuck in the mempool | Bitcointalksearch.org

Johndric2021

newbie

Activity: 6

Merit: 4

Quote from: o_e_l_e_o on April 01, 2021, 03:54:29 PM

Quote from: Johndric2021 on April 01, 2021, 03:20:52 PM

Yes “1AaE9A5pF6L5J2aYa2TdeDfmCQqNfD7aEz” is the change address, I used Android electrum wallet.

Electrum for Android does not have coin control features. If those are the only funds left on the wallet, then any transaction you make will include them. If they are not the only funds on the wallet, then to pick specifically them to be included in a transaction you will need to import your seed phrase to Electrum desktop client available from: https://electrum.org/#download. Make sure to verify your download before you install it!

Quote from: Johndric2021 on April 01, 2021, 03:20:52 PM

When I observe the mempool on their site sometimes the rate goes down to 30 sats / vbyte, 20 sats / vbyte and even 8sats / vbyte, at these rates I can do the CPFP with what is found on the change address?

I'm not sure where you are looking at the mempool, but it is incorrect. For the last several hours, the minimum fee required to be included in a block has been around 70 sats/vbyte. See: https://mempool.space/

I 1-input-1-output legacy transaction will be around 190 vbytes. Adding that to your two previous transactions, and assuming you spend the 19,693 sats you can spend from that address on a fee, your total will be 1047 vbytes paying 25,617 sats, which will work out to 24.5 sats/vbyte, which is nowhere near the required level.

Thank you for your advice, I did what you said and it finally worked, I did the CPFP "6fed3737ab66630899c3d93462aaacdbd3b03626b86d9f870434c12a639d47d6" with 103sat / vbyte this allowed me to have an effective rate of 24.4sat/vbyte and that at allowed to confirme all my other stuck transactions. The method works thank you

Here are the screenshots on the mempool site before and after confirmation

https://prnt.sc/1124frs

https://prnt.sc/1124hfv

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18748

Quote from: Johndric2021 on April 01, 2021, 03:20:52 PM

Yes “1AaE9A5pF6L5J2aYa2TdeDfmCQqNfD7aEz” is the change address, I used Android electrum wallet.

Electrum for Android does not have coin control features. If those are the only funds left on the wallet, then any transaction you make will include them. If they are not the only funds on the wallet, then to pick specifically them to be included in a transaction you will need to import your seed phrase to Electrum desktop client available from: https://electrum.org/#download. Make sure to verify your download before you install it!

Quote from: Johndric2021 on April 01, 2021, 03:20:52 PM

When I observe the mempool on their site sometimes the rate goes down to 30 sats / vbyte, 20 sats / vbyte and even 8sats / vbyte, at these rates I can do the CPFP with what is found on the change address?

I'm not sure where you are looking at the mempool, but it is incorrect. For the last several hours, the minimum fee required to be included in a block has been around 70 sats/vbyte. See: https://mempool.space/

I 1-input-1-output legacy transaction will be around 190 vbytes. Adding that to your two previous transactions, and assuming you spend the 19,693 sats you can spend from that address on a fee, your total will be 1047 vbytes paying 25,617 sats, which will work out to 24.5 sats/vbyte, which is nowhere near the required level.

dunfida

legendary

Activity: 3122

Merit: 1140

Quote from: Johndric2021 on March 31, 2021, 10:00:53 PM

please have anyone experienced this situation ?, I chose 10sat / byte and I see transactions of 10sat / bytes, 9sat / bytes and even lower being included in blocks but mine is ignored for 2 days now. I am only observing the mempool but I do not understand anything about my case, someone has already experienced this.

https://prnt.sc/1116axk

Txid: c2218ef08179c40cb1c740268c8b8c0c75145f7817b686487d1ebee86598a045

You would need to wait up and based off on your screenshot where a 10sat/byte block had been already confirmed then thats the time when the network does have low fee

and when it surges or shall we say that the price rise up that high once again then your transaction would really be still in pending because miners would eventually priority
those transaction with higher fee and as long those transactions do keep piling up then theres no other option for you to do but only to wait up.

Johndric2021

newbie

Activity: 6

Merit: 4

Yes “1AaE9A5pF6L5J2aYa2TdeDfmCQqNfD7aEz” is the change address, I used Android electrum wallet. When I observe the mempool on their site sometimes the rate goes down to 30 sats / vbyte, 20 sats / vbyte and even 8sats / vbyte, at these rates I can do the CPFP with what is found on the change address?

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18748

Quote from: Johndric2021 on April 01, 2021, 10:10:00 AM

I had tried the RBF they told me insufficient funds.

Your transaction is not flagged as opted in to RBF, so you will not be able to use RBF.

Quote from: Johndric2021 on April 01, 2021, 10:10:00 AM

can I use this unconfirmed amount from the change address to make a CPFP? If it is possible explain to me how to do it please?

Yes. First you'll need to let us know which address is the change (I would guess 1AaE9A5pF6L5J2aYa2TdeDfmCQqNfD7aEz, but I may be wrong), and also let us know which wallet software you are using. You'll also need to be aware that with the current fee rate for a fast transaction sitting at around 70 sats/vbyte, there is not enough bitcoin on that address to successfully boost the fee rate of the 3 transactions combined to the level required for a fast confirmation, and you would need to also spend additional coins from another address (which would further increase the size, and therefore price, of your CPFP transaction).

Johndric2021

newbie

Activity: 6

Merit: 4

Thank you for the explanation if I understand correctly this is the first transaction that blocks me. The worst part is that the change address is also part of the second transaction and also awaits confirmation, can I use this unconfirmed amount from the change address to make a CPFP? If it is possible explain to me how to do it please? I had tried the RBF they told me insufficient funds.

dkbit98

legendary

Activity: 2212

Merit: 7064

Quote from: Johndric2021 on March 31, 2021, 10:00:53 PM

please have anyone experienced this situation ?, I chose 10sat / byte and I see transactions of 10sat / bytes, 9sat / bytes and even lower being included in blocks but mine is ignored for 2 days now. I am only observing the mempool but I do not understand anything about my case, someone has already experienced this.

https://prnt.sc/1116axk

Txid: c2218ef08179c40cb1c740268c8b8c0c75145f7817b686487d1ebee86598a045

It is still unconfirmed but If you are not in a hurry just wait for this weekend and in Saturday or Sunday your transaction will probably be confirmed.

If you need faster confirmation and if you used replace-by-fee, you can pay higher fee following this guide I posted few days ago and use increase fee option in Electrum.

hv_

legendary

Activity: 2534

Merit: 1055

Clean Code and Scale

There are some discussions here

https://dlive.tv/p/freedomain+TmbsRHlMR

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18748

Quote from: Lucius on April 01, 2021, 05:35:36 AM

I do not believe that the situation with mempool will improve to the extent that 2 sat/byte transactions will get a chance to confirm.

It doesn't need to. It only needs to improve to the situation where 6.9 sats/vbyte transactions start to confirm. When miners consider CPFP transactions, they consider the effective fee rate of all the transactions they would have to mine. The combined size and fee of OP's two transactions together works out to a total fee rate of 6.9 sats/vbyte as I explained above, and so the 2 sat/vbyte transaction would still be mined at this level to permit the miner in question to also mine the 10 sat/vbyte transaction.

Quote from: Lucius on April 01, 2021, 05:35:36 AM

Currently, such transactions are as much as 90+ vMB from the tip

As long as the first transaction is not purged from the mempool (and at present it isn't as I can still find it on most block explorers), then it makes no difference how far from the tip it is when considered in isolation.

Lucius

legendary

Activity: 3234

Merit: 5637

Blackjack.fun-Free Raffle-Join&Win $50🎲

Quote from: bakasabo on April 01, 2021, 03:45:40 AM

FYI I had a transaction with 5sat/fee and waited around 40 days to get it confirmed. I bet you will have to wait for 10+ days to get it confirmed.

I do not believe that the situation with mempool will improve to the extent that 2 sat/byte transactions will get a chance to confirm. Currently, such transactions are as much as 90+ vMB from the tip, and I don't remember the last time I saw a transaction with such a low fee pass (unless it's a miner transaction).

bakasabo

legendary

Activity: 2492

Merit: 1215

You dont have to worry about your transaction. It is not stuck, it is waiting for confirmation. It will be either confirmed, or dropped and returned to your wallet. You wont lose your money in any case.

FYI I had a transaction with 5sat/fee and waited around 40 days to get it confirmed. I bet you will have to wait for 10+ days to get it confirmed.

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18748

Quote from: Haunebu on April 01, 2021, 03:17:40 AM

You chose a low fee which is why you need to stay patient for it to get confirmed.

He actually chose a perfectly reasonable fee, and there are multiple times since he broadcast the transaction three days ago where it would have confirmed, it not for the unconfirmed parent.

Quote from: Haunebu on April 01, 2021, 03:17:40 AM

You could always use TX accelerators to get your TX confirmed asap in my opinion. Check the below link out(Very helpful).

Of all the accelerators listed on your link, the only free transaction accelerator which still works is ViaBTC. However, they only accept transactions which do not have any unconfirmed parents, and so will not accept OP's transaction.

As I stated above, the only realistic option available to OP here is for either him to perform a CPFP with his change, or the recipient to perform a CPFP.

Haunebu

hero member

Activity: 3178

Merit: 977

www.Crypto.Games: Multiple coins, multiple games

You chose a low fee which is why you need to stay patient for it to get confirmed. Due to the current high TX fee and long TX time situation, you might need to wait for a couple of days.

You could always use TX accelerators to get your TX confirmed asap in my opinion. Check the below link out(Very helpful).

https://bitcointalksearch.org/topic/bitcoin-transaction-accelerator-free-and-paid-list-4466298

hugeblack

legendary

Activity: 2702

Merit: 4002

Next time, use a wallet that supports RBF so that you have the ability to increase fees if you want to rush to obtain confirmations.
You have no choice but to wait or use CPFP by paying a higher fee more than 10 sats/vbyte on average for your three transactions.

learn more about RBF and CPFP ----> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zL9Nu39qft4

o_e_l_e_o

legendary

Activity: 2268

Merit: 18748

The problem here OP is that you are spending unconfirmed inputs.

You transaction includes 0.00014 BTC which comes from this transaction: https://blockchair.com/bitcoin/transaction/84e6a94368cc2492158a1c26fda982acfb98570915bbb83edb7a50b92ef09b3e

The above transaction has been unconfirmed for almost a month. It has a fee of only 2 sats/vbyte. Your new transaction cannot confirm until this first transaction does, which means that the 10 sats/vbyte you are paying for your current transaction is being weighed down, so to speak, by the low fee being paid for the unconfirmed transaction it is based on.

The combined size of both transaction is 338 + 519 = 857 vbytes. The combined fee is 704 + 5220 = 5924 sats. This gives a total fee rate of 6.9 sats/vbyte. Once the mempool empties down to this level, then both your transactions will confirm.

Since neither of the transactions are marked as RBF then you cannot use that to help you here. However, I notice that your new transaction has two outputs, so presumably one of them is your change. You can use that change to perform a child-pays-for-parent (CPFP) to speed things up if you are desperate for a confirmation, but if it were me I would just be patient.

bitmover

legendary

Activity: 2352

Merit: 6089

bitcoindata.science

Quote from: Johndric2021 on March 31, 2021, 10:36:49 PM

I carried out the transaction with Android electrum wallet, the RBF box is checked in the parameters but when I carried out the transaction I did not choose it is an rbf I rather choose no. this is my mistake ? all the funds in my wallet are on the same address and therefore when I try the RBF I am told insufficient funds

You didn't make a mistake, unless you are really in hurry.

I checked mempool.space, and your transaction will probably be confirmed in a few blocks. ETA is about 40minutes

https://mempool.space/tx/c2218ef08179c40cb1c740268c8b8c0c75145f7817b686487d1ebee86598a045

However, lots of transactions with 10 sat byte were confirmed in the previous blocks. You might have some broadcasting problems. Just to be safe, I rebroadcasted your transaction here:
https://blockchair.com/broadcast
https://blockchain.info/pushtx

Johndric2021

newbie

Activity: 6

Merit: 4

I carried out the transaction with Android electrum wallet, the RBF box is checked in the parameters but when I carried out the transaction I did not choose it is an rbf I rather choose no. this is my mistake ? all the funds in my wallet are on the same address and therefore when I try the RBF I am told insufficient funds

hd49728

legendary

Activity: 2044

Merit: 1018

Not your keys, not your coins!

Your transaction will get confirmation soon with the fee at 10 sat/vbyte. It is on the top of mempool and in very first priority to be chosen and confirmed.

https://blockchair.com/bitcoin/transaction/c2218ef08179c40cb1c740268c8b8c0c75145f7817b686487d1ebee86598a045
You can see the Mempool: Priority: 4805/54073. It is good.
Your transaction is not marked as Replace-by-Fee: NO.

Which wallet you use to broadcast that transaction?
If it is a non custodial wallet, please check settings and choose Replace by fee: Turn it from NO to YES. In this case, you are lucky but in other cases, you might need to bump fee for your transactions and Yes for Replace by Fee is required.

How to cancel Bitcoin transaction?. That topic can help you to practice your Replace by Fee in the future.

Johndric2021

newbie

Activity: 6

Merit: 4

please have anyone experienced this situation ?, I chose 10sat / byte and I see transactions of 10sat / bytes, 9sat / bytes and even lower being included in blocks but mine is ignored for 2 days now. I am only observing the mempool but I do not understand anything about my case, someone has already experienced this.

https://prnt.sc/1116axk

Txid: c2218ef08179c40cb1c740268c8b8c0c75145f7817b686487d1ebee86598a045

Topic: transaction stuck in the mempool (Read 220 times)